3 ms·
> No known bugs This is the part that I doubt will ever be achieved by any system or structure of moderate complexity or above. Everything that exists in the r
by lolinder 3y ago
> No known bugs
This is the part that I doubt will ever be achieved by any system or structure of moderate complexity or above. Everything that exists in the real world has problems with it. If it's a building or a machine, then it's done once it's built unless there are major safety issues. The cost of fixing non-critical issues in a physical product is too high to justify.
The problem with software is that the marginal cost of "one more fix" is close to zero, which means that declaring something "done" means drawing a somewhat arbitrary line in the sand. Why is this new complaint less important than the similarly-scoped one that you fixed last week? There's not really a good answer to this question, so there's never a good day to say that you're not fixing anything more.
- jonhohle 3y ago> If it's a building or a machine, then it's done once it's built… Modern construction requires a significant amount of maintenance. The Romans on the other hand, they knew how to build a building!
- lolinder 3y agoThat's fair, but we'd still consider the building to be "done" in the sense that OP means—the construction crew can go home. When I refer to problems that go unaddressed I'm thinking of problems like "this bathroom is too small", not "the roof needs replacing".
- rodgerd 3y ago> Modern construction requires a significant amount of maintenance. I was raised with the rule of thumb that you should budget 1% of the purchase price of a house for maintenance; while that's roughly true for my century-old villa that I purchased at the turn of the century, I suspect that the hockey-stick of residential housing has made it a bit inaccurate. And something that I didn't really understand until an architect cousin explained to me is that modern commercial buildings mostly have a designed lifespan, typically 50-100 years.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jonhohle 3y agoYeah, modern commercial buildings suck compared to many of the old skyscrapers and government buildings built >100 years ago. The Empire State Building, the capitol building, grand central station, etc. Just walking through them you can tell by the materials and craftsmanship that they were built to last. Modern buildings, on the other hand, feel cheap and their unlimited flexibility leaves them with no inherent character.
- asperous 3y agoThere's a bit of irony with this thread I think but this was Minix's creator's viewpoint as well: https://www.cs.vu.nl/~ast/Publications/Papers/computer-2006a.pdf https://www.cs.vu.nl/~ast/Publications/Papers/computer-2006a...
- toast0 3y ago> No known bugs That's too high a standard. If nothing else, differences of opinion over the design are sometimes classified as bugs. No known bugs worth the effort to fix and deploy is acheivable. Most NES software is done, none of the bugs are worth recalling to update roms.
- bombcar 3y agoTeX and METAFONT are designed to be "done" when Knuth dies: > At the time of my death, it is my intention that the then-current versions of TEX and METAFONT be forever left unchanged, except that the final version numbers to be reported in the “banner” lines of the programs should become TeX, Version $\pi$ and METAFONT, Version $e$ respectively. From that moment on, all “bugs” will be permanent “features.”
- lolinder 3y agoHah, that's a pretty reasonable way to define done.
- bombcar 3y agoConsidering the last list of bugs: https://tug.org/texmfbug/tuneup21bugs.html https://tug.org/texmfbug/tuneup21bugs.html I think he's getting pretty close to perfection - his report on it https://tug.org/TUGboat/tb42-1/tb130knuth-tuneup21.pdf https://tug.org/TUGboat/tb42-1/tb130knuth-tuneup21.pdf and hopefully he'll live to do the next one in 2029. His dedication to the unchanging format is important, I can compile ancient TeX documents that are almost older than I am with no changes, and I can compile LaTeX documents almost as easily.