4 ms·
5 Years of the GDPR: National Authorities Let Down European Legislator
- jruohonen 3y ago"With the imminent introduction of the EU Collective Redress Directive, users will have the opportunity to group their litigation efforts through joint 'class action' lawsuits. This approach not only circumvents the reliance on DPAs, but also possesses the potential for a more impactful deterrent effect than GDPR fines that are largely theoretical." Indeed, from a quick look of the Finnish law, there are several ways to enact proceedings: (a) several state agencies (e.g., DPA, consumer protection, telecom, medicine, and finance regulators) can litigate on their own for preventive measures and (b) consumer protection agency for normal claims, but also (c) not-for-profit interest groups approved by a state regulator can file claims. What is more, (d) the law allows European not-for-profits to litigate on behalf of Finnish people in a Finnish court and in some cases in any EU/ETA court. The last case is particularly interesting, as in theory it might allow some muscular body like BEUC to proceed with pan-European litigation. See: https://www.beuc.eu/blog/beucs-relentless-quest-for-collective-redress-that-works-for-consumers/ https://www.beuc.eu/blog/beucs-relentless-quest-for-collecti... And in particular: https://www.beuc.eu/sites/default/files/publications/BEUC-X-2022-085_Private_International_Law_and_Cross-Border_Collective_Redress.pdf https://www.beuc.eu/sites/default/files/publications/BEUC-X-...
- filleokus 3y ago>Companies learned to ignore the GDPR. While the industry had initially thrown a tantrum about the GDPR and its high fines, the past years have shown that this deterring effect has quickly washed off. The reality shows that the legislator was unable to simply legislate an enforcement culture. The GDPR has often become a mere paper tiger. I'm not a huge GDPR fan, for a multitude of reasons, but the reality of the compliance situation is the biggest one. I wonder if this experience will inform the EU in its further legislative adventures. Most likely perhaps by causing even sterner legislation, or perhaps (if I dare to dream) by limiting the bureaucratic-federalist ambitions.
- jruohonen 3y agoIt already has informed quite a lot. For instance, the DSA's enforcement was designed precisely with the GPDR's enforcement problems in mind. But it indeed points toward the federalist direction you fear. While mileages vary, centralization seems to be the only option for real enforcement as otherwise things end up in the lingo of infighting, lack of harmonization, and national bias. The other option is a US-style regulation-through-litigation, but I am not sure whether that is any better (neither for companies nor for consumers).
- nickpp 3y agoThe most interesting fact about GDPR is that it doesn’t apply to governments.
- jruohonen 3y agoWhat? Of course it applies to governments. The notable exemptions are national security and law enforcement, and for the latter there is a separate data protection directive. See Art. 23 for a full list.
- blitzar 3y agoIts like the bendy bananas or turkey certain to be joining the EU next week (5 years ago) all over again
- moi2388 3y agoNot only does it apply to them, they are one of the fees actually taking it really seriously
- candiodari 3y agoThe most protected class of data is medical data ... which in most European countries is only in public hands. And this data is being sent to insurance companies, mostly because they're also public or semi-public (and exceptions were made for this). Every government gets to appoint a board that makes exceptions to the GPDR for them. So this is "OK", if that's what you mean by "taking it really seriously". The main reason for the GPDR was to ensure this wouldn't happen. Likewise ever more data is being shared. For example, psychological diagnoses are now used in divorce proceedings (determining child care, alimony, ...). How did this happen? Well first, police and social services have demanded, everywhere, that medical data be shared with them (mostly for the purpose of finding people for debt recovery by arresting them when they go for medical treatment. One can only hope they do have the decency to arrest them AFTER actually getting said medical treatment) ... Then social services is present at all divorce proceedings now (which also was supposed to help, but the main problem was waiting times, scheduling, reaction time, and of course this is also making that problem, the main problem, worse) If this is what you mean by governments taking the GPDR seriously, sure, they're making sure they're going through motions. Does the GPDR actually protect individuals from "powerful interests", as was promised? No. No it doesn't. I would declare the GPDR a total failure. It most certainly did not have the intended effect, and it is a constant cost and nuisance to everyone. Ironically it is a cost and nuisance BOTH for companies attempting to exploit user data AND the users themselves.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]