7 ms·
The damage to lunar orbiting spacecraft caused by the ejecta of lunar landers
- belter 3y ago"...This manuscript analyzes lunar lander soil erosion models and trajectory models to calculate how much damage will occur to spacecraft orbiting in the vicinity of the Moon. The soil erosion models have considerable uncertainty due to gaps in our understanding of the basic physics. The results for ~40 t landers show that the Lunar Orbital Gateway will be impacted by 1000s to 10,000s of particles per square meter but the particle sizes are very small and the impact velocity is low so the damage will be slight. However, a spacecraft in Low Lunar Orbit that happens to pass through the ejecta sheet will sustain extensive damage with hundreds of millions of impacts per square meter..."
- tabtab 3y agoSmall and medium meteorites smack into the moon's surface all the time, being it has no atmosphere. I find it hard to believe that human-built landers have nearly as much impact on low-orbit grit than these meteor impacts.
- dr_orpheus 3y agoSome of the data from LADEE and Lunar Dust Experiment (LDEX) instrument might point to this being the case, but it was more along the lines of human-built landers do not have nearly as much of an impact as meteor showers themselves (not necessarily the impact and resulting dust). "if LADEE did encounter any lunar soil particles thrown up by the final descent of Chang'e 3, they would have been lost in the background of Geminid-produced events." [0] That said, the Chang'e 3 is an order of magnitude (or close to two) smaller than the lunar landers they are talking about in the study. Also my own speculation is that the more continuous thrust of a lander may get particles to higher velocities due to the additional time for acceleration in the wake of the thrust as compared to the single impact of the meteor. I struggle to compare exactly how bad the lunar dust ejection is though. Most Micrometeoroid and Orbital Debris (MMOD) curves are specified as a Flux by particle size (velocity is sort of irrelevant, as you assume most of the velocity is from the spcecraft itself and most hits are in the direction of travel of spacecraft, the ram direction). My suspicion is that MMOD flux in a LEO orbit is still going to be far far worse. [0] https://www.nasa.gov/ames/ladee-project-scientist-update-milestones-maneuvers-and-moisture/ https://www.nasa.gov/ames/ladee-project-scientist-update-mil... Edit: The paper talks about flux of particles 10 um and smaller of about 10,000 impacts/m^2 during the passes. If we assume that this is a sphere of iron (new MMOD fluxes are specified in mass, not size) its ~5e-9g. In LEO at 400 km altitude (a little above the ISS) the flux of particle this size is ~1000 impacts/m^2/year. But the paper says smaller than <10 um. And at smaller masses the flux increases exponentially to 10^7 particles/m^2/year at a particle mass of 10^-18 g. So I believe my suspicion is correct that most LEO orbits are still worse, but its hard to compare apples to apples.
- azernik 3y agoLanders don't impact hard - they fire rocket engines down, which may be much more efficient at kicking up dust than an impact. (I still think this is overblowing the problem, because any lander that causes this big of an ejecta problem would also badly damage itself. All the designs will put a LOT of engineering work into minimizing debris, eg Starship putting separate landing engines high up on the vehicle.)
- Sharlin 3y ago> because any lander that causes this big of an ejecta problem would also badly damage itself Not necessarily because the relative speeds will be very slow. Not so in low lunar orbit, where an orbiting spacecraft will slam into the ejecta curtain at >1 km/s.
- azernik 3y agoThe paper estimates that if there's LLO debris, it'll be starting out with about 1.6km/s of surface-relative velocity. Not something you want to get even a small percentage of on your landing gear.
- LorenPechtel 3y agoThe ejecta would go out to the side and not harm the lander. I'm just amazed that the ejecta is being thrown hard enough to be a threat at orbital altitude.
- fnordpiglet 3y agoI would expect it’s the sustained thrust prior to landing and at take off that is the difference.
- sandworm101 3y agoImpacts are impacts. Rockets are more like leaf blowers. Drop a massive rock into a pile of leaves and few leaves even move. Point a leaf blower at the pile and leaves will scatter everywhere.
