9 ms·
Neanderthal Flute
- mooreds 3y agoYou can see the flute played here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3agcq7fSGC8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3agcq7fSGC8
- QuercusMax 3y agoThis video is all about the flute music without all the interesting sciency stuff: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sHy9FOblt7Y https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sHy9FOblt7Y
- jasonwatkinspdx 3y agoWow, that is a much more capable and versatile instrument than I expecting for something so simple. 2.5 octave range and a scale/tuning that sounds pleasant even to modern ears.
- dhosek 3y agoThe thing that’s impressive to me is that it has the holes for controlling pitch. The reconstruction offers some guesses at the temperament, but I imagine there’s a lot of room for error. Presumably there are other instruments even older (it’s likely that the very first instruments would be percussion instruments which, even should they survive, would be difficult to identify as musical instruments tens of thousands of years later.
- QuercusMax 3y agoThe first percussion instruments were almost certainly either rocks or sticks banged together. The sticks were presumably used just like claves (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Claves https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Claves).
- gabrielsroka 3y ago> Probably the earliest flyswatters were nothing more than some sort of striking surface attached to the end of a long stick. https://snltranscripts.jt.org/93/93rdeep1.phtml https://snltranscripts.jt.org/93/93rdeep1.phtml
- bdhcuidbebe 3y agoIn Africa there are several giant boulders that when stroken plays a certain tune. While undateable, they show markings from a very long time of use.
- dheera 3y ago> lot of room for error I mean, when you have all day and nothing to do sitting around in your cave, you can make a lot of flutes and hopefully one will be error-free.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dhosek 3y agoI was thinking not about the original flute, but the recreation of it from a fragmentary artifact.
- asdff 3y agoOne would think a blade of grass would be even older than the flute. Kids sometimes pick up grass whistling intuitively but its also something that is culturally passed down over the years at the playground, and might be quite old.
- jacurtis 3y agoAfter watching the video, it seems that they are distinguishing it by the fact that it was a man-made object created for the specific purpose of producing music. This of course still allows for other pre-existing natural objects to be used for music playing. For example, I assume prior to creating a flute, human ancestors likely batted rocks together or beat rocks against hollow logs to create a beat or variants of music. But the significance of this finding is that it was purpose-made for creating music, which is interesting since it hints at the cultural impact that music may have played 60,000+ years ago.
- ilyt 3y agoOr just hitting something with a stick to drum
- rpastuszak 3y agoThat reminds me, tangentially, of The Song of the Reed, by Rumi. http://www.dar-al-masnavi.org/n-I-0001.html#1 http://www.dar-al-masnavi.org/n-I-0001.html#1 (think of the 3 meanings of reed: an instrument turning human breath (life) into music, a writing tool (qalam), and of course a living creature itself)
- piwi 3y agoSome people think it is a hyena who punctured the bone, and that it is not from neanderthal. Search Divje Babe in https://royalsocietypublishing.org/doi/full/10.1098/rsos.140022 https://royalsocietypublishing.org/doi/full/10.1098/rsos.140... It is amazing to see how much work is spent collecting pieces of evidence.
- mandmandam 3y agoThat might seem plausible after reading just this article, but if you look at this video [0] you can see the way it was reconstructed, and hear it being played. It strikes me as unnecessarily dismissive to insist that hyenas gnawed a perfect pentatonic flute; that really does just seem like some kind of weird jealousy... Especially when we have other examples of pentatonic bone flutes tens of thousands of years old. 0 - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sHy9FOblt7Y https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sHy9FOblt7Y
- crazygringo 3y agoIt's not dismissive or jealousy at all -- it's wanting it to make sure this is based on actual evidence rather than wishful thinking, because that's how science works. And when you see the image of the partial flute, it is entirely non-obvious that it's a musical instrument. It's a small piece of bone broken on both ends with two holes in it, and a hint of a third hole. There are lots of natural objects that look man-made but aren't, and canine species absolutely can produce similar-looking tooth puncture holes in the middle of bones. And when that happens enough, it's not hard to imagine 3 holes that could be used musically just through coincidence. So it really does require a lot of analysis to show that this is actually a man-made instrument, and it's important to do that rather than just make unwarranted assumptions.
- Tao3300 3y agoWhatever the doubtful counterpart to wishful thinking is, a great example would be conjuring up the perfect hyena to make the perfect bite without otherwise crushing the bone. "Withering skepticism" maybe?
