2 ms·
In general the answer seemed to be something like: yeah, mostly, but not always, and the winners don’t always have a perfectly unified voice, so this can be mit
by bee_rider 3y ago
In general the answer seemed to be something like: yeah, mostly, but not always, and the winners don’t always have a perfectly unified voice, so this can be mitigated to a great extent by careful study. Which seems like a fine answer although not super enlightening.
The bit that stuck with me was a little aside near the beginning.
> Whether we like it or not, we view the past from a modern standpoint, privileging (consciously or otherwise) the interests and ideals of the world we know. As a result, we tend to treat developments towards modernity as natural – and disparage the apparent dead ends that stood in its path.
I think modern values are pretty good. But we sit on a branch in a big tree which history has explored stochastically. The idea that, going back, some figures could be seen as good or bad not because of the fundamentals of their deeds, or because of the propaganda (good or ill) recorded about them, but because the just mismatch with modern values is interesting…
But I dunno, I can think of any, I must just be too throughly soaked through with modern values.