2 ms·
"Um. Isn't that what this case is trying to establish? It's unclear what the legal expectation is or isn't." Not really. The general terms are quite settled th
by giantg2 3y ago
"Um. Isn't that what this case is trying to establish? It's unclear what the legal expectation is or isn't."
Not really. The general terms are quite settled that it is fine for a person to film stuff from a public area, even if they are able to see a private area. The question is about whether police can also do that or if the 4th amendment prohibits it. Based on the long standing decisions that you don't have an expectation of privacy of being filmed from a public location and that the reasonable expectation of privacy is all that prohibits a "search", then it's a pretty logical outcome. Unless, again, they want to change the longstanding test. So it would not be about establishing anything, but rather changing something.