3 ms·
Yeah, the Niihau incident and the shelling of a Santa Barbara oil facility by a Japanese sub with a witness (falsely, in retrospect) reporting seeing the sub tu
by dragonwriter 3y ago
Yeah, the Niihau incident and the shelling of a Santa Barbara oil facility by a Japanese sub with a witness (falsely, in retrospect) reporting seeing the sub turning south toward LA and signalling someone on shore after the attack [0], and the subsequent incident where what was later identified to have been a rogue weather balloon triggered war nerves and resulted in substantial anti-aircraft fire on phantom Japanese aircraft over LA [1] were all part of the context of the internment, but while, like the more deliberate propaganda directed by the Nazis against the Jews, they are important if you want to understand the mechanics of how the actions they preceded were seen as justified at the time, they are so distant from anything that might actually remotely justify the action (and, unlike the Nazi propaganda, aren’t themselves an organized part of the action) that there is a very good reason they aren’t highlighted in most discussion of the ethics of the action.
[0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bombardment_of_Ellwood https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bombardment_of_Ellwood
[1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Los_Angeles https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Los_Angeles
- NoImmatureAdHom 3y agoThis is a really thoughtful comment, thank you. I agree with everything you've said with one exception, and I appreciate the additional context I didn't know about. I would say that it is very reasonable to argue that "...they are so distant from anything that might actually remotely justify the action...", but that does not imply that "...there is a very good reason they aren’t highlighted..." is the actual reason Ni'ihau isn't highlighted. I'm still pretty convinced it's because it's inconvenient, awkward, uncomfortable...not because those events and the context they were part of made a bad justification for trampling the rights of 125,000 people. As I think about it more, the thing I'm stuck on is more like...Ni'ihau and the stuff you mention, and the context that makes for, all make the people involved seem more reasonable, less kind of...crazily racist and afraid...a little less cartoonishly evil. And a lot of people these days don't like that. They want an "other", an enemy that is simple and easy to hate. Clear right and wrong. Red and Blue, D and R, Tory and Labour. And I think that's childish and wrong and bad in almost all circumstances. Pointing out Ni'ihau amidst the self-flagellation about Japanese internment in WWII makes that sort of person look at something he doesn't want to look at, but that he looks at it is good for him and for the rest of us.