4 ms·
Well, ULA needs some big DoD contract to launch heavy objects. Military solid state lasers are finally getting powerful enough to be useful. Below 100KW, they
by Animats 3y ago
Well, ULA needs some big DoD contract to launch heavy objects.
Military solid state lasers are finally getting powerful enough to be useful. Below 100KW, they weren't effective enough, and it took decades to get the power up. Northrop-Grumman delivered a 150KW laser to the Navy in 2021.
Lockheed-Martin delivered a 300KW demo unit last year.[1] These are ground or sea based. Israel's Iron Beam system tried lasers, but below 100KW, and only useful against small rockets and drones. Since that's what their opposition shoots at them, it's useful.
Space-based lasers have lots of problems, from cooling to being big targets themselves.
But they're a much less silly idea than they were in the 1980s.
We may be seeing the biggest reversal in war since late WWI - defense may be stronger than offense again. Historically, this has gone back and forth. In the era of castles, defense was stronger. Then came artillery. WWI started out with defense being stronger - nobody could advance against machine guns. Then came tanks and the beginnings of air power. Offense has usually been stronger since then. Now we're entering an era where nobody has air superiority. There's a mostly empty sky. If it flies, it dies. On the ground, tanks are now very vulnerable to man-portable weapons.
When defense is stronger, wars lead to bloody stalemates, like Ukraine. Nobody can force a decision.
Battles are long, bloody and destructive. The winning side gets to own the ruins.
[1] https://newatlas.com/military/lockheed-martin-delivers-record-300-kw-laser-weapon-to-us-military https://newatlas.com/military/lockheed-martin-delivers-recor...
- mabbo 3y ago> Now we're entering an era where nobody has air superiority. There's a mostly empty sky. If it flies, it dies. The danger here is everyone filling space with satellites as a means of defense. When the war starts, Kessler Syndrome kicks in, and everyone loses their defenses in a few days. Ground based lasers may have less range, etc, but they can be hardened, protected, even hidden. Imho, we'll see a day where every major city on the planet has a set of anti missile lasers.
- frumper 3y agoHow about moon based lasers?
- chrisco255 3y agoHow else are we going to defend the 51st state?
- mabbo 3y agoThat only covers half the earth! We'd need another set of lasers at the earth-moon L3 point. (Also the distance would be a problem for a variety of reasons)
- ars 3y ago> When the war starts, Kessler Syndrome kicks in No, these defenses would be in low orbit, and low orbits are rapidly self cleaning. Kessler Syndrome is only for high orbits. There no reason for an attacking missile to go into a high orbit, they would stay pretty low.
- mabbo 3y agoWhile I agree that these would be in a lower orbit, if they are low enough that debris would fall quickly then so would satellites. Debris doesn't know it's debris and so it should fall when the satellite did not. Yes, some satellites can self-boost with ion drives giving them longer life in lower orbits, but they can't do that very often or for very long due to reaction mass limits. You're still talking about orbits where debris would last years.
- PeterisP 3y agoNo, debris in the same orbit would fall much more quickly than satellites, due to the square/cube difference, a larger piece gets slowed much less than many smaller pieces with the same combined mass. Also, "the same orbit" is the best/worst case scenario, since after an impact any new orbit still passes through the point of impact, but if the new orbit is more elliptic than the original (which most likely was close to circular), then it has a lower perigee, where most of the drag occurs, and thus would get dragged down faster than in the original orbit. If a satellite is in a low orbit that needs re-boosting every few years, then the debris from its destruction would get cleared out in weeks or months.
- panick21_ 3y agoYou can not have Kessler Syndrom as early as you think. And even then not on all orbits. If you deploy defensively, you can keep sats working fine even Kessler Syndrom existed on some orbits. You can hide things in space as well.
- dirtyid 3y ago>We may be seeing the biggest reversal in war since late WWI Mainstream discussion so far limited to the tactic/operation layer in farflung battle fields. More pertinent is strategic layer where this desperate race for ABM is due to offensive rocketry / long range conventional strikes is increasingly openning up CONUS for attack. Which is the biggest reversal against US primacy since Revolutionary war. US homefront being ground to existential halt because ABM can't prevent adversaries from blowing up US refineries will place vast constraints on US willingness to defend interests abroad. When homelands are mutually vunerable - something US hasn't had to factor into calculations - it becomes much harder for US specifically to unilaterally force decisions, something it would otherwise do with relative impunity when adversaries could not disrupt CONUS.
- danw1979 3y ago> We may be seeing the biggest reversal in war since late WWI - defense may be stronger than offense again. Pretty sure once you’ve got that 300kW space laser up there someone is going to find an offensive use for it.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- ianburrell 3y agoLasers that shoot down missiles from space can also shoot down laser satellites in space. Lasers on the ground can be larger and more energetic, but do have to shoot through atmosphere. The article seems to talk about strategic hypersonic but I’ve mostly read about them for attacking ships and bases that are likely to have defenses. Ground point defenses might be cheaper than space constellation. I think lasers have potential to change warfare. For example, naval warfare gets really weird if lasers can shoot down missiles and maybe even shells. Do they use torpedos?