2 ms·
> This is how you can buy a gas powered car and have lower emissions than an electric F-150, Rivian, Hummer, etc. because those require so much more steel and
by mschuster91 3y ago
> This is how you can buy a gas powered car and have lower emissions than an electric F-150, Rivian, Hummer, etc. because those require so much more steel and thus manufacturing emissions.
That's a different problem - US consumers are (lured to) buying SUVs because of an old loophole [1] and because SUVs make really good margins so manufacturers prioritize these in advertising. Nothing, absolutely nothing makes an electric vehicle be heavier than an ICE vehicle.
Comparing apples to apples, a Tesla Model S clocks in at 2255kg max dry weight, a 7-series BMW at 2525kg.
[1] https://www.wired.com/story/the-us-wants-to-close-the-suv-loophole-that-supersized-cars/ https://www.wired.com/story/the-us-wants-to-close-the-suv-lo...
- freedude 3y agoThe dry weight is a misnomer which avoids the inconvenient facts. The Tesla requires large amounts of hard to obtain Lithium, Nickel and Cobalt. The BMW uses Aluminum and Iron which are easy to obtain by comparison. This means the Tesla requires much more emissions to produce a car of the same mass.
- mschuster91 3y ago> This means the Tesla requires much more emissions to produce a car of the same mass. Indeed, but during the course of its operation, the BMW will consume a ton of fossil fuels (which may be produced at harm to the environment such as with fracking) while the Tesla can be driven completely emissions-free using renewable electricity. It's a trade between upfront and recurring emissions, and given just how long cars can last (many a first-generation Tesla from over a decade ago is still on its first battery pack), I seriously prefer the former as the total lifetime emissions are what matters.