4 ms·
How Big Oil is manipulating the way you think about climate change
- sokoloff 3y agoI think most people would agree that when I eat beef, I’m responsible for (part of) the slaughter of a cow. If I fuel my stove, boiler, or car from fossil fuels, the same argument applies. I recently tried to convert my old boiler to an electric air-to-water heat pump. While technically feasible, it would have cost over $20K more than a 96% gas combi (after incentives) and would have been more difficult to have serviced over the next 20 years of projected life (fewer experienced providers and worse parts lead-time). The economic payback period was literally never and with my grid being 64% fossil fuel now and majority fossil fuel when that equipment would be replaced, the fossil fuel reduction would be minimal. I was a relatively early adopter of EVs in 2014. That’s been overall a positive experience but, as above, I’m just outsourcing the buying of fossil fuel at the moment and for the useful life of that car. If you want people to change their behavior, make it at least one of more convenient or cheaper. Maybe that means taxing fossil fuels more and increasing that over time. Maybe that means more incentives for green alternatives. Saying the fossil fuel industry is causing X damage while changing nothing on the demand side may smugly feel good, but isn’t going to effect lasting change the way that demand reduction [edit to add: for fossil fuels] will.
- danpalmer 3y agoI’m skeptical of demand reduction. History shows that we keep finding more ways to use energy to improve our lives. We’re unlikely at a global scale to reduce lifestyle to reduce energy usage. We’ve got a big enough problem here with meat eating, where there isn’t a substantially lower carbon option and we’ll probably just have to move to more plant based diets. For energy consumption it seems much easier to me for us to replace energy generation with green alternatives. I was skeptical of this 10 years ago, but we’ve since seen huge rollouts of wind and solar, the near phasing out of coal in many countries, and continually dropping prices for the necessary hardware. We need to accelerate these, but this feels feasible.
- sokoloff 3y agoSorry. I wasn’t clear enough. I meant demand reduction for specifically fossil fuels (to include indirect fossil fuels used for electricity generation), not for energy in general. That includes making it economically advantageous to choose electricity as the local source while accelerating the greening of the grid. That is frequently not the most advantageous choice for consumers now, and we should not be surprised when they choose what’s most advantageous for them.
- jdsnape 3y agoThis is happening in the UK at the moment. I'm not an expert, but my undestanding is that there is an incentive plan to reduce the cost of install electical heatpumps, with the goal that the increased volume reduces the price over time. The sale of new gas/oil fired boilers will only be allowed for a few more years. This means that as the grid is made greener there is an increased impact in terms of reduced emissions overall.
- hodgeheg 3y agoEven with the government grant taken into account it would cost me £3,000 to have a heat pump installed at my house. The running costs would be around £500-600 a year more than I'm paying to heat my home with gas at present, and that's with my gas bill having almost trebled over the last year and a bit. Financially, as things stand, it would be lunacy for me to scrap the gas boiler in favour of a heat pump.
- sokoloff 3y agoGP's logic is exactly why I wanted to convert. Your findings are exactly why I didn't (only the up-front delta was about 5x worse in my case). If we can't remove the skew in the economics, it's going to be very slow to make progress.
- danpalmer 3y agoAh yes in that case I completely agree!
- ikekkdcjkfke 3y agoI believe it's just a water heat exchanger hooked up to the same tech used for air conditioning all over the world, including third world, fine tuned and adjsuted to operate the flows correctly?
- sokoloff 3y agoIt's not hard nor inherently expensive tech. The difficulty for adoption in the US is that it's positioned as a premium product, with very few vendors of equipment, very few qualified installers, low market adoption (with all the resulting service and parts availability and latency concerns that come with that). In a location with $0.25/kWh electricity, $1.91/therm gas, and ~9%/yr cost of capital, the payback period is literally never.
- bearmode 3y ago> Maybe that means taxing fossil fuels more and increasing that over time This is infeasible, there are already millions who are struggling to get by with existing energy bills, and without enough cash to upgrade to more eco-friendly systems. These people are stuck on fossil fuels, increasing taxes for it across the board is just going to cause more pain, suffering, and homelessness. A better idea would be progressive taxation built into income tax. The higher-earners also tend to be bigger polluters, so it makes sense in that regard as well.
