3 ms·
By analogy: "We can't fly into space, the propellers will have nothing to push against" "We have rockets for that, they're more expensive but don't have that
by ben_w 3y ago
By analogy:
"We can't fly into space, the propellers will have nothing to push against"
"We have rockets for that, they're more expensive but don't have that limitation."
"I see we're reaching the 'you're holding it wrong' stage with propulsion."
- cookieperson 3y agoI think their point still stands. We have people and bots shilling chatgpt on a minutely cadence all over the internet right now talking about how "it is the same thing as a person" "look at how it is always correct in these complicated cases" then whenever something doesn't work there's mass gas lighting..."you didn't use the latest version!" "You probably engineered a fake prompt so it would fail!" "You just don't know how to use it" To people who understand the technology your reply is fair. But it doesn't account for the millions of people who don't and are spewing manic sentiment about it's capabilities on the regular. A lot of companies adopt this strategy for broken technology because it fosters a cult like group of zealots for a short period of time while they go off and try to fix everything. In my experience it usually doesn't last long.
- ben_w 3y agoThanks! The way you steeled their point was much more convincing than what I had replied to, and made it clear to me what I had overlooked.
- namaria 3y agoFailing to understand that you can't reduce everything to a single vector and claim "this is the worse it's ever gonna be... it's only gonna get better... when it this reaches 10x or 100x what it is now you'll see what it's really capable of" is a perfect analogy in fact for the hype around LLMs. EDIT: found another way in which you're illustrating my point - yeah propellers and LLMs are great for flying under a hard ceiling. We need something entirely different to reach orbit. You can't just tell people to bolt on rockets to propeller driven aircraft, you need to invent something entirely different, like spacecraft.
- usrbinbash 3y agoMaking bigger models and training them to specific tasks != Inventing a class of sequence predictors with a new paradigm.