- aaron695 3y ago[dead]
- 100k 3y agoAmazing, hearing it played sends chills down my spine. It's not as old, but in Wernor Herzog's documentary "Cave of Forgotten Dreams", an archeologist plays a 30,000 year old vulture bone flute. It even uses the pentatonic scale! Some links about it: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yUCBBDV2Tzk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yUCBBDV2Tzk https://www.ethanhein.com/wp/2011/flute-of-forgotten-dreams/ https://www.ethanhein.com/wp/2011/flute-of-forgotten-dreams/ https://www.npr.org/2009/06/24/105823127/a-little-flute-music-to-warm-the-cave https://www.npr.org/2009/06/24/105823127/a-little-flute-musi...
- ddol 3y agoThe first link of Wulf Hein playing the Star-Spangled Banner on a 30,000 year old flute is incredible. To think that someone noodling on a flute could have produced that melody before dogs were domesticated is fascinating.
- bloak 3y agoIf the flute is designed for a pentatonic scale, why did he play a melody that isn't even heptatonic? He should have played a well-known pentatonic tune like "Auld Lang Syne"! [The tune of the Spar-Spangled Banner uses all the notes of the major scale plus the fourth note sharpened by a semitone on the last syllables of "early" and "perilous". The unsharpened fourth note, an octive higher, is present on "air". (Yes, I did have to look up the lyrics, obviously.) Apparently the tune was taken from "The Anacreontic Song" (18th century), which did not have those accidentals.]
- todd8 3y agoA friend's wrote a book on prehistoric flutes. Her Ph.D. dissertation was on the subject, [1]. Unfortunately, I believe that it is out of print. [1] Lana Neal, The Earliest Instrument: Ritual Power and Fertility Magic of the Flute in Upper Paleolithic Culture, https://www.amazon.com/Earliest-Instrument-Fertility-Paleolithic-Culture/dp/1576472213/ref=sr_1_2?crid=3F4GUEY0PAPZF&keywords=lana+neal+flute&qid=1685055812&sprefix=lana+neal+flute%2Caps%2C150&sr=8-2 https://www.amazon.com/Earliest-Instrument-Fertility-Paleoli...
- masfuerte 3y agoThe Slovenian national museum has an English language leaflet describing the museum's top ten attractions. I particularly wanted to see the Neanderthal flute and an impressive silver torc. The torc (and a couple of other highlighted items) were missing. So before I left I asked about them. The staff did not give a fuck. It was a strange experience.
- chompychop 3y agoHow do they definitively know it was used as a musical instrument? It could just have been something punched out on the bone just for fun, by the Neanderthal. Sure, you can make music out of it, but that's not scientific evidence to conclude that someone did use it to make music, is it?
- Tor3 3y agoTry punching random holes - and see if it creates a musical scale as we know it (go for a pentatonic scale). It's very unlikely that the placement and sizes (placement also affect sizes) of the holes will create that scale, even if you perform the random experiment again and again and again.
- karaterobot 3y ago> This discovery confirms that the Neanderthals were, like us, fully developed spiritual beings capable of sophisticated artistic expression. That feels a bit like an unsupported claim to me. It may be so, I am not saying Neanderthals weren't spiritual beings capable of sophisticated artistic expression. I am just wondering how you would confidently conclude that from the existence of (a thing which is probably) a flute. In a slightly larger sense, it feels like a lot of claims about Neanderthals do this same thing: the presence of a specific artifact becomes not only evidence of technological sophistication, but proof of some deeper philosophical or spiritual consequence. I'm fascinated by early hominin, and try to follow this stuff as a lay person. So much interesting progress in such a short time. But, I'm not comfortable with the level of speculation I frequently see among communicators in this field, personally.
- beezlebroxxxxxx 3y agoThe connection between artistic expression and "spiritual beings" is also odd. What if they were just playing some songs around a fire? What if the flutes were for emulating bird songs? Maybe it was a kid's toy. The presence of artistic expression need not require some complex or even simplistic spiritualism, only a kind of basic aesthetics, a desire for creative expression.
- mastazi 3y agoI get your point but > Maybe it was a kid's toy. We shouldn't be dismissive of kid's toys, I think they fully qualify as indicators of intelligence. Fish fry or newborn reptiles don't play flutes.
- Tagbert 3y agoI think the objection is equating "intelligent" with "spiritual being". Those are not necessarily coincident.
- mastazi 3y agoYes, true, my bad. I have a history of not understanding what the word "spiritual" means (I think I've read every possible explanation over the years, I still don't get it), so I usually tend to find a proxy for it when I'm reasoning about something. In this case I was using "intelligent" as my proxy.