- moffkalast 3y agoYeah but throw a car sized boulder into a pile of leaves at a few km/s and they'll scatter all the same.
- ikekkdcjkfke 3y ago[flagged]
- pmontra 3y agoSo, land as few times as possible to carry what's needed to build a landing platform? Conversely, blowing an engine nearly horizontal to the surface is going to shut off the Moon for a while. That's a weapon.
- SketchySeaBeast 3y ago> Conversely, blowing an engine nearly horizontal to the surface is going to shut off the Moon for a while. That's a weapon. Is it in any way more practical weapon than just lobbing stuff?
- JumpCrisscross 3y agoYes. You don’t have to aim as you inundate an orbital plane with debris.
- masklinn 3y agoGood ol’ kessler syndrome.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> Good ol’ kessler syndrome Kessler is a chain reaction. Destruction is caused by secondary effects, i.e. bits of satellites the primary projectile broke hitting targets. This is closer to an area denial weapon: the destruction is caused directly by the debris blown off the surface.
- jerf 3y agoIt is also not permanent. The orbits of the debris would intersect the point where they depart, which is pretty close to the engine. Basically the engine would be hitting itself with everything it fired. Therefore, the logical thing to do is to put it on the correct side of a mountain, to shield the engine. But that would also collect all the debris. So it would generally only be in orbit for one orbit. That makes it more targeted than some of the other unfriendly things you can do in an airless planetary environment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35862424 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35862424 (To be honest, I think on any planetary body without an atmosphere, long term everyone is going to have to dig in to the planet, and to a non-trivial degree, too, not least of which is the complete indefensibility of surface installations.)
- moralestapia 3y ago[flagged]
- gs17 3y agoThe paper models a 40 t lander. That's roughly Blue Moon. The sum of all Chinese probes landed on the moon is far less than that, and I wouldn't be surprised if the sum of all Soviet Luna landers was also less than that.
- shagie 3y agoAs noted, the paper is referring to a 40 t lander with a single 67 kN thrust engine. As some other data points, the Apollo landers were 16t (later ones a bit more for an extended mission). The ascent module had a dry mass of 2445 kg and had an additional 2376 kg of propellant (5t). The lander's descent propulsion system was capable of 10,500 lbf (47 kN) that could be throttled between 10% - 60% and 100%. (1,050 lbf (4.7 kN) and 6,825 lbf (30.36 kN)) The ascent propulsion system was 3,500 lbf (16 kN).
- gs17 3y agoAnd Starship is already 100 t empty, although we don't have exact numbers for anything Starship HLS really AFAIK.
- flangola7 3y agoWhere did they say that the country was a factor?
- fnord77 3y agoso, low lunar orbit/landings could be DOSed by a couple of well-placed impacts of sufficient force?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jcims 3y agoDidn't we largely solve this with the sky crane for recent Mars missions?
- masklinn 3y agoThe lander size under consideration is about 40x that of the Martian rover, I don’t know that a sky crane would work as well without a parachuting stage and atmosphere, and finally it seems rather unhelpful for taking off.
- inamberclad 3y agoI presume this is part of why SpaceX is planning to use landing thrusters that are higher up the rocket.
- moffkalast 3y agoAfaik that's mainly so the plume of razor sharp dust doesn't tear their engines to billion tiny pieces. Unlike the LEM, they won't be bringing a spare for liftoff.
- rini17 3y agoDoubt 100meters will be enough.They need to be much higher not to kick regolith toward the rocket and beyond.
- ericbarrett 3y agoVelocity required to reach a 50 km orbit* above the moon's surface is only ~1.6 km/sec, and there's no air resistance to slow dust particles kicked up by the craft. For Mars, the orbital velocity is ~3.5 km/sec, thus requiring almost 5x the energy for a given mass of detritus (E = 1/2mv^2); and while its atmosphere isn't as thick as Earth's, it'll definitely cause drag for particles going that fast. * You don't quite need orbital velocity for a plume to get high enough to disrupt an orbiting craft, but it's a handy reference point.
