3 ms·
I know that for now, tape wins versus optical (Blu-Ray Recordable etc.) in terms of cost. Do people expect that to always be the case, or is anybody expecting
by crazygringo 3y ago
I know that for now, tape wins versus optical (Blu-Ray Recordable etc.) in terms of cost.
Do people expect that to always be the case, or is anybody expecting tape to have been supplanted by something else (optical or other) 20 or 30 years from now?
Or is there just something about the physics of tape technology that we can't even imagine anything else in the medium-future that could even begin to compete with it for archival needs?
(Knowing nothing about the area, just as a consumer I would have expected that with the advent of 2-layer DVD's and then 4-layer Blu-Rays, that before too long we'd be getting 1,000-layer discs and essentially moving into 3D storage cylinders by now or something that would have left tape in the dust...)
- codemac 3y agoOptical vs. Tape is only a discussion if you intend to archive (and not read!) your data for years. This is a very uncommon workload, and thus the size of the optical market is much smaller than necessary to get the COGS down. The vast majority of even backup data is legally required to either be readable in a very short amount of time (say one week) or is required to be deleted within 90 days. Neither of these are ideal for optical (or tape btw, thus why it's YoY growth is only 5% in this LTO marketing piece)
- RobotToaster 3y ago>The vast majority of even backup data is legally required to either be readable in a very short amount of time (say one week) or is required to be deleted within 90 days. Neither of these are ideal for optical Wouldn't an autoloader solve the the former, and a fire solve the latter?
- codemac 3y agoYou are assuming the data is compacted such that the 90day data is grouped by expiration date. This is not how production deletion works at any reasonable scale where cost of media matters. In reality, the data is all mixed up because data gets backed up usually around the time it's written, and gets deleted in a completely different pattern. The art of compaction is very important, and things like optical and tape make inaccurate compaction extremely expensive due to the reduced IO. And even if we pretend you do have perfect compaction, you still don't have nearly the IO that HDD would provide. Considering hypothetically you have perfect compaction, that also means you have the perfectly smallest live data set, and thus the HDD premium is even smaller for wildly better throughput in disaster.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]