6 ms·
And yet, me with my tiny gasoline generator has absolutely no incentive to use it at times of peak demand. When any market gives no incentive for most particip
by londons_explore 3y ago
And yet, me with my tiny gasoline generator has absolutely no incentive to use it at times of peak demand.
When any market gives no incentive for most participants to resolve any supply/demand imbalance, then shortages are sure to happen from time to time.
Electricity isn't even a market where people can 'panic buy' like toilet paper.
- isoprophlex 3y agoI have a dynamic pricing contract, prices are generally around or slightly below fixed market rates, but when it's sunny or windy I get power for free, or better. Got paid to charge my car today. I like it, because it makes me more mindful of the e-grid (also free power) So, it is possible to have some force changing consumer behavior. It all depends on sane legislation, allowing a system like this to exist.
- the_third_wave 3y agoWe have a dynamic (hourly rates) contract as well and well and we sometimes see negative electricity prices. This does not mean electricity ends up being free since there is also the transmission charge, energy tax, renewable energy surcharge and value added tax on all of these to pay. Do you actually get paid to use power, i.e. do you not have to pay any of the mentioned charges?
- 0cf8612b2e1e 3y agoIf they do get 100% free, this continually reraises a question of mine: outside of crypto mining, is there anything a consumer can do to capture benefit from free electricity? Low efficiency synthesis of ethanol, hydrogen, carbon capture, desalination, precious mineral enrichment from seawater? With net metering rates tanking, I would love to see some way to productively capture spare juice. The duck curve is not going anywhere.
- londons_explore 3y agoIf in a cold climate, heat the earth under your house. Then, that earth slowly gives its heat back to you over the coming months (soil is quite a poor thermal conductor, so the heat hangs around underground for a really long time) Obscenely powerful heaters are rather cheap. Assuming prices only go negative pretty rarely, you really want 100 kilowatts or more of heaters under your house to get as much free power as possible.
- willglynn 3y agoResidential power here for single family homes -- the type which could reasonably do what you suggest -- is almost always single phase 120/240V. As an upper bound, let's consider 400A service. (Most homes have services smaller than 400A, and even 400A service is typically delivered to a pair of smaller panels to keep conductor and busbar sizes manageable.) Such heaters would be considered continuous loads, reducing the 400A service to 320A of current. Resistive heaters are a linear load, so we can multiply 240V * 320A to get 76.8 kW at maximum. Hitting 76 kW is wildly impractical. Exceeding 100 kW is nonsense.
- Hextinium 3y agoEasiest is probably using your house as a thermal battery and just temporarily dumping energy into cooling or heating down to a set temp and then when allowing your house to normalize when prices go up. Alternatively, charge your own batteries and load balance. It's boring but effective. You could have your computer queued to run high energy ops when free, queue training models, compiling, etc. Which would generate a lot of heat, thus cranking the AC. I could see how this could easily 10x your power draw for a few thousand dollars and work in the background.
- isoprophlex 3y agoOften the base price is negative but you still pay some for taxes etc. Yesterday, net price was also negative because the base price was so ridiculously low...
- dv_dt 3y agoIt’s possible, but in California for instance, I see large utilities constantly placing blockages in the way via regulatory capture of the PUC.
- everybodyknows 3y agoIt's called a "TOU" service plan, and I've had one for several years now, through San Diego G&E, which is a large utility.
- dv_dt 3y agoIt’s been gutted for future customers - https://solarrights.org/savecaliforniasolar/ https://solarrights.org/savecaliforniasolar/
- ThatPlayer 3y agoHome solar installs (and that change) would be NEM, not TOU. California had a mandate to move everyone to TOU a while back, though some might still be on the old plans.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dv_dt 3y agoAs a residential electricity user there is little reason for me to be on tou unless I also have an Nem for installed solar. All the tou might do is expose me to inconvenience and high costs.
- ThatPlayer 3y agoThat really depends on your usages. The extreme examples are if you have an electric car that you can charge overnight instead of peak hours, or work any shift that's not 9-5 so that you avoid the 6-9pm peak hours. And of course the whole point is to incentivize changing usages to using less power during peak hours, which it does better than the old plans. There's always going to be a slight inconvenience to get everyone to change habits.
