9 ms·
Colorado repealed law limiting municipal internet
- fetus8 3y agoNextLight is truly an incredible service.
- lp251 3y agoa fellow longmonster!
- polpo 3y agoWe are legion! Love my NextLight.
- oh_sigh 3y agoWhat's it like living in the big city? I'm just a little Niwoter over here with no hope of ever getting Nextlight.
- MetallicCloud 3y agoI'm in Erie and get Gigabit. It's not symmetrical, but it's the best internet I've ever had.
- gaze 3y agoI just bought a house in Longmont a few weeks ago! You like it?
- wyclif 3y agoHow is Longmont as a place to live? I'm talking about quality of life issues.
- qmarchi 3y agoThere are dozens of us! Dozens! Rocking the 2.5G service, but occasionally getting up to 2.7 if they're feeling nice. Do wish that they would get IPv6 rolled out already. https://shx.nyoom.io/2023/05/r6ro6SZtV3.png https://shx.nyoom.io/2023/05/r6ro6SZtV3.png
- cashsterling 3y agoIt is proof that municipal internet can be awesome and is probably the way most municipalities should go over time. For those who don't know, Longmont Colorado's Nextlight internet service provides symmetric 1Gb/sec speed for 50 USD per month and they don't spy on your traffic. It is the most reliable residential internet service I have had to date and is more reliable than the commercial internet at my places of work in Boulder.
- 0000011111 3y agoWhat is the data cap?
- bobwaycott 3y agoI don’t brag on Chattanooga, TN often, but when I do, it’s always about the municipal symmetric gig fiber—CHA/EPB was the first to do it in the US, it’s always been cheap, it’s more reliable than anything else anywhere I’ve been, no data caps or throttling, held off a Comcast lawsuit trying to stop them (so Comcast went to the state to legislate away meaningful competition), and (afaik) there’s no spying on you. I was lucky enough to build a bunch of the software used consumer-side to enable signing up for and managing fiber internet/tv/phone service, was brought in to establish and run their first internal software team, and built even more cool software to make tech support real-time, improve the lives of CSRs, and more. And they’re now getting into quantum computing. Truly a great group of people trying to take care of their city, and every time I run into anyone, I’m still impressed by what they’re doing.
- sarchertech 3y agoMoved here 4 years ago and the difference between them and comcast is insane. On one of the Chattanooga FB groups someone will occasionally ask which ISP they should use, and there will inevitably be 10+ pages of people writing EPB, EPB, EPB!
- thcipriani 3y ago+100 Yay, Longmont! My service has been rock solid: https://photos.tylercipriani.com/2023-05-25_next-light.png https://photos.tylercipriani.com/2023-05-25_next-light.png
- SplitVengeance 3y agoAnother longmonster here. Totally agree that NextLight is awesome. However, as someone that runs a nonprofit in town, I wish that business/nonprofit pricing was more reasonable.
- mplewis 3y agoNextLight is a local gem!
- donatj 3y agoThe actual difference is almost certainly moot at the end of the day since the ISPs are all in bed with the feds, but the concept of getting my internet from the same institution (read: Government) that brought us the patriot act sounds less than ideal.
- wolrah 3y agoYou're thinking about the federal government. This is about local governments developing last mile networks for the benefit of their residents.
- ultrarunner 3y agoI'm personally skeptical of any level of government, but then I come from the place where Steven Seagal was given access to a sheriff's department tank (provided by the federal government, naturally), and drove it through a gate targeting alleged cockfighting [0]. There's plenty of horrible stuff Joe Arpaio did, but if county-level governments are receiving "tools" (including stingrays and other surveillance equipment) from the federal government, I don't see any reason they wouldn't just walk into the local government ISP whenever they wanted. Not that I trust Cox et al much more, but I have at least passing sympathy for GP's overall point. https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2011/03/23/134803230/arizona-sheriff-uses-a-tank-to-arrest-cockfighting-suspect https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo-way/2011/03/23/134803230...
- SteveGerencser 3y agoI would agree with you except I'm still paying $90/mo for 3Mb (yes, meg) DSL from the only copper provider in the area and have been hearing from them for nearly a decade that 'fiber is coming' soon. Every time someone makes progress on providing an alternative (the local electric company has tried most recently) they have been fought HARD by the local phone company. I've even looked at renting an office in the next town over to set up my own point to point wireless solution after the local phone company quoted me $5000 per MONTH for a 10Mb service.
- jahlove 3y agoDoes any state (short of maybe California, I suppose) make it on the front page of HN as much as Colorado?
- simlevesque 3y agoNew York ?
- hesdeadjim 3y agoWell, we're a very polarized red/blue state, a tech hub, and the source of most of the water for the entire southwest.
- kyrra 3y agoColorado has not been a purple state in 8+ years and is going more solid blue by the year. In the 2022 election, there was one thought to be close statewide election. It was a blowout, 55.9% dem, 41.3% GOP. The 2020 presidential election had very similar results. https://www.politico.com/2022-election/results/colorado/ https://www.politico.com/2022-election/results/colorado/
- hesdeadjim 3y agoAggregate stats are nice when it comes to presidential, but we still have a bunch of reps like Boebert who cause havoc in DC.
- caseyohara 3y agoAggregate stats give a clearer picture of statewide politics though. Boebert wasn't elected by the whole state, only the 3rd district. And we have two Democratic senators now. That's perhaps the best indicator that Colorado is hardly polarized.