- WalterBright 3y agoWhy wouldn't the orbit of the ejecta intersect with the surface, since it is in free fall ever since leaving the surface?
- CydeWeys 3y agoI think this is only in the immediate aftermath of a landing, not permanent orbiting debris.
- WalterBright 3y agoHow is it going to get into an orbit that doesn't intersect the moon? Any impulse from the surface will hit the surface in one orbit.
- zardo 3y agoThe moon has large enough density variations that you can't analyze low orbits as though it's just a point mass.
- WalterBright 3y agoYes, I know about the masscons, but it seems highly unlikely they'll be just at the right point. It's hard to believe that any object given a single impulse at ground level, in a vacuum, is not going to hit the moon again in one orbit (unless it is given escape velocity). Masscons did perturb the Apollo missions enough that they had to switch to a doppler radio to navigate accurately.
- rini17 3y agoDon't forget electric fields are involved too on Moon. They are strong enough to levitate the dust sometimes.
- PeterisP 3y agoThe paper models an 'ejecta sheet' of particles that exceed the escape velocity of the moon and thus aren't in orbit.
- uguuo_o 3y agoThis problem has been known for a long while. The models used here by Metzger have such a large uncertainty and only take into account erosion due to shear. As soon as the erosion transitions from shear-based (smooth sheets) to bulk (fluidized), none of the data extends to that regime. A massive vehicle landing on the moon will definitely cause fluidization. To estimate erosion and ejecta needs far more detailed numerical methods [0]. [0]https://doi.org/10.1017/jfm.2021.29 https://doi.org/10.1017/jfm.2021.29
- areoform 3y agoThe paper's author Dr. Phil Metzger is such a rockstar. He is The Expert on the mechanics of soil erosion by rocket exhausts, and writes a lot about the problem in an approachable way, https://twitter.com/DrPhiltill/status/1658507854859337737 https://twitter.com/DrPhiltill/status/1658507854859337737 It turns out that the rate & mechanics of erosion by rocket plumes is an unsolved problem that requires a new kind of model. To quote from his thread, In the Apollo era the thinking was that the rate of soil erosion is controlled by conservation of momentum. It turns out this is wrong. NASA researcher Leonard Roberts, the first person to research this topic, hypothesized that the soil grains steal momentum from the gas, which slows down the gas and thus reduces the erosion rate. It was this feedback that determined the rate. I argued some years ago this has to be wrong because the particles achieve their high velocities far downstream of where they are lifted off the surface, so momentum transfer does not provide feedback to control the rate that grains are lifted. He's going to be publishing his alternate model soon-ish. Can't wait to see what he has come up with.
- _joel 3y agoI wonder how much Starship mitigates that by having the descent propulsion controlled by the top thrusters. I'd assume they use the same thrusters from take off too as we've seen the damage Raptor 2's can do, let alone 3 and whatever comes after the 350bar line. Also, could regolith be bound or, well, packed down to build pads?
- yetihehe 3y agoThere is a project to inject small aluminum granules into exhaust, so they melt when leaving engine but solidify on contact, which would be a good way to cover your landing site with solid aluminum layer. A rocket engine could easily melt a ton of aluminum per minute.
- _joel 3y agoThat's still throw ejecta in the air though and sounds just like a recipe for disaster.
- yetihehe 3y agoIf you hover high enough in vacuum, gases have enough time to disperse and won't throw ejecta that much, but those melted aluminum droplets can travel relatively unimpended and solidify on contact. You land only when you have good solid surface.
- Titan2189 3y agoSpallation is a process in which fragments of material (spall) are ejected from a body due to impact or stress. In the context of impact mechanics it describes ejection of material from a target during impact by a projectile
- Gravityloss 3y agoHmm, you need smaller landers, longer legs or engine at the top (with multiple nozzles), wire lowering of payloads or something...