4 ms·
Can't read it, so I'll link to this HN thread[0] from 2016 where Alan Kay and Rich Hickey talk about whether "'data' is a bad idea," which is probably more wort
by krapp 3y ago
Can't read it, so I'll link to this HN thread[0] from 2016 where Alan Kay and Rich Hickey talk about whether "'data' is a bad idea," which is probably more worth the readers' time.
edit: actually, this[1] appears to be a reprint which isn't paywalled. The author seems to be playing a lot of semantic games and betting the question - "data" doesn't exist because the word is a general term that doesn't describe one specific thing, the value is in the social graph therefore data has no value, it's already everywhere so no one can "own" it, all of the arguments around AI and data are ridiculous, QED. All they've done is demonstrate the strawman definitions they use don't apply to the real world.
But "data" clearly does exist, it can be owned (ex: SSN, bank account data, IP, etc.) and it obviously has value. You can't just nullify the ethical and legal issues around AI by saying "what do words even mean anyway?"
[0]https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11945722 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=11945722
[1]https://www.ben-evans.com/benedictevans/2022/5/27/theres-no-such-thing-as-data https://www.ben-evans.com/benedictevans/2022/5/27/theres-no-...
- andsoitis 3y ago> it can be owned (ex: SSN, bank account data, IP, etc.) Who owns those things that you enumerate. What about if someone takes a photo of your house. Is it their data or is it yours? (note, I'm avoiding privacy considerations, just focusing on "ownership" of "data"). What an electronic conversation between two people. Do they share ownership of that content 50/50?