4 ms·
> We will not be releasing the usernames involved publicly or to the users themselves. Why not to the users themselves? Have they been prohibited from doing so
by jacquesm 3y ago
> We will not be releasing the usernames involved publicly or to the users themselves.
Why not to the users themselves? Have they been prohibited from doing so? (TFA does not say afaict)
- shadowgovt 3y agoThat, or they have reason to believe the investigation is legitimate and they would prefer not to hinder it.
- jacquesm 3y agoThey say very explicitly that they do not know what it was about.
- shadowgovt 3y agoThere's a wide gulf between concrete knowledge and belief. I see an ambulance going lights-and-sirens behind me. I don't know they're on their way to or from a hospital, but I pull over because I have reason to believe they are.
- junon 3y agoWeird analogy. An ambulance has a very narrow scope of responsibility. Legal processes have a very wide scope. Clearly this is related to a legal matter and not an immediate medical matter. But the nature of the legal matter could be a very wide variety of things, ranging from lower court civil proceedings up to treason, etc.
- weaksauce 3y agothey have five usernames... that can narrow down what projects they were associated with pretty quickly to infer if there was something nefarious about them. though it could be entirely unrelated to their activity on pypi and be a trawl for leads based on username similarity from some other messageboard or activity that was used for illegality. though, thinking about it more, that seems legally dubious a reason to be able to get a subpoena issued for. ianal
- CodesInChaos 3y agoThey only wrote that they weren't told what it was about. However it might be obvious from the packages uploaded by those users (e.g. if they uploaded malware).
- ruffrey 3y agoOften subpoenas are part of an ongoing investigation, and they require not releasing information to those who’s data was subpoenaed.
- stonepresto 3y agoThe why: notifying a suspect in a criminal investigation could allow them to flee or take measures to avoid prosecution, destroy evidence, etc.
- tptacek 3y agoThe subpoena probably includes a nondisclosure clause; a court order certainly would. The mechanics of nondisclosures on subpoenas is interesting and I don't totally understand it (by definition, a subpoena is a document authorized by someone other than a judge).
- jacquesm 3y agoSo is this message a way to obliquely signal to those users (whoever they are) that they may be under investigation without actual disclosure?
- tptacek 3y agoI doubt it. Most of these investigations (really: most federal computer-related investigations) are super boring, and are about things ordinary people wouldn't object to seeing investigated. We're a message board and we're thus optimized for drama over truth-seeking (it's just human nature). The truth of these kinds of events is usually not all that interesting. If it's something more dramatic, we'll hear more about it in the future. In, like, a sort of Bayesian sense, you can predict that any given subpoena or court order is going to be about a case nobody would bother sending warning signals about.
- bredren 3y ago> Most of these investigations (really: most federal computer-related investigations) are super boring, and are about things ordinary people wouldn't object to seeing investigated. This is true. The result may be so boring local news wouldn’t even cover it. In some cases you have to find the investigating agency’s unremarkable press release and then dig for related court documents to even find out what happened.
- can16358p 3y agoThat might get PyPI into trouble especially with a gag order which we can assume that they are forced to obey and forced not to talk about. PyPI would pretty much want to inform the users, but they probably simply can't (without getting into legal trouble).
- toast0 3y agoThe users themselves already know their own usernames, presumably. They could let the users know they were subpoenaed without letting them know their username. :P