6 ms·
Why people reward innate talent over hard work
- meany 3y agoThe very best performers have both talent and incredible work ethic.
- readthenotes1 3y agoThat's the story of basketball greats, at least.
- version_five 3y agoI've never heard this before and I'd say the exact opposite is true. A good example is that jobs like consulting, finance, and FAANG all have interview processes and selection criteria to hire type A people who will ignore pareto optimization and eke out the extra 1% quality for 50% more effort to get themselves to the top of the class. And I've never heard of anywhere that's looking for genius slackers, that's absolutely the worst profile to have.
- onlyrealcuzzo 3y agoAnd yet the people who work 50% harder to eek out 1% quality don't get promoted, and the people who do nothing but game the system for promotions get promoted. So, I'd say the opposite is true.
- viscanti 3y agoAre the people gaming the system being rewarded for innate talent? Or is it hard work at gaming the system (presumably if it was easy to game the system everyone would do it)?
- francisofascii 3y agoHmmm I would argue you have to have a certain personality type to game the system. So that falls more into innate talent.
- lloeki 3y agovalue systems come into play and many a mind revile at the idea of gaming the system, however easy it would be for them.
- User23 3y agoI think physical attractiveness, both male and female, plays a far larger role in promotion decisions than anyone realizes, including those making the decision. The halo effect is very real. This leads to a case where you have persons who are, in some sense, gaming the system and might not even know that they are.
- cardy31 3y agoYeah and even getting into FAANG is often about gaming the interview system anyway. I don’t think FAANG really manages to select the top 1% of hard workers.
- wtetzner 3y agoHow do you game the interview system? Practice leetcode problems a lot? Sounds like a lot of work.
- dasil003 3y agoYes, and interviewing in general. You think that’s a lot of work to get your foot in the door and $500k+ in a relatively cushy salaried position and top tech brand name on your resume?
- wtetzner 3y agoYou also need to do multiple system design interviews. Yes, you might be able to game it, but I doubt you could game it and still be an incompetent programmer. You also wouldn't be able to keep that job very long, given the way performance reviews tend to be done. They probably don't have the top 1% of hard workers, but getting and staying there almost certainly requires a certain amount of hard work.
- meany 3y agoWhen I interview people I tell them, 'You can work long, hard, or smart, but at Amazon.com you can't choose two out of three," Bezos wrote in the 1997 letter.
- hotpotamus 3y agoAnd as Bezos gazes down from space at his domain, I'm sure he appreciates your dedication, or probably would if he knew your name/serial number. I assume he can monitor all from his super-yacht as well, but somehow it just doesn't feel like hard work when done from a super-yacht.
- xnickb 3y agoI guess he thinks he is the smart working kind then?
- fauria 3y agoI'll quote Larry Wall here: "We will encourage you to develop the three great virtues of a programmer: laziness, impatience, and hubris."
- hgsgm 3y agoThose are in service of "getting things done" as Spolsky wrote, not navel gazing.
- l__l 3y agoI genuinely think this is a UK/US thing (limiting to those countries because that's the limited experience I have); in the UK this is absolutely true. There is a definite cultural thing going on where people play down how much effort they put in to things. It's definitely 'uncool', throughout school, higher education and in the workplace, to be super keen. Contrast to the US: American colleagues I've had have all agreed that it's kind of the reverse on that side of the pond. I've heard people brag about the hours they've put in to work; that would be a complete embarrassment over here, especially if the work turns out not to be top-tier.
- oh_sigh 3y agoFalse. I have worked at three FAANGs and I am a type B if anything. Having said that, I'm probably under leveled compared to what people think I am, because I don't want to give up my ample free time. If I'm making 400k/yr and work 30hrs/week, why would I want to make say 480k/yr and work 40hrs/week?
- Veuxdo 3y agoI'm wondering if it could be [the assumption that] those with natural talent have more untapped potential than those who have already "worked hard" for their achievements.
- newsclues 3y agoEver met a hard working but dumb person? It can result in a lot of poorly done work that needs to be fixed or redone. They can create more problems than they fix. Hard work cannot overcome extreme lack of talent.
- jyscao 3y agoYes indeed. Had a coworker at an old job who worked harder than me, but I'd always have to go back and fix his buggy code. For every feature he added, he'd cause a regression somewhere else. I legit felt bad for the guy. Also one of the few people I've known who was let go (after 3 months) for incompetence.
- ResearchCode 3y agoI would feel sorry for him too, because it sounds like the real problem was with your testing and code review process, not your very new co-worker. Why are your reviewers accepting broken patches?
- duk 3y agoThey are slow so they have to work hours to complete what would take a smart person minutes. So they can “look” like they are working harder. But you are right. Now that I think of it, never met a dumb hard working person. That’s why I do not think AI will make any dumb person smarter by “personalize” learning experience. How many dumb people do you think are using ChatGPT to satisfy their “curiosity”?
- waboremo 3y agoI question your definition of hard working, because to me hard working isn't just about being busy or looking busy. It's about getting the task done. For a task to be done, it has to be done correctly. It's like calling someone a hard working baker, but all they're doing is tossing flour into the oven. That's not hard working: that's just dumb.
