3 ms·
Title: "Shell Shareholders Vote to Let the World Burn" What actually happened: Shell shareholders rejected resolution 26, which according to the linked CNBC ar
by gruez 3y ago
Title: "Shell Shareholders Vote to Let the World Burn"
What actually happened: Shell shareholders rejected resolution 26, which according to the linked CNBC article "calls on the company to align its climate targets with the landmark Paris Agreement and commit to absolute carbon emissions cuts by 2030"
The wikipedia article on the paris agreement says "emissions need to be cut by roughly 50% by 2030". Without arguing over whether rejecting that means "let the world burn", doesn't that target seem unrealistic? Is anyone anywhere close to hitting that target? The only thing I can think of is companies with fat margins (eg. google) that don't emit much relative to their profit, and can pay for carbon offsets to be "net zero". It's not realistic for anyone else or the economy as a whole. It's easy to lambast shell shareholders for not adopting the resolution and "letting the world burn", but if everyone else is doing the same, can you really blame them for not wanting to torpedo their company?
- nightowl_games 3y agoYes. You can. Companies are not that important. The ethical decision making here is completely revolving around ones speculative beliefs. If you truly believe this will have a sufficiently meaningful impact, then you should be willing to torpedo this company, no matter who you are. What qualifies as sufficiently meaningful is up to us.
- asdff 3y agoThey had 15 years to figure this out in a way that wouldn't torpedo their company. I think they deserve a good torpedoing at this point.