3 ms·
> needs to understand LLMs don’t understand. They don’t understand because they have no model of reality.
by andsoitis 3y ago
> needs to understand
LLMs don’t understand. They don’t understand because they have no model of reality.
- gmerc 3y agoCan you prove that? Because understanding ultimately is the ability to map to abstractions and GPT4 and other models are certifiably able to abstract.
- jen729w 3y agoThe onus is on you to prove that they do understand. One may not simply claim that a machine ‘understands’ because it appears to. Now we’re actually in the much-misunderstood Occam’s razor: that the theory which introduces the fewest new assumptions is the most likely correct. The assumption that a machine ‘understands’ — is capable of such a thing — is new, and requires extreme justification.
- andsoitis 3y ago> Can you prove that? Yes. One can easily construct a conversation where it is obvious that ChatGPT doesn't understand.
- gmerc 3y agoYa that’s not how proof works. People can do the same with humans. Not understanding things happens to be not a sign for the lack of capacity of understanding in humans.