3 ms·
People do this because flying can be enjoyable and fun. These are often hobbyists flying small planes. They're also not necessarily "ultra" rich. Should we als
by vel0city 3y ago
People do this because flying can be enjoyable and fun. These are often hobbyists flying small planes. They're also not necessarily "ultra" rich.
Should we also ban recreational boating? What about recreationally driving a car?
- epups 3y agoBut if we allow people to take off on a plane for fun, why shouldn't we allow people to collectively share a plane and get to their destination for a variety of reasons? This partial ban seems unfair otherwise
- vel0city 3y agoI imagine this ban doesn't affect a GA pilot taking a few of their friends along for a flight. But this is a pretty rare use, it's impact is extremely less than commercial operators doing constant flights on much larger planes every day. GA pilots generally aren't flying Airbus A320s with like 120 seats, they're flying Cessnas and Pipers with like maybe half a dozen seats. They're maybe flying every couple of days instead of back and forth a few times a day, every day of the week. Its a pretty major difference.
- epups 3y agoOk, but the commercial planes are taking a lot of people for reasons that impact commerce (tourism, business meetings, etc). A private flight for pleasure should obviously be banned before those use cases if we're purely thinking of global warming. I am against banning any aviation use btw, this is too unfair to a particular group of people and is not based on any objective standard. Any aviation restriction that doesn't start with not letting the rich have private flights is unfair.
- vel0city 3y agoThat private flight every now and then has such extremely negligible emissions compared to a whole industry of much larger planes which fly as much as economically possible. Can you really not see the difference between these two different usages?
- josephcsible 3y agoYou're right. That's yet another reason why this ban shouldn't exist at all.
- happymellon 3y agoAh, fair enough. Elsewhere there was the talk around private jets and politicians and I mixed up my usecases. I would also class flying in a completely different category to boats and cars, as emissions at altitude are significantly worse.
- vel0city 3y agoA Cessna 172 will use ~10GPH cruising. A large motorboat might use 15-30GPH. Neither one usually has a lot of emission control devices on board. Chances are that boat pulling some water skiers all day is dumping more emissions in an afternoon than a Cessna flying for a few hours.
- sidewndr46 3y agoBoats do not use leaded fuel that gets spread into the countryside. Cessnas usually do, unless converted to run on pump gas or to a turbine engine.
- vel0city 3y agoI do agree it's stupid leaded gas is still in use, it should have been phased out a long time ago. I'm just pointing out, a Cessna's GHG emissions aren't that far off (or might even be less) than a typical small recreational boat.
- sidewndr46 3y agoso you're just unashamedly carbonwashing general aviation. "It's got less GHG so it's GOOD". How about I show up at your house and sprinke lead all over it non stop every day?
- vel0city 3y agoI've written a letter to the FAA in support of getting rid of leaded gas. I've written my Congress critters about the issue several times. I'd love to see it end. I don't personally do any GA, I've never flown in any of those planes, I've never bought avgas. I'm not in support of the use of leaded gas in the slightest. What have you personally done to remedy the situation? All I'm trying to do is share knowledge. I imagine many people on this forum would have thought a Cessna would have used more gas than a speed boat. Chill out.