- dmm 3y ago> there are already millions who are struggling to get by with existing energy bills Most carbon-tax proposals I've seen are revenue-neutral, meaning the carbon taxes collected are returned to people, everyone getting the same amount. The intention is to incentivize reducing carbon emissions but not destroy the poor.
- sokoloff 3y agoThere’s no (non-political) reason that we couldn’t issue a refundable tax credit of $1000/yr (or another amount) to every full-year resident and increase taxes on fossil fuels by an amount such that a median consumer of fossil fuels would break even. The purpose of the tax is to better align choices with consequences, not to raise revenue. It can be revenue-neutral or even cost money for administrative overhead.
- _aavaa_ 3y agoYou need a carbon tax, and one that also imposes itself on imports so that other countries can’t cheat. Canadians have a system similar to this. Everyone pays a carbon tax. 10% of the total pool is skimmed and used by the government for climate related things, and only climate related things. Then the rest of the money is split evenly among everyone. The poorer people come out ahead since they use less (e.g. can’t afford a car and take public transit) and thus paid less than the average but receive the average amount back.
- 3y ago
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- acdha 3y ago> I think most people would agree that when I eat beef, I’m responsible for (part of) the slaughter of a cow. > If I fuel my stove, boiler, or car from fossil fuels, the same argument applies. To make this analogy work, you’d need the beef industry to have spent half a century pouring billions of dollars into campaigns denying that cows are being slaughtered (“they were just going to die of natural causes anyway!”). I agree that the right fix is to start pricing externalities into things but the decades of denial mean that the easy gradual options are no longer feasible. If we’d acted 3-4 decades ago when the climate science consensus was settled we’d have had the option to decarbonize much less disruptively. On the heat pump front, one big factor to consider is the relative efficiencies and switching costs. Power plants are professionally maintained and everything I’ve read says that you’ll almost always emit fewer greenhouse gases using electricity from the grid rather than burning fuel at home (or in your car), especially factoring in that things like natural gas leaks aren’t affected by efficiency improvements in equipment. Each new fossil fuel device locks in pollution for multiple decades, whereas electricity is fungible so each new clean option coming online will increase the amount of time that your grid power is producing less emissions than it does now. Given the cost advantages in many markets, that trend is only going to accelerate.
- sokoloff 3y agoYour last paragraph is spot-on! That's why it's so tragic that the economics are so unfavorable for air-to-water heat pumps in the US right now. I have a new combi boiler on the wall now (which was eligible for a rebate from my local utility company!). Hopefully when it comes time to replace it (in about 2042), the economics will have shifted to make an A2W competitive as its replacement.
- Aromasin 3y ago> you’d need the beef industry to have spent half a century pouring billions of dollars into campaigns denying that cows are being slaughtered Not quite half a century - they are a bit behind the times when in comes to climate lobbying - but they sure as hell spend. I've met a couple of farm lobbyists during my short time in local government, and they're not doing poorly on the financial front. To quote a favored WP article of mine on the subject: "The North American Meat Institute, insisting that there is “much uncertainty” about climate change, publishes “fact sheets” that selectively count only manure management and animal digestion byproducts as contributors to emissions. The National Cattlemen’s Beef Association website includes an animated explainer, “Tough questions about beef sustainability,” that minimizes the industry’s role in environmental problems, from water use to carbon emissions. In response to congressional plans to address climate issues or reports calling for dietary changes, these groups contend that the beef supply chain has environmental benefits, such as cultivating soil for carbon storage. They also point to data showing that farmers and ranchers have become more efficient, producing meat and poultry using fewer resources. Changing food consumption, they contend, is not a “silver bullet.”.... ... Sara Place, a scientist who worked for the National Cattleman’s Beef Association, preemptively wrote an article on “Why Taxing Beef Isn’t the Answer.” What unfolded with fossil fuels suggests at least one path for meat and dairy. Instead of clean coal, the industry might tout carbon-neutral beef, regenerative agriculture and responsible grazing. Just as natural gas from fracking was presented as a “bridge fuel,” we might expect marketing to encourage consumers to switch to “bridge meats” like chicken or salmon (which, like natural gas, have their own significant environmental impacts). The agricultural industry will also invest in technological solutions — such as an algae diet to reduce methane in cattle — to avoid making more substantial changes that would hurt its bottom line." Same shit with a different coat of greenwashing paint. See article here: https://www.washingtonpost.com/outlook/the-meat-industry-is-doing-exactly-what-big-oil-does-to-fight-climate-action/2021/05/14/831e14be-b3fe-11eb-ab43-bebddc5a0f65_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/outlook/the-meat-industry-is-...
