4 ms·
The US seems especially bad, though. Do other countries do things differently in terms of incentives?
by rayiner 3y ago
The US seems especially bad, though. Do other countries do things differently in terms of incentives?
- moltar 3y agoA subset of services in Ontario, Canada are handled by a private company on a tendered government contract. It’s called Service Ontario, and is sort of a DMV equivalent, but also handles healthcare cards and other daily minutia. http://www.ontario.ca/page/own-private-serviceontario-centre http://www.ontario.ca/page/own-private-serviceontario-centre I’ve used Service Ontario services many times, and they certainly feel like a balanced blend of bureaucratic process and efficiency. It’s certainly an oasis in the desert of dealing with the government.
- bryanrasmussen 3y agoIn Denmark government money is pretty good, especially when taken in with the benefits, for areas like being a social worker. Working in Gov tech is not that great but it isn't bad either, the problem is every gov I have ever seen makes it difficult to fire people and gives lots of benefits to make up for the fact that they don't give money. Why would you work a government job given that it is underpaid unless there were benefits to even it out? And don't say helping people is a benefit, that kind of thing lasts a couple years and then most people burn out on helping people.
- inferiorhuman 3y agoThe pay scales are all public info for public sector jobs (in California at least). sfgov.org/careers or something should point you in the right direction, most of the tech positions I've seen listed fall under 104x or 106x. However (and I don't think this is unique to SF) most of the tech jobs are listed as civil service exempt. So it's kinda like USDS. No civil service exam required, mediocre pay, next to none of the typical civil service perks. Why would you work a government job given that it is underpaid unless there were benefits to even it out? To make the world a better place. Seriously. When I was starting out I went through the whole process with the SF school district. The folks I interviewed with seemed quite decent and were also realistic about the work environment. The top pay band was not far enough off from private sector pay to. matter to me. Unfortunately they could only offer me the lowest band because reasons. Megacorp pulled something similar when they asked me to come back. Bureaucracy is nasty no matter who's signing your checks.
- CogitoCogito 3y agoWhat exactly do you mean by "the US seems especially bad"? Bad compared to what? US government efficiency vs foreign governments' efficiency? US government efficiency vs private sector efficiency? After clarifying what you mean by "bad", _is_ the US especially bad in actuality? Are you basing this perception on any systematic analysis? I don't mean this to be argumentative or something, I'm just trying to understand what you're basing your thinking on.
- Schiendelman 3y agoYou can often trace the apparent efficiency of a bureaucracy back to the length of time that particular one has existed and its complexity. Because of World War II, and other mid-20th century government changes, European bureaucracies can sometimes be much newer than those in the United States, making them appear they are better designed, when they simply haven’t existed for long enough to become as terrible.
- tptacek 3y agoThen why is the federal IRS so much better than the state revenue services?
- Schiendelman 3y agoBetter?? Taxes in the US are a byzantine monster. State taxes are far simpler.
- tptacek 3y agoEmployees of the federal IRS are Waldorf Astoria concierges compared to state revenue agencies, regardless of what you think of the underlying statutes.
- Schiendelman 3y agoBut we’re not talking about “employees”. We’re talking about the entirety of an organization.
- tptacek 3y agoYes. The IRS is a relatively good organization, and a much older one than many of the state revenue agencies that underperform it so pitifully. This thread isn't a debate on whether we like the tax code (which the IRS doesn't control, not that it matters) but rather a discussion on whether the age and size of a bureaucracy determines its efficiency. Here's a counterexample to that claim.
- JamesBarney 3y agoI think there are a two reasons the US is worse. 1. Scale, a lot of countries are closer to a city state than the size of the US government. State governments are run poorly for different reasons having to do with our political system. Yeah Luxembourg and Singapore are run really well but India and china aren't. 2. No political party is interested in fixing efficiency. The Democrats ignore it because they don't want to bring attention to government inefficiency/corruption issues. The Republicans want government to be as inefficient as possible so we are incentivized to get rid of it.