4 ms·
Neal Katyal, a self-professed “extremist centrist” [...] argued that Hennepin County’s position was supported by the Statute of Gloucester of 1278, which gave f
by anigbrowl 3y ago
Neal Katyal, a self-professed “extremist centrist” [...] argued that Hennepin County’s position was supported by the Statute of Gloucester of 1278, which gave feudal lords in England the ability to recover their land from tenants.
This is why I'm against centrists. They don't stand for anything other than enforcing the status quo, no matter how unjust it is. They have no principles; they're just conflict-avoidant. There is something broken both intellectually and morally in trying to leverage a 750-year old feudal statute to win an argument in a 21st century democratic Republic (or even an 18th century one, if you consider the US dysfunctional in the way I do) which exists specifically because its founders rejected feudalism. I'm genuinely surprised because Neal Katyal is an intelligent person and a very experienced litigator, so he had to know that this argument was bullshit on multiple levels.
- dylan604 3y ago>so he had to know that this argument was bullshit on multiple levels. Isn't a lawyer supposed to argue on behalf of their client and not necessarily their personal beliefs? Sure, sometimes they align, but I've heard some pretty crazy things come out of a lawyer's mouth in whatever they need to provide the full throated legal argument for their client (even if it's not the best legal argument)
- whatshisface 3y agoIt's kind of strange that one of the major professions in our society is one where you pretend to be insane!
- anigbrowl 3y agoYou are certainly supposed to argue on behalf of your client, but with good arguments. If your client doesn't have a leg to stand on, praising their running ability is a waste of everyone's time.
- SllX 3y agoThey used what they had available to support a position that was ultimately determined to be an aberration under a 21st century court; but it’s worth noting we rejected a Feudal system but we did not reject the entirety of the English legal tradition nor the body of law associated with it except insofar as it is found to be abhorrent to our own republican laws in the States and in the Federal judiciary.
- crooked-v 3y agoIn my experience, most 'centrists' just turn out to be people on the center-right who don't want the public embarrassment in their nominally liberal social circles of admitting they're on the center-right.