- revelio 3y agoSalon presents this article by a "professor of logic". She presents three pieces of evidence of manipulation by Big Oil: 1. "Another example of this subterfuge, also from the fossil fuel world, is the idea of carbon sequestration" 2. CO2 footprint calculators. 3. The UN Climate Change Conference. To this Highly Credentialed Expert In Logic all the above are examples of manipulation by Big Oil. Meanwhile, outside the ivory tower: https://apnews.com/article/science-business-arts-and-entertainment-journalism-united-states-087d1d5dd7189c529fe5d7a21a1ffb5f https://apnews.com/article/science-business-arts-and-enterta... The Associated Press said Tuesday that it is assigning more than two dozen journalists across the world to cover climate issues, in the news organization’s largest single expansion paid for through philanthropic grants. The grant is for more than $8 million over three years, and about 20 of the climate journalists will be new hires “This far-reaching initiative will transform how we cover the climate story,” Pace said. It’s the most recent of a series of grants the AP has received since the mid-2010s to boost coverage in health and science, religion, water issues and philanthropy itself. Some 50 AP journalists have jobs funded through grants. For many years, Journalists and philanthropists were more wary of each other. News organizations were concerned about maintaining independence and, until the past two decades, financially secure enough not to need help. Philanthropists didn’t see the need, or how journalists could help them achieve their goals. Nonprofit news organizations like ProPublica and Texas Tribune led the way in changing minds. The Salt Lake Tribune, which in 2019 became a nonprofit to attract more donors, and The Seattle Times are other pioneers. Ms Moore says: "You have to be alert and you have to be smart, I tell my students, because the people who would deceive you are sophisticated professionals". Quite.
- Biologist123 3y agoThe AP article you linked to doesn’t actually name the providers of the grants.
- revelio 3y ago"Five organizations are contributing to the effort: the William and Flora Hewlett Foundation, the Howard Hughes Medical Institute, Quadrivium, the Rockefeller Foundation and the Walton Family Foundation."
- bebeneezer 3y ago[flagged]
- joemazerino 3y agoI have a mental blockage with the climate change argument(s). While rationally founded, the West can't just constantly handicap itself when 2nd and 1st world countries are the largest carbon emitters. I'd like to see global opt-in rather than just constantly harping on one side of the hemisphere.
- rat9988 3y agoTwo things, first it depends of the western country we are talking about. Luxembourg and USA have a too high emission per capita compared to the rest. Second, I'm not sure why you see it as a handicap, it's not you vs them? If you are worried their cheaper bad climate good can eat your market just put some carbon tax or whatever polluants we are talking about.
- joenot443 3y agoI'm happy to be proven wrong, but my understanding is that the atmosphere itself doesn't really care about "per capita", absolute numbers are what matters. I'd imagine Vatican City has an even higher emission per capita than nearly anywhere else, but it would be silly to pretend that's where we should prioritize policy change. As it stands, the one country produces more CO2 than the following 7 combined. That number is only set to increase. If our goal is a global reduction, should that not be where we focus the majority of our political energy? If Luxembourg went down to net 0 emissions, my understanding is effectively no difference would be made on a global scale.
- rat9988 3y agoThe problem with your reasoning is that you think that the atmosphere problem is a problem that should be equally burdened by every country, whereas it should be equally burdened by every human. There is no reason that people that are inmore populated countries should be burdened more than people in less populated ones.
