3 ms·
> who recently caught 40 of the 96 students [...] cheating That 40 is reported suspected, by one individual. The same individual claims that only 2/3 of thos
by neilv 3y ago
> who recently caught 40 of the 96 students [...] cheating
That 40 is reported suspected, by one individual. The same individual claims that only 2/3 of those were admitted at time of writing.
Also, suspicion was by only a 1:100 coincidence probability standard of evidence, and by some imperfect metric. IMHO, that threshold would be too low to "prove" guilt in such a potentially serious matter (negative mark on student record, reputational damage among college social and professional networking peers, and potentially including suspension or expulsion).
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- masfuerte 3y agoHe says that only one student was at roughly the hundred to one level, so he thought that one might be honest. The rest were at the billion to one level.
- 6D794163636F756 3y agoHe also said that he is talking to others about what he should do. It seems like he very sensibly is using this as a starting point rather than accepting his work as the final verdict
- ajross 3y ago> Also, suspicion was by only a 1:100 coincidence probability standard of evidence, and by some imperfect metric. ...only? In a sample size of 96, what's the value in analysis beyond that level? No, this seems pretty solid to me. The math to do this is routine freshman statistics stuff, something every practicing scientist knows. The assumptions just require that wrong answers be roughly evenly distributed across the choices (e.g. you could construct a test where everyone who was wrong would be led to choice C and rarely B or D, but that's a little pathological; and regardless it's something that would be evident in the data set and seems not to have been). I mean, standards vary but I'll bet in most jurisdictions 100:1 odds count as "beyond a reasonable doubt" for jury instructions in criminal trials. At the very least you'd bring the trial, which is what happened here. If I know there's only a 1% chance I'm wrong, it's absolutely valid for me to accuse you of cheating.
- sokoloff 3y ago> I'll bet in most jurisdictions 100:1 odds count as "beyond a reasonable doubt" for jury instructions in criminal trials. IANAL, but I sure hope that 100:1 chance, standing alone, doesn't meet the bar for "beyond a reasonable doubt". To me, a 1% chance of an accusation being false is definitionally "reasonable doubt".
- Wowfunhappy 3y ago...I have no idea where I heard this, but for some reason I was under the impression "beyond a reasonable doubt" meant ~95% confident. (Whereas "preponderance of evidence" meant >50% confident.)
- ajross 3y agoPer Wikipedia, the original framing is Blackstone's ratio from the enlightenment, where he used 10:1. Real courts don't put numbers on this, of course, but that's the thinking that produced the philosophy. Basically: no, given the level of innaccuracy we already know to be present, I think it's very clear that a sincerely-believed 99% confidence will send someone to jail pretty much anywhere in the US. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reasonable_doubt https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reasonable_doubt https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blackstone%27s_ratio https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blackstone%27s_ratio
- neilv 3y agoThe quoted sentence I objected to was the sloppy writing, conflating of "suspected" with "caught". I think "caught" would be read by most readers as implying guilt. Suspected at 1:100, certainly. Quietly confronted and questioned at 1:100, sure. Convicted at 1:100, absolutely not. I'm not sure this is the best analogy, but imagine that, for every 100 people in society, 1 of them is wrongly convicted, at random. Further imagine that this lottery happens repeatedly, so that even more than 1 in 100 end up getting hit. That sounds like a miserable society in which to live.
- sokoloff 3y agoHeadline: "80 million people worldwide caught cheating" just in the first round.
- Aunche 3y agoThe 1/100 chance is assuming that students choose all answers with equal likelihood, but supposedly these answers were obviously wrong. If the probability of accidentally choosing the obvious wrong answer drops even by a few percent, that would significantly decrease the likelihood of innocence.