4 ms·
Of course one can argue about the semantics of "defensive war", but as far as I understand, there was basically zero chance Japan would have conquered the US, o
by cubefox 3y ago
Of course one can argue about the semantics of "defensive war", but as far as I understand, there was basically zero chance Japan would have conquered the US, or any American territory for an extended period of time, without the US invading Japan. So in this sense the war wasn't purely defensive. It was nothing remotely like the defensive war of France against Germany during WW2.
- dragonwriter 3y ago> > so you’ll need to move the goalposts farther. > […] there was basically zero chance Japan would have conquered the US, or any American territory for an extended period of time, without the US invading Japan. So in this sense the war wasn’t purely defensive. War is only defensive if the attacker is likely to conquer and hold territory for an extended period of time? Well, there go the goalposts as expected, though I could not have predicted that that was where they would go.
- cubefox 3y agoThe OP talked about "defensive wars". If X tries to steal Y's pocket, and Y prevents X from stealing it, and additionally gives X a kick in the ass, then that might be justified, but it's not just an act of self-defense.
- juve1996 3y agoJapan stole quite a bit, from quite a few people, in the Pacific theater. The war doesn't end when the US gets back what was stolen - it ends when all of its allies get back, what was stolen.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoThat's hardly a universal truth. Nations, the US included, don't wait until War every time another country is wronged. They don't continue until every wrong has been righted. It is far from clear that the us would have entered the Pacific War simply to to defend other countries, even if us strategists wanted to.
- juve1996 3y agoWe aren't arguing universal truths. This was a fought war with context. No claim of universal truth was made. > They don't continue until every wrong has been righted. It is far from clear that the us would have entered the Pacific War simply to to defend other countries, even if us strategists wanted to. Once the US entered the war and thus entered into deeper agreements with allies it was inevitable. The war was never ending once the US righted its own wrongs. It made promises to allies.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoIf that was your point, I agree. War can have multiple objectives. Depending on how things started and played out, they could have been different, which was my primary point. If Japan had not attacked Peral harbor, it is possible that the US objectives could have been different.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoThat not really how it works when nations go to war. Once hostilities start, you need either complete submission or a high degree of trust to stop them. This is because there is a large downside risk to stopping prematurely. By way of analogy, if you are in a fist fight and stop before you know the opponent is down, you may be knocked out yourself