2 ms·
It's not like this undoes the CWA, it's more about trying to solidify where it applies. The main issue is the lack of clarity around the definition and the rat
by verdverm 3y ago
It's not like this undoes the CWA, it's more about trying to solidify where it applies.
The main issue is the lack of clarity around the definition and the rather significant fines ($60k / day) that can be imposed on someone who moved some dirt.
Part of what the court wants is for congress to define the law rather than putting that in the hands of ever changing, appointed officials in a federal agency.
--- start of the majority opinion
This case concerns a nagging question about the outer
reaches of the Clean Water Act (CWA), the principal federal
law regulating water pollution in the United States. By all
accounts, the Act has been a great success. Before its enactment in 1972, many of the Nation’s rivers, lakes, and
streams were severely polluted, and existing federal legislation had proved to be inadequate. Today, many formerly
fetid bodies of water are safe for the use and enjoyment of
the people of this country.
There is, however, an unfortunate footnote to this success
story: the outer boundaries of the Act’s geographical reach
have been uncertain from the start. The Act applies to “the
waters of the United States,” but what does that phrase
mean? Does the term encompass any backyard that is
soggy enough for some minimum period of time? Does it
reach “mudflats, sandflats, wetlands, sloughs, prairie potholes, wet meadows, [or] playa lakes?” How about ditches,
swimming pools, and puddles?
For more than a half century, the agencies responsible for
enforcing the Act have wrestled with the problem and
adopted varying interpretations. On three prior occasions,
this Court has tried to clarify the meaning of “the waters of
the United States.” But the problem persists. When we
last addressed the question 17 years ago, we were unable to
agree on an opinion of the Court. Today, we return to the
problem and attempt to identify with greater clarity what
the Act means by “the waters of the United States.”
--- later
Second, the EPA’s interpretation gives rise to serious
vagueness concerns in light of the CWA’s criminal penalties. Due process requires Congress to define penal statutes
“‘with sufficient definiteness that ordinary people can understand what conduct is prohibited’” and “‘in a manner
that does not encourage arbitrary and discriminatory enforcement.’”