3 ms·
I understand the intent behind copyright laws and I agree that people should be able to profit from their creations, but the extreme lengths to which copyright
by freedomben 3y ago
I understand the intent behind copyright laws and I agree that people should be able to profit from their creations, but the extreme lengths to which copyright has been pushed and abused (for example DMCA) is incredible to me. I don't doubt that if it could possibly fly, they would try to ban browsers. Not that my opinion matters, but it's eroded most of the sympathy I have toward it and I'm getting closer to the "copyright should die in a fire" camp than I normally would.
It's obviously a bit in the future, but I look forward to the day when you can just use AI to generate new music, movies, TV shows, etc that are unencumbered so you can watch them wherever and whenever you want, even in 4k on Linux! I'll have sympathy and sadness for the individual creatives that lose the ability to support themselves, but not for the mega corps that have brought us to where we are now.
- lbotos 3y agoDMCA gets a bad wrap, and it is abused -- but on the surface it seems pretty right: I promise that the content that is being hosted at location X is mine, that I did not give Y person permission to publish it, and I'm willing to face the fine of perjury if I'm actually lying. Like, in a functioning society that seems like the right tool to start a legal dispute over the right to distribute copyrighted works?
- jeroenhd 3y agoThe problem is that the "perjury if I'm actually lying" part is unenforceable. As long as you have a reason to think your licensed work is being distributed elsewhere, proving perjury is very difficult. Trash companies attacking random internet websites with the permission of copyright giants can do as they please. Nintendo lies and defrauds with these notices all the time but there's no way anyone is going to take them to court over it. It's not just the entertainment industry either. HackerRank was a notable example of an IT company that willingly abused DMCA takedowns, for example. There were a whole bunch of bogus takedowns, many of which still haven't been reverted, but when one of them made it to the HN frontpage they finally seemed to have fixed their policy. There's no doubt their competitors are abusing DMCA the same way, except that they hire more competent DMCA takedown companies. In many places, the DMCA has the right idea, but it lacks serious abuse prevention. It also places a lot of unilateral power with copyright holders, more than I'm comfortable with. The whole "reverse engineering is a crime if it's copyright protection software" racket has little to do with protecting individual copyrighted works and only serves to let large media and tech companies keep their monopolies.
- freedomben 3y agoYes, exactly, the reporter is almost never held accountable for the false take down request, and because of the current state of tech the entity doing the takedown is a gigantic (usually automated) tech company that is risk averse. The huge power differential puts the reportee in an impossible situation where the "neutral" third party is completely unreachable and executes their actions often without human intervention/judgment. A better law would be one that has actual penalties for wrongful reports, possibly (when the third party acts as a gate keeper like Apple, Google, etc) holding the third party liable for a wrongful judgment might help balance the scales as well because "erring on the side of the reporter" won't be a no-brainer risk-wise.
- dragonwriter 3y ago> A better law would be one that has actual penalties for wrongful reports. We have general law that provides remedies for false damaging statements and for improper attempts to interfere with existing contractual relationships. I don’t think the absence of an additional cause of action specific to DMCA takedown notices actually has much effect.
- freedomben 3y agoYes but this requires a lawsuit, which is a complete non-starter for nearly all the "victims." Even if the "victim" is themself a lawyer, it's still a ridiculous amount of work required to collect. It would only be "worth it" if the power differential is lower in the first place, which is ironically when it's less likely to be needed...
- dragonwriter 3y ago> Yes but this requires a lawsuit, which is a complete non-starter for nearly all the "victims." Why is "victims" in quotes there? And even of there was a specific unique cause of action for DMCA misrepresentation, that would take a lawsuit too. How do you imagine a penalty exists without legal action? (You can create a public cause of action, too, but then the victim still has to convince the relevant public authority that the case is meritorious and a priority, which can be hit or miss.)
