6 ms·
A temperature rise of 2 degrees Celsius impacts billions
- thebooktocome 4y ago> Looking at individual country impacts on dangerous heat levels, researchers found that current emissions from 1.2 average US citizens condemn a future human to live in extreme heat. This is a terrible sentence that encrypts their intended point. “Current emissions” do not have the agency implied by “condemn”. One might get the impression that the “1.2 average US citizens” are doing the condemning, but the average US citizen does not have enough agency to move the needle one way or the other. The government (supposedly, a sovereign power concerned with its own continued existence) ought to regulate the corporations (supposedly, rational agents concerned with their own continued existence) that are contributing almost all US emissions. Those two are the ones doing the condemning.
- qgin 4y agoThe percapitafication of emissions is one of the biggest misdirects of the climate change issue. There is no plausible mechanism for individuals to steer this based on their own consumption. You can want it to happen but it won’t ever happen in a the numbers required. Changes have to happen at the corporate and industrial levels.
- dylan604 4y agoThe theory is that you have to get the individuals motivated to make decisions that make those corporations make changes. When the numbers of individuals becomes a large enough number to effect the bottom line of corporations, then they can maybe have a chance of actually influencing those corporations. s/corporations/elected-officials/ either individuals stop using corporations or individuals influence gov't members to enact changes to force corporations, the corporations are not going to do anything that might negatively impact their bottom lines
- dchftcs 4y agoThere's a lot of waste based on pure nonsense and most of the public indulge in them. Individuals that actually care and make well-informed decisions form a minority.
- Spivak 4y agoI think that's unfair to people, one person's nonsense is another person's joy. I'm not saying that there isn't obvious lavish excess but unless you're 99th percentile in wealth (not income) nothing you do even wiggles the needle.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Spivak 4y agoRight, but that's like trying to steer a river one bucket at a time. Alternatively we could get together and build a dam. The mechanism we invented for top-down collective decision making is government; we should use it.
- MichaelZuo 3y ago> The mechanism we invented for top-down collective decision making is government; we should use it. How does that make sense if there are just as many opposed to using it? In most countries this 'mechanism' is only relevant if a sizable majority of the electorate wants it, and there are no sufficiently motivated blocking interests.
- dylan604 4y agos/corporations/elected-officials/ key part of my comment
- anonuser123456 4y ago>There is no plausible mechanism for individuals to steer this based on their own consumption. Pigouvian taxes do just this. All you have to do is price carbon at the cost of removing it from the atmosphere and watch substitution effects take effect.
- xupybd 4y agoIsn't that the point? That the government needs to act.
- slily 4y agoHow do you know that making necessities (energy, food, transportation) more expensive will not cause more harm than the effects of climate change, especially to poor people who do not have a choice anyway?
- anonuser123456 4y agoI don’t. I do know that letting government solve the problem through regulation will be massively more expensive than solving it via the market.
- Loquebantur 4y agoThis is a false dichotomy. Regulation is what needs to be done in order to shape the market in such a way it can solve the problem. "The market" does not incorporate socialized costs when left to its own devices, quite the contrary. That's what got us here in the first place.
- majormajor 4y agoIsn't that their point? Or how do you do that tax at an individual level vs a governmental one?
- Turskarama 4y agoTaxes are literally not something individuals can do.
- usrusr 4y ago“I'm not emitting, it's the entities I pay to give me stuff and services"
- qgin 4y agoI'm not saying you can't blame individuals. I'm just saying you're not going to actually solve the problem by blaming individuals. If your local utility burns coal or natural gas, there's not really any amount of shaming of the consumers that will change the carbon output of those utilities. If concrete and steel manufacturers are emitting carbon at hugely high rates, there's no amount of individual shaming of occupants of buildings made with that concrete and steel that will change that. But regulations at the governmental level to direct those industries into emitting less carbon, that has a realistic path to actually making a different.
- megablast 4y ago> There is no plausible mechanism for individuals to steer this based on their own consumption. Wrong. This is what we NEED to do. People need to change their actions. Young people are doing this already. We can't just have people driving everywhere.
- temporarara 4y agoIt would be great. But last I checked the youngsters are just about the biggest consumers I've ever seen. Anecdotal, sure, but nevertheless buying Tesla and things like that still doesn't make anyone an environmentalist. But doing real changes like buying mostly used goods (and trying to avoid buying things in the first place) makes you social outcast so I try not to be too hard on people, especially youngsters. Going with the masses is the easiest way to handle life. Thus, the changes really must be forced upon us by regulation, so that there is no shame choosing the "poor people thing". It is of utmost importance that whatever those regulations would be, you shouldn't be able to buy your way out of them. Things like a personal consuming limit for "bad thing" X that is absolute and there is no way around to buy yourself more. Dystopian, sure, and in general I'm not even a fan of big government.