- joemazerino 3y ago
- faffffaf 3y agoI love the religious overtones of this, especially as I was brought up devout Christian and have a good familiarity with the Old Testament prophets and the Book of Revelation. Here, the author is warning us of the promised false prophets and deceivers, who do the work of the Enemy in its long and shadowy struggle with The Science. Only those who follow the True Path will enlighten humanity, navigate our pending Doom, and guide us into the prosperous Green Age.
- SQueeeeeL 3y agoI have no idea what argument this comment is trying to make. All the comments in this thread seem to be pretty wild, so this is probably another one of those "Hacker News becomes unhinged when you bring up topic X" situations.
- joenot443 3y agoI don't think they're trying to make an argument, just broadly observing that the article has some similarities to some Biblical themes. I didn't see it as unhinged or wild, just a very tame observation. I'm curious what part of their comment bothered you so much?
- giraffe_lady 3y agoIt's probably the unstated implication that because the argument may share some similarities to religious principals it can be straightforwardly dismissed as having no value. This assumes that both religion has no value, and that things resembling religion, possibly in any way, have no value. This is unrigorous, because a lot of things resemble religion generally or specific religious practice in various ways and have value despite or sometimes because of that resemblance. And annoying also because a lot of people find value in their religious beliefs and it's petty to dismiss that common experience.
- faffffaf 3y ago>have value despite or sometimes because of that resemblance What kinds of value? Personal reflection and growth? Community cohesiveness? The construction of inspirational and grandiose places of worship? How would these be useful values to the cause of Climate Change? >It's probably the unstated implication that because the argument may share some similarities to religious principals it can be straightforwardly dismissed as having no value. Nearly. It's that the root causes and values of such societal constructs and shared value sets might be quite different than we expect at face value.
- witchesindublin 3y agoA big issue that I have with the current discourse on environmentalism is the idea that individuals should do small things before the institutions do big things. For example using any gas appliances less without first converting all power plants to renewable. The first aim should be to convert all power plants to renewable and build automated recycling plants and incinerators, then move on to ensuring all transportation is clean by building more public transport and banning non-electric cars.
- lesuorac 3y agoAh yes, instead of having people do things that they can do within a year lets not do any of those things until somebody spends decades building enough power plants to replace all of our current ones. You should look up Critical Path [1]. If you want to go things done faster, creating a long critical path is not a good idea. Of course, if you want the status quo to stay the same it's a great idea. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Critical_path_method https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Critical_path_method
- sharemywin 3y agocouldn't all of the above work? personal responsibility is important but collective responsibility is important too. Just like you should try not to mug people in the park it's probably a good idea to pass laws that make it illegal too.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- toddbonzalez1 3y agoThis idea came from a marketing campaign from BP: https://mashable.com/feature/carbon-footprint-pr-campaign-sham https://mashable.com/feature/carbon-footprint-pr-campaign-sh...
- gs17 3y ago
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- entropicgravity 3y agoClimate change has to main components, temperature and CO2, which are related by the relationship burning fossil fuels creates CO2 which increases the world's average temperature. This much has been known for over one hundred years. Over the past five years though the situation has radically changed in the financial sense. That is, the cost of wind and solar energy (and HVDC transmission) has dropped precipitously and in response the amount new installations has been going by 30 to 50 percent a year. Most large projects are now being bid at between one and two cents a kilowatt hour! To clarify, that means that the company that bids on these projects commit to selling the power produced at a rate of 1 to 2 cents a kWh, for solar, for TWENTY YEARS. And it's about 4 to 5 cents per kWh for new wind projects. And the winning bidder expects to make a profit at these rates. Today the consumer is paying between 10 to 50 cents per kWh depending on country etc. The stunning consequence of this is that green power is already way cheaper than power produced by fossil fuels, and it's only going to get better. In fact it's so cheap that in some jurisdictions it's cheaper to mothball a perfectly fine coal burning generator and switch over the green energy. This is already happening. In essence then the war on climate change has already been won for all intents and purposes. Even five years ago this was not the case. There is still the tricky problem of being able to deploy enough green energy quickly enough to squeeze through the eye of the climate needle. But it's now longer how but when. Sometimes technology can run you over from the back while you're looking ahead.