4 ms·
> Nobody said that nature is optimal. Wheels are trivial, however not present in biology. Nature creates tentacles, not jet engines, nuclear energy etc. Wheels
by baq 3y ago
> Nobody said that nature is optimal. Wheels are trivial, however not present in biology. Nature creates tentacles, not jet engines, nuclear energy etc.
Wheels are trivial but useless without bearings.
Bearings most certainly aren't trivial. All the things you listed further are dependent on bearings somewhere.
- mirekrusin 3y agoI think 5yo kid with lego would have problems agreeing with this otherwise moot statement.
- baq 3y agoDon't want to sound mean but I don't think you've dealt with bearings if you say so.
- TeMPOraL 3y agoAFAIK both exist in biology. Bacterial flagellum is effectively a motor, and has a working wheel-like structure. IIRC, some crickets had an equivalent of a bearing somewhere in their anatomy too. Evolution is a greedy, lazy optimizer, so it promotes things that work a-ok for a given environment. It's also worth noting that wheels alone are not too useful for transportation, as they're only half of the picture. The other half is roads. That is, because we couldn't (and mostly still can't) figure out all-terrain mobility systems that could navigate diverse environments, we cheated and locally flattened the environment, to reduce the problem to that solvable by a humble wheel. Evolution can't cheat like this.
- baq 3y agoI actually googled before writing the comment (preposterous, I know; also, out of vouge, should've asked chatgpt) and the bacteria thing was the only thing I found, nothing macro scale, which made sense since it's easier to rebuild than to heal. Anything bigger than that would have to be healed and it's hard enough to fix mechanical bearings, can't imagine how to regrow or heal one even if it somehow grows. Maybe it's an issue with my imagination ;)
- TeMPOraL 3y agoGood point about rebuilding vs. healing. We're kind of rediscovering it with economies of scale and price of labor making it much cheaper to replace things than to repair them. I can imagine evolution creating macro-scale wheels that can be healed, and/or able to survive long enough before failing to be advantageous - after all, bones and teeth can hardly be healed if badly damaged, and yet they last long enough to stick around as core design elements. This is why I mentioned roads. Whether or not evolution could iterate its way to macroscale wheels, it wouldn't, because they'd be useless without roads. Legs may be more complex overall, but they're an all-terrain solution that can be incrementally improved, and every improvement step grants improved survivability.
- mirekrusin 3y agoIf that's the case why are we sending wheeled rovers to mars/moon and not something with legs? In any case this discussion is going sideways, the point is that nature doesn't have monopoly on being optimal. This also applies to intelligence/learning/modeling something better than brain.
- TeMPOraL 3y ago> If that's the case why are we sending wheeled rovers to mars/moon and not something with legs? Because Mars is a simple and boring environment. Most of its surface, and especially the parts we target with rover missions, are effectively flat sheets peppered with rocks - a decent set of wheels and suspension is close to optimal for navigating such terrain. Now, if we were to send missions to a planet that's mostly forests and rivers, like Earth used to be, then wheels wouldn't cut it - not before cutting down some of the forests first. > the point is that nature doesn't have monopoly on being optimal. This also applies to intelligence/learning/modeling something better than brain. Fair enough. Nature doesn't do globally optimal - but it makes things heavily optimized for their environment. That's why our planes are nowhere near as energy-efficient in flying as birds are, but birds cannot travel as far and as fast as our planes can.
- mirekrusin 3y agoExactly, same with intelligence - it's polluted with emotions and all kind of "nonsense" - but it doesn't have to. We can create emotionless, super-intelligent machines exceeding human capability by far (and use them as hammers). No need to imitate every detail of the brain to extract intelligence.
- pixl97 3y agoThe counter to this is you can end up with an exceptionally powerful, but unaligned AI, which presents a new series of 'known unknowns' and 'unknown unknowns' that we have to deal with.
- 3y ago
- bcrosby95 3y agoThey've found gears in insects too https://www.livescience.com/39577-insects-with-leg-gears-discovered.html https://www.livescience.com/39577-insects-with-leg-gears-dis...
- pmoriarty 3y ago"Wheels are trivial but useless without bearings." Carts, chariots, and wheelbarrows (to name but a few examples) have been useful for thousands of years without bearings.
- baq 3y agoThe simplest bearing is a greased axle. This was the big 'wheel' discovery, not the round thingie, but how to attach a box on top. So we agree!
- DrScientist 3y ago> but useless without bearings. Or more importantly - level ground.