3 ms·
> It is precisely this violation of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights Pretty much all countries distinguish citizens from non-citizens. This isn't an A
by robertlagrant 3y ago
> It is precisely this violation of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights
Pretty much all countries distinguish citizens from non-citizens. This isn't an American thing. And you're committing a category error, namely that rights Americans have aren't a superset of any internationally agreed rights. They are.
- pjc50 3y agoThe US refused to ratify the Convention on Rights of The Child, so the rights of Americans are not a superset of internationally agreed rights.
- robertlagrant 3y agoBut is this is not missing the point? Just as with any country, if the US didn't agree them, then they aren't agreed. Thus they aren't an example of the US differentiating between its citizens and its non-citizens on its agreed human rights.
- tastyfreeze 3y agoIn most countries people are subjects of the government. In the US the people are sovereign. The government doesn't tell us what our rights are.
- robertlagrant 3y agoSure, no. The cop with a gun pointed at you shouts your rights at you; rights which the government wrote down. In all seriousness though, I've no idea what this means in any practical sense. I don't know what being a subject of a government is, not how it compares to being a sovereign.
- aa-jv 3y agoBah, this is just another example of how Americans' can be convinced to buy their own doom by packaging it as exceptionalism instead. Human rights supersede citizenship, which is as it should be - especially for those human beings who want to exercise their rights while not being citizens of any state, whether by choice or by war, etc. Non-citizens are humans too, and therefore have the same rights citizens do.