- xkcd1963 3y ago"fully developed spiritual beings capable of sophisticated artistic expression" confused shrugging
- cubefox 3y agoI found this striking: > The flute from Divje babe is the only one that was definitely made by Neanderthals. It is about 20,000 years older than other known flutes, made by anatomically modern humans. Does this suggest that for some period of history, the Neanderthals were "technologically" ahead of Homo sapiens? At least in terms of flutes?
- ldjkfkdsjnv 3y agoIts not spoken about openly, but there is a decent correlation between % of DNA from neanderthals and IQ
- cubefox 3y agoDo you have some reference? (I know that they had a larger brain. But if they were more intelligent, why did they go extinct?)
- BurningFrog 3y agoI'm 2.3% Neanderthal. We're not extinct. We merged.
- ldjkfkdsjnv 3y agoAnother aspect, is theres no telling how much that 2.3% matters. Not all strands of DNA have the same effect on how someone turns out
- davidmnoll 3y ago2.3% doesn't reflect what i'd call a merge..
- vanattab 3y agoSo do you only merge your code when you've edited more then 50% of your lines?
- 3y ago
- dkga 3y agoI cannot describe how I feel hearing the sounds and tunes coming out of that flute. To know I am experiencing music with that particular timbre fills my soul with awe that we have this link to the past. And the affirmation that it is sufficient to play most classical music pieces means that its range includes the diatonic scale. Similarly amazing (in the literal sense) is that other wind instrument techniques are possible. I don’t know if I am overhearing things but I noted the musician what harmonica folks call “bending”.
- crazygringo 3y agoIncredibly cool, and the video explains how they made a 3D scan of it in order to reconstruct a playable version with broken parts replaced. Which seems like it would be the coolest thing ever to 3D print. I'd love to have this on my bookshelf. Unfortunately, I can only find a primitive playable version that was recreated from an illustration [1], and the museum gift shop sells a 3D-printed version that is unrestored and therefore unplayable [2] -- though the museum shop page doesn't seem to load any content [3]. But 4:34 [4] in their video shows the detailed scanned version with restoration that is playable: "To this end, we made a 3D model of the replica in which Ljuben Dimkaroski added the missing pieces." I wonder how I could get/print one of those...? (I also wonder whether a 3D printed plastic one would sound any good... Another source [5] indicates the playable version is a clay replica.) [1] https://www.thingiverse.com/thing:500840 https://www.thingiverse.com/thing:500840 [2] https://www.3d-solutions.si/en/neanderthal-flute/ https://www.3d-solutions.si/en/neanderthal-flute/ [3] https://www.nms.si/en/museum-shop/replicas https://www.nms.si/en/museum-shop/replicas [4] https://youtu.be/3agcq7fSGC8?t=274 https://youtu.be/3agcq7fSGC8?t=274 [5] https://www.classicfm.com/discover-music/instruments/flute/worlds-oldest-instrument-neanderthal-flute/ https://www.classicfm.com/discover-music/instruments/flute/w...
- bradleysmith 3y agofantastic stuff. I'm fiddling with screenshots from your [4] link video to try to pull 3D model from multi-image 3d model build tools. I too would very much like a print of their playable reconstruction on my desk. Please update if you get to a usable STL.
- beezlewax 3y agoAsk them
- Tor3 3y agoFor a flute it'll make minimal difference if it's plastic or clay or bone. You can find endless discussions on this on flute- and whistle forums, but it all boils down to the fact that the sound is produced by a standing wave of air inside a tube, and not by any vibrations of the actual tube material (i.e. totally different from string instruments). Though the material can make a difference when it comes to the actual part where you blow across an edge (very minimal differences are audible - and working with different and more or less difficult materials affect this). (I own flutes and whistles made of plastic or other synthetic materials, various types of metal, and wood)
- minroot 3y agoHoly shit!
- dorfsmay 3y agoDoes this fuel the debate on Neanderthal being able to speak? Could a people unable to speak be able to develop such an instrument with the right distances between holes etc..? That would mean a single individual not able to gain from previous generations' knowledge.
- bdhcuidbebe 3y ago> That would mean a single individual not able to gain from previous generations' knowledge. Surely not. Skills can be passed on by imitation and observation. That being said, I’m certain they had language too. Sign language, whistles and probably spoken language too since they probably co-develop.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- smolder 3y agoOrcas have been teaching each other to sink boats, from what I was reading. They don't speak, but they do communicate.
- precompute 3y agoNeanderthals lived in small groups in sub-zero temps. They had to co-ordinate or they'd die. So I'd say, yeah, they could indeed speak and communicate in complex manners, much like us, or maybe even better.
