3 ms·
Do you think anything could be done to keep moderators from going off the rails? Would making mod actions as transparent as possible help? How about user feedba
by account42 3y ago
Do you think anything could be done to keep moderators from going off the rails? Would making mod actions as transparent as possible help? How about user feedback that could see mods. Obviously you'd still need the dictator at the top to be benevolent but that seems to be more likely at least until the community gets big enough that selling out would actually pay.
- MichaelZuo 3y agoThey have to be paid, so that people other then the petty power seekers with their race-to-the-bottom dynamic apply to become mods.
- zamnos 3y agoDo you? What if, instead the system promoted a random active user to moderator status, with a strict term limit, with the possibility of being kicked out if too unpopular. Power shouldn't be given to those who seek it, and kind of low stakes Internet forum seems like a way to thrust power unto those that aren't.
- Eisenstein 3y agoThe problem with that is a lot of communities are work to mod, and most people wouldn't bother.
- r00fus 3y agoThis sounds very similar to slashdot and "meta-mod". Moderation was done through an infrequent escalation of privileges (sometimes this was weekly for me but sometimes I didn't get it for a month+), but everyone past a certain level could meta-mod every day. Both operations were limited in scope for a prescribed number of moderations each time.
- Lammy 3y agoThat's kinda how FYAD used to do it with regular election of a new "Idiot King" https://web.archive.org/web/20031023125845/http://www.stateog.com:80/index.pl?node=Idiot+King https://web.archive.org/web/20031023125845/http://www.stateo... “Originally FYAD was a complete anarchy. Nobody moderated it, and it was good. When it started to become more popular, however, certain users did stuff that was just annoying (spamming huge images that broke the tables and made threads impossible to read, posting a billion threads, posting illegal porn, that sort of thing) so certain people called for some kind of moderation. Others said that a moderator would ruin FYAD. Fistgrrl, in her infinite wisdom, proposed the Idiot King contest. Once a week, she (or another admin) posts a thread. The admin has already two numbers, one for the Idiot King and one for the Loser King. Everyone who wants to enter the contest posts under that thread, and chooses a number between 1 and 100. When the contest is over (Usually 20 minutes or so), the person who posted closest to the Idiot King number becomes the Idiot King for a week, with most of the powers of a moderator and a ceremonial title. The person who posted the number closest to the Loser King number is banned for a week. Anyone who posts a duplicate number, a number that is not between 1 and 100, or posts in the IK thread but has not posted in FYAD in the last 24 hours is also banned for a week. UPDATE: April 30, 2003: Lowtax did the IK contest this week, and instead of numbers he asked people to post states. What a crazy guy!” I never read actual confirmation for this but I assume the position was named for the Soul Coughing song https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5qAxjmvvtOk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5qAxjmvvtOk
- account42 3y agoThat still sounds like its selecting for people who desire power - perhaps even more so because of the risk of a ban. I guess it might be appropriate for that kind of forum.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- sdflhasjd 3y agoI certainly think it's not a simple thing to solve. One thing, and alluding to the other reply, is the "benevolent dictator", they need to be keeping the mods in shape - not doing any moderating themselves, but to keep them from running amok. This is how I ran thing until I didn't have time any more, at which point things deteriorated (not in some dramatic way, mind you.) The other thing is that mod selection is really, really difficult. Maybe 100% of people that "apply" or show any desire to be a mod are mostly just thirsty for some of that banhammer power. Additionally, on a gaming forum, the general age and maturity of these applicants leaves much to be desired. Generally I handled this by throwing mod responsibilities as a burden of those that were generally already community contributors in other ways (devs, etc) and they seemed mature enough. I think this made a difference compared to other communities that I saw around that time. In retrospect one other thing that should have been done would be to separate the mod identity from the community identity as a way of tempering the ego that sometimes causes issues. Lots of forums and whatnot slap a load of badges and medals on mods that gives the role an air of privilege that isn't deserved. ...and none of this really applies to the context of reddit, and especially not for the larger communities of millions of users. The structure just doesn't scale since your dictator just can't see what all the mods are doing.