3 ms·
The largest threat against the free press right now is the EUs GDPR laws and how they are now systematically abused by European governments to hinder transparen
by carlosjobim 3y ago
The largest threat against the free press right now is the EUs GDPR laws and how they are now systematically abused by European governments to hinder transparency of documents that should be strictly available to the public by law. Here is how it works:
All European governments have instituted "Data protection authorities" to work for them. When a journalist, citizen, or other investigator sends a request for information or documents that the people in government wants to hide, they will call on this authority. Before GDPR they simply had to give out these documents, because it is completely clear in the laws that the public should have access to them. Now they have an option for not giving out public information they don't want to be seen, by calling on their "Data protection authority". This authority will then do everything to stall the process. They will send a bunch of questions to the person who required the documents, such as what backup software they use, where are the servers located (which is of course sensitive information), etc etc.
If they find anything from the United States among the software like Google software or whatnot, they will deny sending the public documents requested. They will write "Since you are using e-mail from the United States, you will break GDPR law if you get these documents". Of course they are themselves sending this message through a Microsoft cloud service in the USA that the government uses. Mission accomplished for them and documents remain hidden.
These European data protection authorities deliberately make the false interpretation of the law that any name of a person in any document should be protected information under GDPR in order to hide information that should be publicly available. It seems the main purpose of the GDPR laws has been this, to help governments combat public transparency. And to put up annoying cookie banners - even on the government radio website that OP links to.
- jruohonen 3y agoAlthough I agree with the observation that certain state institutions are misusing the GDPR to violate FOI laws, the rest of this rant is pure anti-GDPR propaganda. If you actually care about media freedom, you already know that your comment is entirely false. Concentration of media ownership, state censorship, media independence, harassment of and violence against journalists, declining media pluralism, state surveillance and abuse of national security laws, etc., not the GDPR, are real threats. https://rsf.org/sites/default/files/medias/file/2022/04/RSF_Index_Questionnaire_2022_EN.pdf https://rsf.org/sites/default/files/medias/file/2022/04/RSF_...
- carlosjobim 3y agoThere is nothing false in my comment, these abuses of GDPR law happen. You can choose what you want to believe if you want to be ignorant. "If you actually care about media freedom..." - What kind of comment is that? I just made a case for transparency - and this is your reaction? You are free to make a sustainable post here about the issues you are bringing up. "State censorship" - yes, that is what I was describing. Abuse of GDPR laws is the largest threat in the EU right now. I should have been clear that I meant in the EU. Violence against journalism is always the most serious threat, but it is not the largest threat, since it is rare.
- jruohonen 3y ago> Abuse of GDPR laws is the largest threat in the EU right now. While abuse of the GDPR by public authorities does happen, this statement is still not true. What they are mostly abusing is related to alleged security issues and over-interpretation of the laws governing confidentiality of information. In fact, the GDPR has substantially improved mishandling of citizens' data by public authorities, although there is still much to improve.
- carlosjobim 3y ago> In fact, the GDPR has substantially improved mishandling of citizens' data by public authorities, although there is still much to improve. And that has zero to do with my comment, which was not about wether GDPR is good or bad as a thing, but how these laws are being abused by governments in order to hide public information. If this abuse is allowed to continue and expand, it is on the course to become the biggest freedom of press problem in the EU, unless something else comes up. Thereby the largest threat.
- jruohonen 3y ago> but how these laws are being abused by governments in order to hide public information. Now you are on the right track; you should just specify to which "these laws" refer to. As I said, the GDPR is hardly the main culprit; it governs personal data, which is usually of little value beyond gossip magazines and crime "journalism". The real abuses of FOI are elsewhere.
- Dah00n 3y ago>This authority will then do everything to stall the process. They will send a bunch of questions to the person who required the documents, such as what backup software they use, where are the servers located (which is of course sensitive information), etc etc. I have made several requests and this is not at all what I have been met with. I also follow Noyb closely and this does not sound like something they meet often either (and if they do, they will sue I'm sure). >Since you are using e-mail from the United States, you will break GDPR law if you get these documents" I'd like to see proof, or I'll call that out as a lie. I have received documents at a Microsoft and Google mail. Actually, this reads very much like an American trying to describe GDPR.
- carlosjobim 3y agoMaybe you should go outside and take a breath of fresh air before you start accusing people of lying, being Americans etc? For one, these DPA decisions are confidential, or at least that's what they write when they give them. Secondly, do you think I will put my own privacy and the privacy of others in jeopardy in order to satisfy you? Even if I sent you the evidence you would refuse to acknowledge it, because you already know what you want to believe - as is your right. > I have received documents at a Microsoft and Google mail. Of course! They will not have a problem with any of that if they don't have a problem with giving out the information. It is when they don't want to give out some information that it is suddenly a problem that you use Outlook or GMail. In a majority of cases the public servants will have no issue with giving out requested information. 99% of times things work correctly and smoothly.
- Dah00n 3y ago> Even if I sent you the evidence I asked for a company/service name. If you can't give out that then clearly you have already said too much or you haven't got a name to give. This: >99% of times things work correctly and smoothly. and this: >The largest threat against the free press right now is the EUs GDPR laws and how they are now systematically abused by European governments Do definitly NOT agree with each other...