- newsclues 3y agoYou can bake inedible bread. You can build a house that will fall apart. You can code a website with security vulnerabilities and bugs. Doing something and doing something well are not the same. But dumb or untalented people can accomplish a task in a substandard manner, and they may not even realize their work is substandard.
- azurenumber 3y agoStatement should be like People reward social skills over hard work.
- adamwong246 3y agoI think you're almost hitting the nail on the head. When we look to add teammates who will add value to our teams, it is often the appearance of value which is more important than the actual value. I suspect this is why we highly value "talent", given that it is easier to telegraph.
- cardy31 3y agoWhen hiring for technical teams, especially in more junior roles, I value someone with good social skills over someone with high technical skills. Technical skills are much easier to teach than social skills.
- ResearchCode 3y agoThat's the opposite of my experience. Talkers are a dime a dozen. Tech talents are a gem and you're very lucky to get them. The few of them will do most of your work.
- ResearchCode 3y agoI rarely see actual "social skills" rewarded.
- Barrin92 3y agoSuccessful people with innate talent and gift downplay that role because it implies noblesse oblige. On display with say tech billionaires who love to stress merit because it frees them from obligations and boosts their ego. Admitting the role of upbringing, genes and just pure luck implies a responsibility to others. That people have a keen sense for innate talent isn't some flawed bias, it's just very common sense recognition of facts. The irony is that we could have much better outcomes for most people if we ditched the egalitarian myth that just frees top performers from responsibility.
- nasmorn 3y agoIt make total sense to me. You can always hope the talented become more industrious and hard working but not that the hard working become more talented. There is no upside.
- omoikane 3y agoA similar idea might be that one can just find someone else to work harder, but one can't easily find another genius. In other words, people who only work hard seem more replaceable, hence the bias to hire or promote people who seemed naturally talented.
- MontyCarloHall 3y agoBecause, by definition, the most extraordinary achievements are only attainable by the small subset of people with the rare, innate ability to accomplish them — that's what makes those achievements literally extra-ordinary. If anyone could have the athleticism of Michael Jordan or the intelligence of von Neumann or the musical ability of Mozart or the artistic ability of Michelangelo through hard work alone, there would be a lot more people with those respective skills, and the skills would no longer be considered extraordinary.
- ResearchCode 3y agoExtraordinary achievements are not rewarded much. A random on Wall Street makes as much or more than a Terence Tao off just an old-money surname.
- MontyCarloHall 3y agoMoney is only one kind of reward. Fame (social capital) is another kind of reward, and in that regard, Terry Tao is far more rewarded than any random Wall Street trader. Some might argue that in the grand scheme of things, fame is a far greater reward than money. They say that you die twice: the first time is when your body passes away, and the second time is when your legacy passes away. The money earned by that trader will be likely be gone within a couple generations [0], but Terence Tao will be a name remembered by many for centuries if not millennia. [0] https://money.com/rich-families-lose-wealth/ https://money.com/rich-families-lose-wealth/
- Planktonne 3y ago> In almost every discipline, success comes from a combination of talent and grit. This is a naive over-simplification; we don't live in a pure meritocracy. All sorts of other factors beyond the personal (talent or grit) have an impact.
- nico 3y agoHard work is also a talent Saw Tom Cruise’s latest stunt video last night When they show you the final stunt cut, it’s very impressive When you watch the process, you realize they started with a super safe basic version of the stunt and practiced incrementally for months/years until they got it right It took a lot of hard work to put it together and do it safely The thing is at first you might think: oh wow, Tom Cruise is so incredibly talented, then when watching the process you might think: oh, it’s just hard work But then when you see how much hard work, you realize: oh, that’s also talent
- vasco 3y agoBeing able to work long and hard is a talent, but people discount how much can be gained by consistently showing up. Putting in the work will _always_ increase your chances of doing well. The worst thing you can do to yourself is convince yourself you are powerless to change your situation.
- waboremo 3y agoGreat summary, and this is also why a lot of people quit their dreams before they even began. It's also why having great parents encourage this consistency at a young age is so powerful, it's not really innate talent anointed by the gods, but decades of consistency. We just see a 20 year old show up and be great at [skill] compared to their counterparts and then label them innately talented, but ignore the years of showing up. It's universally true, Celine Dion started singing when she was 5, Michael Jordan when he was 5. We aren't just talking carelessly singing or mindless games (although it might have felt that way to the child), but serious efforts: Celine for example was encouraged by family to sing at weddings at a young age. She came from a musical family so she was encouraged to compose, work on musical technique, etc. it wasn't random singing but already "professionally" training. For some this is dreadful to hear, if they weren't doing some skill as a child their lives are over. However I would reframe that, it's quite optimistic. You can do what you dream of if you start right now and realize it's going to take years of showing up.