- ChrisMarshallNY 3y agoThat’s a cool story. I find this passage interesting: > fully developed spiritual beings
- Tor3 3y agoThat's one part of the article I don't particularly like - what's a "spiritual being"? I consider myself fully human, but there's nothing in my psyche which I would consider "spiritual" - what does it even mean? I play music, I sing, I read literature, I write, I create, and more. Nothing of that is something I feel the need for using the word "spiritual" to describe.
- ChrisMarshallNY 3y agoYeah. I thought it was an odd turn of phrase, for a scientific article.
- ekianjo 3y ago[flagged]
- Tao3300 3y agoIt's the oldest in the world. Prove me wrong.
- ekianjo 3y agoIt's the oldest one KNOWN in the world. Until we find an older one. You know, just because you found something now, does not exclude you will find anything else in the future.
- silisili 3y agoI get the point, but it's a bit pedantic. We don't preface every superlative with 'that we know of.' It's kinda implied.
- Tao3300 3y agoIt's obvious though. Should they also note who it is that knows it to be the oldest, along with when and where they knew this? Just in case? Did you get burned on an exam over this or something? It's silly to be so exact about this.
- ekianjo 3y ago> It's silly to be so exact about this. It's silly for scientists to be always surprised by finding some older stuff over and over again as they scratch more of the earth. Statistically speaking, there is no reason that the oldest stuff would be found first, yet you keep seeing headlines "this is older than what we thought" making them look like complete naive people every single time.
- d--b 3y agoThe level of certainty that is conveyed by the article is staggering… Whatever they say we can’t know for sure that this was made to be blown into, and if it was made to be blown into, we definitely can’t say it was made to make music. Just a little “scientists believe” and “neanderthals may” here and there would make this a lot more palatable.
- fugalfervor 3y agodo some research on the pentatonic scale. it's an intelligent abstraction encoded in the placement of holes on this object. if one were to randomly put four holes in a bone of the same size, the chances that they would produce a pentatonic scale are pretty rare. if this were found in a human settlement, no one would bat an eye: the pentatonic scale has appeared in almost every human culture. with that in mind, this object is far more likely to have been created by an intelligent being than to have been composed of random punctures.
- dghughes 3y agoAncient peoples would have sucked the marrow out of bones. I can imagine someone doing so and there is a crack or hole in the center of the bone they are holding. As they suck out the last remaining marrow and try to get more but all they do is pull air through the hole. A noise is heard and they realize they can make a sound.
- casenmgreen 3y agoSite blocks Tor.
- kbos87 3y agoSo interesting! I do have to say, the way they state some of the specifics as though they are settled facts is a little off putting, like - "the size and the position of the holes cannot be accidental – they were made with the intention of musical expression." Cannot? Were? I'm sorry, but there's no way to actually deduce that from the available information.
- Tor3 3y agoBecause the size and the position of the holes create a scale which can be used for playing music. Via links shown in an earlier comment it's explained that it is a diatonic scale, but the point is really that if the holes had different sizes and the positions were different, even slightly, then you couldn't play music as we know it (see the video where Albinoni’s Adagio is played on a replica flute). That's why it can be stated that it wasn't accidental.
- MilStdJunkie 3y agoOof. It's an important find (AKA the Divje Babe flute[1]), but it's very hard to stay tuned in when they utter the phrase "spiritual being". That's quite a thing to say. How do you measure spirits these days? With wheels, rods, or clocks? So far as intelligent goes, the Neanderthals might have well been smarter than the first Sapiens to cross their path, but were disadvantaged by other factors, like a potentially ruinous birth rate, more restricted diet, and poorer (or more restricted) eyesight. One interesting idea I've heard . . for a story . . imagine if sapiens spread HGT-style via a disease, that was transmitted by violence and rape. Like a bio-zombie, or the "Crossed" virus from "Crossed +100" (and which was invented by Garth Ennis, I guess). From the neanderthal perspective, it would have felt like Planet Zombie afterwards - and then they have to make their way among these terrifying new humanoids. The horror of the future. It would probably be more interesting moved to the present day, with a speciating change propagating via what looks like zombie bites, but which actually reflects the early stages of a new species, some weird more-fully-eusocial variant of homo adapted for extreme density. [1] Which was really, really controversial in its day, and to some extent still is.
