3 ms·
I think I agree that that's a noble aspiration. I'm not so sure that our modern culture which is so focused on passing judgment as well suited to learning such
by s1artibartfast 3y ago
I think I agree that that's a noble aspiration. I'm not so sure that our modern culture which is so focused on passing judgment as well suited to learning such a lesson with our modern approaches. If you want to understand how the mistakes of History are made, you have to be able to put yourself in the shoes of the people that made the mistakes and understand their biases and blind spots. I feel that one failing is a tendency to set ourselves apart from them and simply condemn opposed to understand and learn. It's not enough to Simply know the Nazis were bad. If you want to avoid their mistakes you have to understand how and why they thought that they were good. If you simply think they were monsters while you are not, you deny the opportunity for introspection on how you could be or become monstrous yourself. Simply judging is insufficient for learning
- ttfkam 3y agoJudgement is required. Learning that Nazis aren't cartoon villains does negate the necessity of choosing to highlight they were horrifically bad in the historical timeline. Simply judging is indeed insufficient for learning but it is also a necessary component. Otherwise you get folks who even today assert that "slavery wasn't that bad," "the Civil War wasn't about slavery or racism," "I think nationalism is a good thing," and "our race and culture are under attack due to immigration and white genocide."