- eyelidlessness 3y agoSure, but every US state has such a local split. It’s relative to the proportion and size of dense urban areas, and has been at least since the early aughts. But every “coastal liberal” state (or whatever the “blue state” signifier is) swings sharply conservative as you trek out to less populated areas, with very rare exception. And every “red state” has at least a small island that deviates leftish, even Wyoming.
- dabluecaboose 3y agoI had a brief moment of hope that this might mean decent internet would be available to me, before remembering the entire reason I don't have fiber internet in-unit is because my condo HOA is a bunch of boomers who turned down the install. Kickin' it 2007-style with my DSL
- samtho 3y agoThis is infuriating and would have led me to start a smear campaign against the leadership ultimately leading to a vote of no confidence.
- dabluecaboose 3y agoAs a filthy renter, I have very little leverage with the HOA unfortunately.
- jancsika 3y agoThis is infuriating, and if I were a filthy renter would have led me to start a smear campaign against the leadership ultimately leading to a vote of no confidence. And this being HN, the odds are high that you or someone you're close with already knows precisely how to leverage the outrage of boomers to your advantage. Think of it like stealing from the rich to give back symmetric broadband to the rich. You'll become a legend of the HOA; babies and access points will be named in your honor.
- dabluecaboose 3y agoMy landlord is actually a former ISP contractor, and he told me I should put up flyers for Ting and just get everyone to ask the HOA why we didn't have it... But that sounds like work and my lease is up in March anyway
- ilyt 3y ago> Senate Bill 152 was promoted by the cable industry as a way to prevent wasting taxpayer money on infrastructure projects, like municipal internet. Yes, I'm sure it was to "not waste taxpayers money" and not to remove competition... Hell, why cable companies had a say in that in at all?
- kevviiinn 3y agoBecause in a capitalist society, capital owners are in control
- DubiousPusher 3y ago
- linsomniac 3y agoI'm in Fort Collins and have had city fiber for a couple years now and it's a game changer. We got it during earlyish covid and having 4 of us on video calls was bringing Comcast gig service to it's knees, I imagine because of the limited outbound bandwidth. The city fiber service is gigabit symmetric, no caps, $70/mo, or 10gig for $200/mo. They also are introducing a 2.5gbps, I think that's $100. I'm working on upgrading my internal network to be able to take advantage of upgrading to 10gig. And one of the best parts is that when I had a weird networking issue, I was on the phone with a legit networking person in 15 minutes, rather than stuck with someone who couldn't do anything more than read from a script. The issue ended up being a Comcast routing issue, which I told them from the top, but figured they'd like a heads-up about it. Me and one of my coworkers on the city fiber couldn't reach the office on Comcast, but 2 other coworkers also on city fiber could. I eventually got ahold of a Comcast Business network engineer later that day and they had it resolved the next day.
- throwbadubadu 3y ago> 4 of us on video calls was bringing Comcast gig service to it's knees, I imagine because of the limited outbound bandwidth...upgrading to 10gig Huh, what? Stop imagining and do the math with numbers, maybe Comcast is shitty in general and other metrics.. but still doing here regularly 2 concurrent video calls with sometimes Netflix on top without any issues... on 50 Mbit still! (also asymmetric btw, I may be undemanding, but so a bit wtf on reading that) (Or Comcast cable internet? There is often more bandwidth sharing involved than they tell, especially upstream, or what does gig service mean?)
- froggit 3y agoComcast gig is 1gb/s downstream. I don't know what the upstream rate is and they avoid mentioning it, but based on my experience with them I could see 4 video calls being enough to choke it. It's hard to really appreciate the symmetric data rate until you really start using some decent upstream traffic, then it becomes a day and night kind of difference.
- 3y ago
- DubiousPusher 3y agoIt's weird but there used to be a lot of private roads. I hope one day we'll see private internet infrastructure as just as weird.
- charcircuit 3y agoPrivate roads aren't weird most people use them every day as that is how most people reach homes or businesses they wish to visit.
- DubiousPusher 3y agoYou know what I mean.
- bombcar 3y agoWe have a local quasi-municipal phone/Internet provider and they're about twice as much as 500/500 fiber that just got laid, and I'm getting hard pressed to stay with them even though I like the idea. Maybe I should call and ask if I can keep my current service at the fiber prices.
- japanuspus 3y agoIn Denmark we now have an infrastructure / network-provider split on fibre, so that one company provides the physical infrastructure and then there is an open marked for network providers to provide services over that fibre. Physical last-mile infrastructure is owned and operated by utility companies (privately operated non-profits), typically together with electricity or water, but in some areas by specialized fibre utility companies. This setup requires a mature technology, but it has been very effective in driving consumer costs down.
- argulane 3y agoIn Estonia we are trying to do similar thing with infra/isp split. Coverage is limited but already those places can get 1Gbit internet 3X cheaper than others.
- ExoticPearTree 3y agoYes, this is one of best ways to do fiber. The fiber provider digs all the trenches and runs fiber to every building/house in the city and then you as an end-user can contract the internet service from whichever provider you want. The costs are minimal and in my neck of the woods I pay about $10 for 1Gbps (actual rates being about 950mbps down and about 800mbps up).
- gkanai 3y agoJapan does this for fiber too. You pay an annual fee for the fiber itself and a separate fee for the ISP to provide the bits. Provides a lot of competition for the ISP-portion and Japan's had gigabit FTTH earlier than most (it helps that Japan's geography is such that most people are in major cities.)