- nyanpasu64 3y agoThe problem is that the DMCA also criminalizes hacking devices you own, and explaining to others how to hack their devices, rather than the actual process of copyright infringement (which itself is itself harmful to society in its current maximalist state). So it can be illegal to bypass DRM even if used for fair-use purposes.
- Semaphor 3y agoIsn't the issue that you only have to have issues if you are lying about representing the copyright holder? Not about the X you are pointing to actually being the content you are talking about? Your version seems sane, but I'm not sure the law works that way.
- 6510 3y agoYour opinion matters to me! That said, I'm sure this event has nothing to do with copyright. It would require an actual violation. Google is just trigger happy when asked to do things by big corporate players and lame when asked by everyone else. This usually works out well for them and poorly for everyone else.
- jeroenhd 3y agoIgnoring a DMCA takedown request makes you liable if the request was valid. There's no way Google will take the legal responsibility for a project that happened to be uploaded to their store, no reasonable company with user submitted content at such a scale will.
- 6510 3y agoThe request was not valid in a much to obvious way. It is a browser on their platform, a request to delete it should be treated like any request to delete a browser from Android. It has nothing to do with copyrights. How can you pretend it does? Maybe Curl should be removed, hell why not get rid of the console entirely? Perhaps delete the internet? Maybe we should ban computers? It all starts with electricity? All those connectors on the TV set, those could be used to access web browsers. How do we stop it?
- MikeBVaughn 3y ago"It's obviously a bit in the future, but I look forward to the day when you can just use AI to generate new music, movies, TV shows, etc that are unencumbered so you can watch them wherever and whenever you want, even in 4k on Linux! I'll have sympathy and sadness for the individual creatives that lose the ability to support themselves, but not for the mega corps that have brought us to where we are now." I agree that modern copyright law is atrocious and stifling, but the whole "I have sympathy for artists, but..." thing is just grimly exhausting and depressing at this point. I feel nothing but despair. I've spent a lot of time interacting with ChatGPT and image models, and when people say this, all I can do is wonder how other people interact with art and literature. Every iteration of ChatGPT I've seen is an astoundingly bad prose stylist. At a sentence-to-sentence level, everything that burbles forth from ChatGPT's maw is joyless, flavorless garbage. It's an undifferentiated slurry that has all the verve of a corporate onboarding manual, mated with a self-help book, written by Reddit's gestalt consciousness. Statistically aping surface form is low-hanging-fruit. Even if you just want (ugh) 'content' in the raw sense of the word - stuff that fills time between when we're born and when we're dead - I am skeptical current Large-Whatever-Models will get there. Everything they do is wholly divorced from being an agent in a physical reality. This is why image models can't even do (what-do-you-call-them, oh yeah) hands. There's a difference between regurgitating variants on two-dimensional representations of hands and drawing hands. I am similarly skeptical that a large-text-model can ever do anything that captures inner experience in a truly novel way. I just firmly do not believe that a text model trained on works written prior to Faulkner's career - regardless of how much goading you gave it - could produce "As I Lay Dying." Wake me when a GPT model can write a thriller that delivers the rainsoaked weltschmerz and dread of Le Carre's 'Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Spy.' Until I see an AI put out something on par with "Move. Once you stop, you never start again: there is a special stage-fright that can make you dry up and walk away, that burns your fingers when you touch the goods and turns your stomach to water. Move," I will fear the idea of AI being pushed as any sort of salvation from the overreach of copyright law. If it does end up being the solution we get, I worry we will have to augment the free-as-in-beer and free-as-in-speech axes with free-as-in-dumpster-diving.
- freedomben 3y agoI certainly agree as of now, but I think one of the next areas of "innovation" will be results with smaller models, which also enables higher quality assurance for the data in the model. It totally might be 10 or 20 years away, but eventually I think we'll figure it out. There was another discussion today about "humanizing" drum machine output by subtly introducing minor timing variance and it makes it feel "human." At some point I tend to think we'll figure that out for AI art