4 ms·
Atom Diamondville also has a higher IPC than the current ARMv7 I'm not sure what you mean here. ARMv7 is an ISA, not an architecture, so different ARM cores th
by Symmetry 15y ago
Atom Diamondville also has a higher IPC than the current ARMv7
I'm not sure what you mean here. ARMv7 is an ISA, not an architecture, so different ARM cores that run ARMv7 code, everything from the A5 to the A15, will have radically different IPCs even though they can have the same set of instructions for a given program.
And you can't even really compare the IPC of processor architectures with different ISAs directly, its often easier to solve a problem in one ISA with less instructions than in a different ISA. RISC architectures often do less work per instruction than CISC architectures, but ARM has some features like instruction predication and argument shifting that mean that its individual instruction are often more powerful than, say, MIPS.
And it is actually fair to compare processor that have different clock rates, because often the architecture determines how fast a chip you can make. Itanium servers are only clocked at around half the speed of other architectures because the ISA is very complex and that's as fast as they can make them, and so comparing e.g. Power and Itanium processors of equal clock speed would be horribly unfair to the decisions that Power made that allow them to clock so high.
So to get a fair comparison you really want to just build the best processor of a given architecture you can on a given process, and let them fight it out like they do here. This can be pretty hard to do, since the performance of different company's processes on a given node can be rather different. I seem to recall that Intel could put maybe 20% more current through a N-gate on the 65nm node than their competitors, for instance, but using the same process would be the ideal.
- hackermom 15y agoHow can you produce such a wall of text over a little misnomer? You obviously understood that I am referring to the current incarnation of the ARMv7 ISA, a.k.a the Cortex family.
- Symmetry 15y agoMostly I put up a wall of text because I think the subject is interesting and I wanted to talk about it, but really there is no one IPC for the Cortex Family. An A5 will tend to have an IPC that is much lower than an Atom. An A15 will tend to have an IPC that is much higher than an Atom. And for the cores being compared here, on tight microbenchmarks the superior execution resources[1] and OoO execution of an A9 will put it ahead of an Atom, but on pointer chasing code the superior branch predictor of the Atom will probably give it a higher IPC. EDIT: [1] Well, really the 16 vs 8 registers, 3 operand instructions, and free barrel shift in each instruction. I think they have the same number of ALUs and AGUs.