2 ms·
I'll do you one better, and explain it in Ryan Dahl's words [0]. Getting away from NPM, node_modules, and package.json was one of a very small number of foundin
by lolinder 3y ago
I'll do you one better, and explain it in Ryan Dahl's words [0]. Getting away from NPM, node_modules, and package.json was one of a very small number of founding principles for Deno as he introduced it:
> Linking to a package requires a lot of components, a lot of systems. The problem that I have with [package.json] is that it gives rise to this concept of a module as this directory of files, where that wasn't really a concept before, where we just had JavaScript files. ... It's not a strictly necessary abstraction. And package.json has all this unnecessary noise in it.
> ...
> [In] Deno I want to simplify the module system, so screw all this stuff about how Node modules work... it can't be compatible with Node, otherwise you end up building Node, so there's no attempt at compatibility with existing software.
[0] https://youtu.be/M3BM9TB-8yA?t=1256 https://youtu.be/M3BM9TB-8yA?t=1256
- roqi 3y ago[flagged]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- lolinder 3y agoI linked to the second half of the quotation. The first half was far from a passing comment, he spends a solid 3 minutes on his substantial problems with package.json: https://youtu.be/M3BM9TB-8yA?t=589 https://youtu.be/M3BM9TB-8yA?t=589 That first half is essential for understanding the second half. It sounds like a passing comment if you didn't watch both segments because he's assuming you already have the context for why he's ditching node. Since you're assuming bad faith I won't be monitoring this thread any more. If you'd like to have longer, substantive discussions on HN, I'd suggest knocking off the name calling.
- tomjakubowski 3y ago> The problem that I have with [package.json] is that it gives rise to this concept of a module as this directory of files, where that wasn't really a concept before, where we just had JavaScript files > > [In] Deno I want to simplify the module system, so screw all this stuff about how Node modules work... it can't be compatible with Node, otherwise you end up building Node, so there's no attempt at compatibility with existing software. I think that Deno's module system is still incompatible with Node's: supplying a node_modules directory of files in your project root, at run time or at build time, still won't work. Deno is now just doing the work to ingest npm packages and process them into Deno modules at build time, if you want to use them. That doesn't seem out of line with Dahl's vision to me.