- orbz 3y ago
- Slava_Propanei 3y ago[dead]
- romanhn 3y agoBoth innate talent and hard work are orthogonal to achieving desired outcomes (and you can get there with either). If your talent or efforts are pointing in the wrong direction, you won't get to the outcome, regardless of how well-meaning the intentions might be. If we talk about companies, it's not uncommon to be rewarded for outcomes, vs talent or hard work (a hard pill to swallow for many hard workers, in my experience). This of course requires a system of measuring outcomes, which is a whole 'nother can of worms.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jleyank 3y agoIt’s a combination and it’s been known forever: As Chief of the Army High Command, Hammerstein-Equord oversaw the composition of the German manual on military unit command (Truppenführung), dated 17 October 1933. He conceived of a classification scheme for officers: I distinguish four types. There are clever, hardworking, stupid, and lazy officers. Usually two characteristics are combined. Some are clever and hardworking; their place is the General Staff. The next ones are stupid and lazy; they make up 90 percent of every army and are suited to routine duties. Anyone who is both clever and lazy is qualified for the highest leadership duties, because he possesses the mental clarity and strength of nerve necessary for difficult decisions. One must beware of anyone who is both stupid and hardworking; he must not be entrusted with any responsibility because he will always only cause damage.[32]
- zoogeny 3y agoHere is my uninformed analysis: if your performance is due to pushing yourself to your limits, then you have no room to grow. If similar performance is due to talent and required little effort then you have room to grow. The other cliche we often hear is: never let them see you sweat. In competition, you don't want to give away when you are at the limits of your ability.
- waboremo 3y agoThis analysis doesn't really make sense. You extend your limits due to working at them. This goes for all activities, not just physical sports. Athletes train at their limits every day, actually they train past their limits with the use of technology like oxygen masks.
- zoogeny 3y agoI think your mistake is by considering a single person and not considering the comparison between two individuals. Consider two athletes that can both achieve some specific result, e.g. run a quarter mile in some equal fixed time. The first athlete does so with almost no effort and with very little recovery time while the second athlete does so with clear strain, and significant exhaustion after the test. My contention is that a coach who is forced to choose one of those athletes for advanced training (solely on the information I provided above) may favor the athlete that achieved the equal result with less effort. He can't differentiate them on performance (they got equal time after all) so he will use their perceived effort as a guide. It may not be an accurate decision, but I am suggesting that the coach may reason that the athlete who appears less exhausted could be pushed harder through advanced coaching. It may be assumed (again, incorrectly but somewhat reasonably) that by pushing the first athlete to the same level of exhaustion as experienced by the second athlete, their performance (e.g. the time to finish a quarter mile) may be improved more drastically than pushing the second athlete. This is what I mean when I say "the first athlete appears to have more room to grow". Remember, the article isn't about which athlete can actually improve more, the article is about how we reward and judge other people based on their effort. I'm suggesting we are making a prediction about possible future capabilities in a similar way as my fictional coach.
- mjklin 3y agoDon’t forget the role of chance! “You know what Pasteur said: ‘Chance favors the prepared mind.’ Take one of the chanciest things in the world, like war. Both Kitchener and Frederick the Great, when they were considering a general's qualifications, would always ask, ‘Is he considered lucky?’ It was a perfectly legitimate question, because if he was considered lucky, it meant he was prepared to take advantage of chance.“ - Eric Hoffer
- notacoward 3y agoIn hiring, part of the issue is that the person doing the hiring believes (often mistakenly) that they can inspire hard work, but talent is innate. Kind of like "you can't train height" in sports. Contrary to what some other commenters have immodestly said, interview processes are frequently designed around this assumption and select for talent/potential/whatever. Besides the more obvious problem with this, it tends to perpetuate disparity as the appearance of talent is often more closely tied to circumstance (and sheer luck) more than to actual talent.
- dasil003 3y agoIn order to be successful, ambitious people need to differentiate their actual abilities from external perceptions of those abilities. The hard work you put in maximizes your individual potential, but it doesn't guarantee that your abilities reach any particular bar. That bar is determined externally, and often very subjectively because outcomes often depend on a confluence of factors well beyond one individuals performance. In large scale group environments, like the corporate world, it's even worse because your promotability may depend primarily on the storytelling ability of your boss with tenuous connection to your actual contributions. Many come to this conclusion and focus primarily on optics. This can work to a point, but it can also lead one to lose the plot on ground reality. At this point you are vulnerable to any higher up with a clue coming in, and the higher you go the bigger risk this is because senior management make their bones sniffing out bullshit even when they might not personally have all the details. For that reason I think it's very important to develop hard skills from the ground up, and not focusing primarily on optics from a young age when you don't yet have a deep understanding of how things work. It's much easier to sell quality work than to try paper over a gap in fundamentals.
- liquidpele 3y ago> because senior management make their bones sniffing out bullshit even when they might not personally have all the details. Ahaha, good one. They couldn’t smell shit on their own shoes.
- foogazi 3y agoDoes innate talent exist ? The abilities still have to be applied. Talent is the potential but need the work to realize it. If you believe this then you will price talent + hard work over only hard work
- rowanG077 3y agoI think it's simply that to become the best hard work or talent alone is not enough. You will not become an Olympian just because you work harder then the average person. You will also need to be build different. The problem is that this article makes talent and hard work a dichotomy while it isn't.