- nonfamous 3y agoI had a similar contract when I lived in IL, and I also liked it and it made me more conscious of my energy usage patterns. But there was always this niggling concern that the price could spike to 200x like it did in Texas, without me being able to react. Regulation to cap the peak rate would help allay consumer fears, IMO, while still offering ample profit potential to providers.
- 0cf8612b2e1e 3y agoEven with a cap, it feels like it would just take one freak occurrence (power plant/transformer/blizzard) meltdown to erase any potential savings from subscribing to dynamic pricing.
- zdragnar 3y agoNah, just switch over to a generator for your bare essential needs and hunker down for a bit. You can't go into a dynamic environment and only plan for upsides.
- jltsiren 3y agoFixed pricing is basically dynamic pricing + insurance. In the expected case, you pay more over any period of time if you take the insurance. If you can afford the risks, going without insurance tends to be cheaper.
- everybodyknows 3y agoIn California TOU plans, there are caps on all three of: 1. Price per kWh - $1 last I checked 2. Hours per day at max price - ~9 3. Days per year max price charged - ~10 Even in the worst case, not too scary.
- 0cf8612b2e1e 3y agoWith the horror stories in Texas, I was assuming significantly worse caps. Regardless, I have very little consumption I can time shift to off-peak hours (laundry? dishwasher?), so dynamic pricing would unlikely ever work out for me.
- the_third_wave 3y ago> Electricity isn't even a market where people can 'panic buy' like toilet paper. People can "panic buy" generators, and have been doing so for a while. With solar panels on the roof for when the sun is available and some alternative source like your generator (cheap to buy, expensive to use) or batteries (expensive to buy, cheap to use) for when it is not and power has failed you can be mostly energy independent.
- sacnoradhq 3y agoThat happened in NorCal in 2019. There were no generators to be had south of Chico, CA that summer. Had to go halfway to Redding to a random Home Depot that didn't have a large customer base. When you need a generator because PG&E decided to have a PSPS for a week or 2 without warning, then you need it immediately. It's not a panic purchase when it's an emergency purchase of inelastic necessity, not hoarding of 4000 rolls of toilet paper. Gasoline generators are a PITA. Most of them require frequent oil changes. And floating neutral generators generally won't work well with GFI circuits because they easily see an imbalance in current across neutral and to the ground path. If you want your generator to be safe and work with GFI, you'll have to use a bonded one and ground it. Most residential solar sets in California lack battery backup capacity and do not generate power in the absence of grid power "for safety". This is because most homeowners are uninformed consumers and don't know what options they need. It's worth getting a subpanel, moving critical loads to them, and having a 3-way ATS with solar-batteries-inverter, grid tie, and an autostart natural gas generator.
- WalterBright 3y agoThe trick with a gas generator is to have an electrician install an interlock on your electric panel along with a hookup to your generator. Then it's a snap to switch over to the generator, and start it. The only trouble is that gives no indication when the power comes back on. So there you are, generator blasting away, while power is restored. Leave a couple circuits always connected to the line power, and hook those to a radio or a light so you know when the line is back up. P.S. if you get a generator with an electric starter, odds are good the battery will be dead. The trick is to add a couple power posts to it, so you can jump start it with your car.
- alar44 3y ago[dead]
- PopAlongKid 3y ago>me with my tiny gasoline generator has absolutely no incentive to use it at times of peak demand. You have an incentive when the power to your residence or place of business goes out.
- WalterBright 3y agoI have a small generator, which gets me by when the power goes out 2-3 times a year, once for 2 weeks.
- neilknowsbest 3y agoI agree with your general argument (retail consumers overwhelmingly do not face instantaneous price signals). However, I think you can "panic buy" electricity. I live in a place with unreliable electricity. On hot days, I'm more inclined to cool my house with the AC earlier/colder than I would if I could absolutely count on the electricity being available. If the power goes out, at least my house is cool for a short while.