3 ms·
Yes but this requires a lawsuit, which is a complete non-starter for nearly all the "victims." Even if the "victim" is themself a lawyer, it's still a ridiculou
by freedomben 3y ago
Yes but this requires a lawsuit, which is a complete non-starter for nearly all the "victims." Even if the "victim" is themself a lawyer, it's still a ridiculous amount of work required to collect. It would only be "worth it" if the power differential is lower in the first place, which is ironically when it's less likely to be needed...
- dragonwriter 3y ago> Yes but this requires a lawsuit, which is a complete non-starter for nearly all the "victims." Why is "victims" in quotes there? And even of there was a specific unique cause of action for DMCA misrepresentation, that would take a lawsuit too. How do you imagine a penalty exists without legal action? (You can create a public cause of action, too, but then the victim still has to convince the relevant public authority that the case is meritorious and a priority, which can be hit or miss.)
- freedomben 3y ago> Why is "victims" in quotes there? Because some people lose their minds if you use the word "victim" to refer to a person who has suffered a light crime, rather than reserving it only for people who have suffered a particularly egregious violation. > And even of there was a specific unique cause of action for DMCA misrepresentation, that would take a lawsuit too. > How do you imagine a penalty exists without legal action? (You can create a public cause of action, too, but then the victim still has to convince the relevant public authority that the case is meritorious and a priority, which can be hit or miss.)* It's not an all or nothing, and not all legal action is equally arduous. Adding penalties on top of actual damages would shift the scales significantly and add some protection for the consumer (remember for companies it's all about balancing liability). Having to prove actual damages in a civil suit as is currently is essentially impossible, but reporting would not be. The law could also be changed to make it clear that you can't DMCA a tool or script simply because it could be used to violate somebody's copyright. There could be penalties for wrongfully DMCAing something (that don't require the person to lawyer up and prove actual damages, something essentially impossible for the average person). To be clear, are you saying you like the current DMCA? That it's a good law?
- 6510 3y ago> How do you imagine a penalty exists without legal action? Google is already forced to judge the case. If someone fills enough bogus cases (bogus in Googles opinion) or a ridiculous one they (google) can stop processing them. Say I fill a complaint against a restaurant about food poisoning - but I didn't eat there. People might waste their time investigating it but surely it wont happen when I complaint for a second time? But I do think deleting all web browsers is a very reasonable judgement from Google. No more Chrome, no more Safari, no more Edge, linux would probably have to be banned entirely because you know, everyone will find a way to install a browser and visit that Hebrew website to watch TV programs in Hebrew, all... what is it, 9 million users of the language? I'm sure it will be just a slight inconvenience for the 5 billion/rest of us. We do have to be reasonable at times.
- dragonwriter 3y ago> Google is already forced to judge the case. If someone fills enough bogus cases (bogus in Googles opinion) or a ridiculous one they (google) can stop processing them Google can already do that if it judges that the risk that the complsinant has a legitimate case is low enough that they don't need a safe harbor against them. The only consequence for not honoring a takedown is that if you would have been liable to the company's for copyright infringement before considering the DMCA safe harbor, you don't eliminate that liability.