- jaredhallen 3y agoI've had a similar theory for a long time, admittedly based on basically absolutely nothing. Looking back at history, say WWII, what would have happened if the Axis had won? History is written by the victors, as they say. I have to imagine that things would be perceived differently today, had that happened. Something along the lines of the Heroic Axis defeating the Evil Allies. Having observed the way Homo Sapiens often behave, I've long wondered if we were the Axis, and the Neanderthals the Allies, so to speak.
- MilStdJunkie 3y agoAlternate History is a guilty pleasure of mine too! Except, it shouldn't really be called guilty, should it? Because those "alternates" give us insight into maybe - possibly - isolating crucial factors in human history. I'm not convinced there was any possible scenario where the Axis could win post December 1941, after the retreat from Moscow and the Americans entry. Particularly the latter. I remain convinced that America was the deciding factor in the conflict, and this should not be surprising looking at the raw production numbers. Soviet production levels shocked Hitler into outright disbelief[1], but even those numbers - numbers literally extracted from the blood of the Soviet nation - were half of American peacetime productive capacity. That's not even counting resource production differential (oil, coal, steel, etc), where the USA had more capacity than the rest of the Allies combined - several times over. Dulles and many others wished fervently for a mid-1945 pivot versus the Red Army, to meet them as far east as possible, "Allies" be damned (Stalin had never dealt with the Western allies in good faith, and honestly, Churchill didn't rush to shake hands either). It's hard to see how a March/April pivot could happen without an integration of the Wehrmacht into the Western Allies. How this would have gone down, it's probably not very pretty. We were already the number one employer of former Reich employees by that time, and going further would . . well, let's say that "A Night in the Garden" was a movie that got made for a reason. In some ways, the Reich's ideology was made more for America than it was for Germany, for a nation that still had yet a giant wild of "savages" to conquer and dehumanize. [1] https://erenow.net/ww/stalingrad/15.php https://erenow.net/ww/stalingrad/15.php
- nologic01 3y agoThere is this debate about why the music instinct was developed in humans at all, its role in developing social structures and the interplay with linguistic developmemt. Such discoveries push further back the point where primate brains developed advanced musical capability: As it is less likely that Neanderthal and Homo Sapiens developed this independently, it was something they got from their common ancestor. I wonder if the two branches of humanity ever jammed together in the forests of Europe. We share some DNA but otherwise the narrative is that it wasnt a harmonious coexistence.
- layer8 3y agoWell, humans by themselves aren’t a harmonious coexistence either. That doesn’t prevent them from jamming together. Since a lot of humans also have some Neanderthal DNA in them, we know they did more together than just jamming.
- thedriver 3y agoSome of the comments here seem absolutely ridiculous. What is the probability that a perfect flute just happened by accident and survived until this day? For whatever reason, a lot of people have this fixation that humans were somehow significantly less intelligent all the way until the modern industrial era. Based on what I've read, human brain hasn't significantly changed in tens of thousands of years. People in the stone age didn't have significantly lower cognitive abilities.
- kumarvvr 3y agoTo me this signifies the very core of society itself. Someone made this flute, meaning, they had the time to imagine and experiment. Meaning, they played a different role than hunters or foragers of food. This was probably a gift to someone (concept of love / family) or some higher ups (strata / class in society) And, the reason only a very small sample was found was because someone had the idea, tools and time to probably fashion one out of wood, as it may be more easily workable.
- taopai 3y agoThis idea is mind-blowing. Imagine humans surviving in nature without any of the technology we have today. There must have been a wealth of 'oral tradition' regarding plants, places, animals, and social norms. People must have been highly physically active, which naturally boosted their cognitive abilities. Social interaction must have been intense and tightly connected to survival. When I think about all this I feel thrilled and comforted. Sometimes, I wish my life didn't revolve solely around abstract tasks and concepts.
- capableweb 3y ago> Sometimes, I wish my life didn't revolve solely around abstract tasks and concepts. Unless you're socially insulated, your life doesn't really revolve solely around abstract tasks and concepts. You spend time with other humans, where you have a lot of non-abstract tasks and concepts. You go buy groceries, which is a physical activity, and so on. Maybe we're blind to it, but our worlds are still very much physical and non-abstract on a daily basis.
- layer8 3y agoVideo of the flute replica being played: https://youtu.be/eRUufCAFS50 https://youtu.be/eRUufCAFS50
- F2hP18Foam 3y agoHere's a video of the musician mentioned at the end of the article playing a reconstruction of the flute: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AZCWFcyxUhQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AZCWFcyxUhQ
- given 3y agoYou have really no clue who made it. It's just all speculation. Just as Dinosaurs are fake, Neanderthals are probably fake and the thousands/millions of years.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]