3 ms·
> your account is frozen but we won't tell you why If they suspect fraud, they aren't allowed to tell you about it. They also aren't allowed to give you your
by londons_explore 3y ago
> your account is frozen but we won't tell you why
If they suspect fraud, they aren't allowed to tell you about it. They also aren't allowed to give you your money back (incase the money is laundered).
The only way to get your money back is to get a court to order them to give it back. The process is fairly simple - go to a small claims court, and ask the court to order them to give the money back. They won't contest it, they will just return your money and close the account.
That way, if it turns out that it wasn't your money, or you are a terrorist, paypal is no longer liable - they were just doing what the court ordered.
- foooorsyth 3y agoPretty amazing how nonchalant you’re talking about theft. I guess the approved strategy for legal theft is as follows. 1. Create a payments company that accepts deposits and holds balances (a bank — but don’t call it that) 2. Create a broken AML algorithm that flags X% of deposits as fraud 3. Force the falsely accused to take you to court to get their money back 4. Keep the rest. Most people won’t contest What a great “business” model.
- G3rn0ti 3y agoI think they are required by law to do so. At least in the US.
- denton-scratch 3y agoWhat law?
- G3rn0ti 3y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bank_Secrecy_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bank_Secrecy_Act "A financial institution is not allowed to inform a business or consumer that a SAR [suspicious activity report] is being filed." Laws like this exist in many countries (including my own) that turn banks into agents spying their customers on behalf of the government. Calling it even a "bank secrecy act" is downright cynical. I understand that law enforcement agencies need to be able to go after criminals but I think the balance between freedom and security has been way off for a long time already. That's exactly the reason why Switzerland used to have the strictest bank secrecy laws world wide. It was not to become a safe haven for criminals but to maintain the financial freedom of its citizens.
- milesskorpen 3y ago(1) would not be legal without an enormous amount of work.
- ascar 3y agoYour comment is ironic considering PayPal does exactly that and is in fact not a bank. They are licensed as a money transmitter.
- milesskorpen 3y agoSure. I didn't say it was impossible or that they needed to be a bank. Getting licensed as a money transmitter is really challenging.
- londons_explore 3y agoYou don't get to keep the money yourself. It sits on your balance sheet as a liability for 7 years, and eventually gets classed as a dormant account and gets paid to the state treasury.
- bhelkey 3y agoThis isn't my wheelhouse but couldn't one put the money in a money market account and keep the interest?
- ascar 3y agoYou assume malice. It's not. They're just covering their asses. They earn magnitudes more on the transaction fees of legitimate purchases than they could ever get from stealing money through that scheme. Not even considering that the frozen money isn't even theirs to use but a liability in their accounting.
- foooorsyth 3y agoAmazing how my bank never had this issue. I’ve sent ACH, wires, checks, and Zelles left and right with my major bank for years and years. No issues. Yet my PayPal account that I used twice and had a $6 balance got closed permanently. Along with millions of others. >You assume malice. It’s not. Yes it is. Like many tech companies, they’ve “algorithm’d” something that used to take human investigation work. And their algorithm sucks. Their support sucks. This is all intentional so they can save money on labor. So they’re not stealing my money directly. So what? They’re freezing my funds and forcing me to take them to court so they can operate with lower labor costs. That’s theft — it doesn’t matter if they don’t use my money. If I rob you of some cash and then burn it, is it not still robbery?
- p-e-w 3y ago> If they suspect fraud, they aren't allowed to tell you about it. That sounds like bullshit. Why would a mere suspicion of fraud, in the absence of a subpoena or court/gag order, mean that they aren't allowed to tell the account holder that they are suspecting fraud?
- refurb 3y agoCorrect. Look up the laws on suspicious activity reporting. If they came back and said "oh, we banned you because you made multiple, small transaction to high risk countries", well then you could just not do it next time.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- gambiting 3y agoMonzo have a very informative article about it, explains what this looks like from the side of the bank. They are literally not allowed to tell you, and also the other interesting thing is that they see how skilled fraudsters are at social engineering - the kind of posts that sometime surface here on HN "my bank/google/paypal blocked my account and they won't help me!" - it's not that every one of them is a scam, but fraudsters are incredibly good at writing those across social media and putting pressure on companies to unblock them. https://monzo.com/blog/2019/04/04/why-we-block-freeze-close-monzo-accounts https://monzo.com/blog/2019/04/04/why-we-block-freeze-close-...
- jstanley 3y ago> well then you could just not do it next time. Isn't that what they want?
- 2fast4you 3y agoThey want you to not commit fraud, they also want to catch you if you do
- londons_explore 3y ago
- dfxm12 3y agoThe process is fairly simple - go to a small claims court, and ask the court to order them to give the money back. Where I'm from you gotta file in person and there's a fee for filing and you pay someone to serve the defendant. Then you gotta show up at the court date. That's a bunch of fees and two days off from work before you even get a decision. I understand that this is the process, but it's not so simple for a lot of people to take days off from work, come up with money for fees (especially if their paypal is frozen), etc. It just doesn't serve the regular Joe all that well.