27 ms·
While I appreciate the concerns over the potential of rogue AI, I think it's important to offer a counter-narrative to the doomsday scenario often presented. Th
by bsmith8108 3y ago
While I appreciate the concerns over the potential of rogue AI, I think it's important to offer a counter-narrative to the doomsday scenario often presented. The idea that there will be one rogue AI that spirals out of control is, in my view, overly simplistic and doesn't account for the vast ecosystem of AI that already exists.
Consider this: our world is already filled with numerous AI models of varying power and functionality. In the event that one goes rogue, wouldn't it be plausible for other models to step in, contain, and mitigate the damage? This dynamic is not much different from what we have witnessed in the field of cybersecurity, where security teams and hackers are locked in a constant struggle — a patch and breach cycle.
Also, let's think about the future. We're close to a situation where we don't always have the upper hand over the tools we build, but that's a continuum of the path we have already been treading. It will require collective effort, both from humans and AIs, to combat any rogue AI or even a fleet of them.
The notion of AI being centralized doesn't line up with what we're already seeing play out. An AI ecosystem with hundreds of variations, serving as a safeguard against a rogue AI, seems like a more promising and secure future. We should be focused on developing a diverse array of AI models rather than worrying about a singular rogue entity. Our defense strategy against potential threats lies in the broad dissemination of this technology, not in its undue concentration.
- pixl97 3y ago>wouldn't it be plausible for other models to step in, contain, and mitigate the damage? Conversely you're making an argument to maintenance of that status quo. It makes zero sense that would happen. As analogy lets imagine a nice balanced ecosystem with lots of plants and flowers and insects and animals that's been going on for a while. Then suddenly you drop Kudzu in it and it begins spreading like wildfire and quickly puts pressure on at risk plant and insect species. You release another insect that eats Kudzu only to try to reduce the amount of it, but in the time it takes the insect to breed up to numbers to combat the Kudzu, it's spread even further and wiped a few species out, and now is putting pressure on the larger animals that cannot eat the Kudzu. In natural environments you don't really ever get your old ecosystem back, something are just gone and cannot be supported any longer, and there is a new balance between competeory species. AI is a potential competeory species to humans. Escalation between AI systems present a far larger risk to humans than direct AI versus Human actions in my line of thought.