5 ms·
I have a drum computer [0] that has a "humanize" knob; the manual says the following: HUMANIZE: MIDI effect - adjust the amount of randomness and probabili
by Cthulhu_ 3y ago
I have a drum computer [0] that has a "humanize" knob; the manual says the following:
HUMANIZE: MIDI effect - adjust the amount of randomness and probability, changing the velocity of the steps
in the pattern and slightly moving the recorded steps further from their relative position.
Each time a pattern is repeated, the humanize will change its internal values.
In theory it'll make the drum computer sound more human / imperfect. However, professional drummers can play super tight (as shown in the article, .15 second precision strikes, and Hammett isn't even the best out there) and in some cases will have their strikes triggered, normalized and / or cleaned up for the album, so humanizing a drum beat is more for live performances I think?
[0] https://www.ikmultimedia.com/products/unodrum/ https://www.ikmultimedia.com/products/unodrum/
- matsemann 3y agoYeah, but it's more than just adding some "random" timings. Because I think that for a real drummer, the timings are biased. For instance, after hitting a drum far away, the timing/speed/power at which you hit the next drum is different than if you hit a different drum right before.
- Jolter 3y agoLars Ulrich, the drummer of Metallica, is widely considered to a mediocre drummer, in terms of technique. His style is distinctive but cannot be called precise. The timing on Master of Puppets is likely due to a fluke during the songwriting/rehearsal process. “Hey guys, this 5/8 thing sounds really cool, I think we’re really nailing it now!” plays it out of time Rest of the band likely just got used to his idiosyncratic playing and adapted.
- brookst 3y ago…and he did that, consistently, with only a few millisecond variations, on exactly the same beat of the same riff, for the entirety of just that one song, and in live performances?
- IsTom 3y agoDrumming and generally keeping rhythm is a physical thing. You move your body parts (e.g. bopping head, swaying hips etc.) and it couples with how and when you're playing.
- brookst 3y agoAre you suggesting his movements in this one measure were so unique that they exactly doubled the length of one eighth note? At some point I think we have to put the “it was a freak accident that was repeated with precision over and over, forever” argument to bed.
- IsTom 3y agoWith n=1, for me there is a groove or three that are just muscle memory and I'd need a longer while to sit down and think if asked write them down. They came out from noodling around and coming to "huh, that sounds cool" and I imagine that's not something particularly uncommon for other people too.
- brookst 3y agoI think we lost the thread here. I wasn't suggesting Lars had millisecond-level intrinsic timing and an innovative approach to music theory. I was rejecting the idea that this beat came from incompetence. I think developing an interesting groove and being able to play it consistently in a song, and in live performances for years is evidence of drumming competence.
- Jolter 3y agoYou don’t play music, do you? It’s absolutely possible to learn a rhythm, groove or melody wrong, and to rehearse it until it sounds so right, the anything else sounds wrong to you. But your audience would notice.
- colanderman 3y ago
- mort96 3y agoI really wouldn't be surprised if "5/8" wasn't even mentioned anywhere until long after that part of the song was thought up. It just sounds good.
- spoonfeeder006 3y agoInteger subdivisions are kinda arbitrary too as well Probably we limit ourselves a lot if we're too confined to those without being able to express our energy But someone who is trained explicitly to play exact integer divisions will have trouble expressing their energy as much
- BurningFrog 3y agoRick Beato says the typical 90s band would replace their drummer with a studio pro or drum machine for their first album, since they just weren't precise enough. I didn't get the impression that "humanizing" was much of a concern.
- PeterisP 3y agoIt's not (solely) random imperfections - a good drum groove will have intentional specific deviations from the "theoretically exact" (bad) beat timing, no matter if done by a human or a properly engineered digital track. There is a difference between the crude musical notation and how it's actually meant to be played - a notation showing 4 quarter notes in a 4/4 beat does not imply that the correct way to play them is to literally have 4 identical notes with idential gaps; even without any explicit extra notation (which indicates significant changes) there is an implied understanding that there should be a variation in velocity (and, for a skilled practicioner, not a random one, but placing slight emphasis as required) and a variation in timing (again, for a skilled player not random but e.g. depending on the music genre a slight shuffle or an intentional shift of one beat); this variation is not a flaw of imperfect execution, but required to properly play the music as intended.
- spoonfeeder006 3y ago.15 second precision sounds like a huge margin of error for a pro drummer, or any pro musician for that matter