3 ms·
I'm looking up the reasons why, and it seems quite complex. On the one hand, it does seem like aviation has unfair (?) advantages, in that there's no VAT on pl
by crazygringo 3y ago
I'm looking up the reasons why, and it seems quite complex.
On the one hand, it does seem like aviation has unfair (?) advantages, in that there's no VAT on plane tickets and no tax on aviation fuel.
But on the other hand, laying+maintaining railroad track (and acquiring the land) is quite expensive, while airplanes only need an airport built at either end. Plus train trips just take longer, leading to higher crew costs. And then airlines offset cheaper coach seats with expensive first-class, plus lots of upgrade fees, while the opportunities here are smaller for rail.
Does protectionism also factor in to TGV? I can't find anything on that.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> airlines offset cheaper coach seats with expensive first-class, plus lots of upgrade fees, while the opportunities here are smaller for rail The opportunities for first-class train cars are enormous and precedented. Rail requiring subsidies just makes it politically unpalatable. (The solution is to let private cars hook up to public trains for a fee. Imagine the Caltrain having a Google car instead of a Google bus on the road. Or the Four Seasons operating a fleet of luxury Amtrak cars.)
- Symbiote 3y agoYou generally can't add an extra coach to a high speed train. They are fixed in formations of 4-9 or so coaches, sometimes with one set of wheels shared between two coaches. It is more aerodynamic and safer. You can usually couple two whole sets together.
- bluGill 3y agoYou can in theory couple two whole sets together, but in practice you can't do this either because you need to rebuild all the stations along the way so the platforms are longer. You often can't even build only the busy stations bigger and seat people going to smaller stations on the one car that stops as the train will hang out of the station onto track and so some other train not stopping can't get by it.
- Symbiote 3y agoCoupling sets of 4, 5 or 6 coach trains together is done regularly. There are scheduled trains where this is done partway through the journey. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=1j2e-R1cv9w https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=1j2e-R1cv9w
- bluGill 3y agoAmtrak says they became more reliable when the stopped allowing private cars to hookup. (or they would be? I don't recall exactly what I read) Many people who own private cars have not kept up on maintenance, and if your private car breaks down the whole train stops.
- justrealist 3y agoAmtrack is so incompetently run that I would not take any statement like this at face value — what they are saying is that it's annoying tot think about and they don't want to allow it. (also, it allows them to offload some of their own unreliability onto someone else).
- DiogenesKynikos 3y ago> Plus train trips just take longer, leading to higher crew costs. I assume you're only talking about time onboard, not door-to-door time (where high-speed rail generally beats short-haul flights), so I won't dispute the time aspect. But in order to calculate crew costs, you'd have to know crew density, and my impression is that crew/passengers is several times higher for planes than trains.