3 ms·
> We may be splitting hairs about signed agreements and assurances. Its not splitting hairs. International law is not civil contracts, and even in contracts wi
by dragonwriter 3y ago
> We may be splitting hairs about signed agreements and assurances.
Its not splitting hairs. International law is not civil contracts, and even in contracts wide classes of important agreements must be in writing with clarity as to essential terms to be binding.
> Yes there are no signed agreements.
Which is really the end of the discussion as to whether there was a durable commitment to the USSR inheritable by any of the USSR’s successor states, individually or collectively. If a signed agreement did exist, we'd have to look at its details to see what its exact scope and temporal parameters and conditions were and whether such heritability made sense, and what commitments the other way were tied to it, and whether it was even logically possible for the putative successor states claiming to inherit the interest to uphold them. But it doesn’t, so we don’t need any further analysis.
Binding, long-term, international agreements heritable by successor states don't come out of private oral assurances that aren’t incorporated into formal international agreements.
Russia trying to conjure such an agreement retroactively after first trying and failing to jump the line and get into NATO ahead of other states in the region is especially brazen, though.