3 ms·
> It's a big prize. And it had been Russian from the 1700s until 1956. And now it is again. Except the USSR released it. Nothing to do with the US. And Russia
by vlovich123 3y ago
> It's a big prize. And it had been Russian from the 1700s until 1956. And now it is again.
Except the USSR released it. Nothing to do with the US. And Russia trying to recapture it now has nothing to do with the fact that it’s been it’s own country for almost 50 years. Not to mention Ukraine has repeatedly sought entrance into NATO for exactly this fear and Russia has dissuaded NATO from considering it under threat of viewing it as a direct aggression against Russia.
> It's an economic war. Like most, or even all wars are in reality.
Whatever else I don’t think the war in Ukraine is an economic one. It seems more like a militarily and politically strategic one. Ukraine (specifically Crimea) is an extremely important naval base (at least that’s my impression). The US has also supported the pro-Western political factions within Ukraine which is a problem for Putin considering Ukraine’s proximity to the Russian border and Crimea. Additionally Putin regularly engages in acts of military aggression because it boosts his strongman image which helps him domestically, which, along with the political assassination, helps maintain his power over the political environment in Russia. Putin is already wealthy enough. His moves are about acquiring geopolitical power, not basic wealth.
- int_19h 3y agoCrimea does indeed make for a good naval base, but Russia has more options that aren't much inferior - Novorossiysk, for example. More importantly, Black Sea itself is strategically not very interesting for Russia because Turkey (a NATO country) controls the straits, and thus in any big war involving NATO the Russian fleet would be locked in anyway. No, it is largely a cultural thing. There's considerable evidence that Putin really believes all the tripe about "triune people" that was written in his 2021 essay [0], and genuinely sees independent Ukraine as a deliberately manufactured cultural "anti-Russia" that cannot be allowed to exist for that reason alone. [0] http://en.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/66181 http://en.kremlin.ru/events/president/news/66181
- vlovich123 3y agoWhile Turkey is a NATO ally, I wouldn’t really rely on them, at least not under Erdogan: https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/world/turkeys-erdogan-touts-special-relationship-with-putin-stands-by-his-refusal-to-impose-sanctions/ar-AA1bpVgR https://www.msn.com/en-us/news/world/turkeys-erdogan-touts-s... Sure, it’s unclear Erdogan would go so far as to violate NATO treaties, but I wouldn’t call Turkey the US’s unabashed ally. I don’t know that I buy the whole cultural angle when Putin very reliably acts squarely within the model of realpolitik power acquisition.