5 ms·
The earth naturally sequesters carbon on its own, we are simply vastly outpacing that process. So no we don’t need artificial carbon sequestration to hit even
by Retric 3y ago
The earth naturally sequesters carbon on its own, we are simply vastly outpacing that process. So no we don’t need artificial carbon sequestration to hit even preindustrial levels again.
Carbon sequestration is unfortunately more of a scam than a practical process. Without actual discouraging the burning of fossil fuels people aren’t going to simply stop on their own and if we can’t even get that far nobody is willing to pay for any kind of meaningful rather than token carbon sequestration.
- adrianN 3y agoNatural sequestration is a very slow process. If we want to avoid tipping points we shouldn’t rely on it alone.
- Retric 3y agoSlow is debatable, it’s something like 3 orders of magnitude faster than all the current artificial carbon sequestration systems in operation right now combined.
- adrianN 3y agoA sizeable fraction of the atmospheric carbon only gets sequestered by geological processes that take thousands of years. Comparing it to the basically nonexistent artificial sequestration is not very helpful.
- Retric 3y agoSeems like a reasonable benchmark to say if we spend X00 billion per year we can double the rate of long term sequestration or whatever. It places things in a fairly clear cost vs benefit calculation.
- specialist 3y ago> more of a scam than a practical process Elites and grifters always co-opt and subvert any and all reform, revolution, rebellion. That hardly absolves us of our collective moral obligation. We must protect and provide for (present and) future humans. Despite the obstacles. > people aren’t going to simply stop on their own On the other hand, CDR determines the floor price of removing that pollution. Less arm-wavy than current proposals for determining carbon taxes amounts. Anywho, I'd rather try than not try. YMMV.
- masklinn 3y ago> The earth naturally sequesters carbon on its own, we are simply vastly outpacing that process.So no we don’t need artificial carbon sequestration to hit even preindustrial levels again. Debatable: not only have human activities taken over huge swathes of land which previously sequestered carbon (aka forests), we have been releasing huge amounts of carbon which had been sequestered through processes which basically can not work anymore, at least not naturally. There is no millions of years of trees being buried wholesale because fungi haven’t evolved peroxisade yet, because they did, a while ago, and so dead trees rot and release their carbon.
- Retric 3y agoCarbon sequestration down to a tiny fraction of atmospheric carbon has happened all the way back when phytoplankton first showed up causing the Oxygen Holocaust and has been steady since then. Volcanic activity releases an enormous quantity of net carbon over time, but that carbon doesn’t accumulate in the atmosphere. The misconception around the lack of fungi resulting in massive sequestration is that carbon would have been sequestered either way. It was similarly limited by the amount of carbon available per year from volcanic activity, what changed was the location of carbon storage not the net rate it was stored.
- masklinn 3y ago> Volcanic activity releases an enormous quantity of net carbon over time, but that carbon doesn’t accumulate in the atmosphere. Volcanic activity releases nearly 2 orders of magnitude less carbon than humanity does. That’s a much easier amount to cycle. > The misconception around the lack of fungi resulting in massive sequestration is that carbon would have been sequestered either way. By the process of magic? Because if that’s your hypothesis you need to explain why that magic was overwhelmingly more active during the Carboniferous than at any other epoch.
- Retric 3y ago> By the process of magic. No, by other carbon sinks like dead ocean algae. > Volcanic activity releases nearly 2 orders of magnitude less carbon than humanity does But they have been around far more than just 2 orders of magnitude as long. Between the great oxygen event and the emergence of woody plants volcanic processes releasing ~100,000x as much all of humanity across all of human history yet levels didn’t hit 90% CO2. Further woody plants didn’t increase the rate of carbon release by volcanoes so across such long timescales they had zero net effect on total carbon sequestration. So, across long timescales it was on average 100% of all new carbon before they showed up and it remained 100% of all new carbon afterwards. What changed was where the carbon ended up, the ocean floor sees subduction into the mantle, woody plants stuck around on the surface. Now, yes on human timescales these things seem slow but net zero + 1,000 years really will have a noticeable impact.