- qgin 4y agoIt would be amazing if everyone decided they would make their lives intentionally harder by biking and walking and using buses in places that have been designed to be completely antagonistic to all of those activities. I've never seen that happen anywhere though. People almost always follow the default. What could happen is governments could invest in making cities walkable, bikable, transit-able by default and people would naturally follow. Even that is a big ask at this point due to extreme sprawl, but it's the only way it's going to happen.
- pixelpoet 4y agoAbout halfway there's a picture of a lady enjoying a nice open fridge :)
- makeitdouble 4y agoThis eternal tension between - being "hard" on companies to have them clean after themselves and make actual significant improvement to ecology - being "soft" on people who are not pulling their weight but also have little to no impact on the big picture It's kinda fun to see how to navigate the mixed messaging. We should basically be advocating for regular people to wholeheartedly put all the blame on corporations and pursue them to the bitter end for behaviors we as consumer should be allowed to pull off. As consumers let's be egoistic and hypocrites, with completely valid reasons this time.
- realjhol 4y agoOnly 12% of the emissions since 1750 were man made, so there's not really any significant difference we can make. https://journals.lww.com/health-physics/Fulltext/2022/02000/World_Atmospheric_CO2,_Its_14C_Specific_Activity,.2.aspx https://journals.lww.com/health-physics/Fulltext/2022/02000/...
- xupybd 4y agoWow, I've not heard about this paper. I'm surprised it hasn't made more news.
- bratbag 4y agoBecause it was ripped apart fairly quickly.
- xupybd 4y agoI would have thought that would have made some noise. I'm not saying I think it's correct. I'm saying it's shocking and I'd have thought would have at least stirred up some publicity.
- uoaei 4y agoThere's no publicity needed to contradict a paper which wasn't publicized in the first place.
- thriftwy 4y agoHow is that L1 solar shade coming along? > In a decade or two, most of world's electorate, in terms of energy production and manufacturing capacity, will be people from China, India, Bangladesh, Indonesia, Brazil and the like. Iran, Uzbekistan and Tunisia. Maybe Nigeria or Congo. We will have to start climate change debate afresh because post-Christian flagellation is starting on a seriously wrong foot when talking to these people (to whom I am not a complete stranger). The audience who is now receptive to climate change talks (First World middle class) will be largely irrelevant by then. So, get a better plan, get a durable and realistic solution and quote a price. No CO² pipelines, please.
- syngrog66 4y agoI'm trying to be constructive rather than panicking, because I do think both global climate/ecosystems and US/Western democracy are in dire urgent danger. That we face a likely dystopic future (not unlike Mad Max or Idiocracy), related to both. Unless and until we can come together and make much bigger changes and fixes than we've deployed so far... I was fortunate to do some work in the past related to countering democracy-poisoning propaganda at scale (for the US State Department.) Propaganda and chaos-sowing tactics which have been routinely deployed by Putin's Russia, in particular (then adopted, laundered and tuned by the GOP.) And lately I've put time into building a new game/sim [SB: see below] intended to both entertain and educate on these topics (on climate & democracy threats.) To ideally influence and provide further nudges to act. Because like most of us I cannot simply wave a wand and unilaterally fix the carbon climate crisis. Yet I cannot sit by, saying and doing nothing. The stress and sheer cognitive dissonance would be slowly self-crippling. But I can try to help alert, inform, persuade and motivate others to take action and make better choices too. ---- [SB] - https://synystrongames.itch.io/slartboz https://synystrongames.itch.io/slartboz
- aeternum 4y agoTemperature rise actually impacts humans overall in a positive way since more humans die on average from cold temperatures vs. hot. edit: I see people don't believe this which is surprising since it is overwhelmingly true, like not even close: https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2015/05/150520193831.htm https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2015/05/150520193831.h...
- megablast 4y ago[flagged]
- aeternum 4y agoWhat is the more complex view?
- antisthenes 4y agoThe complex view is that more humans die from cold than heat until they don't, and more start dying from heat than cold. And that people also die of starvation, cancers from fossil fuel extraction and a plethora of other things.
- brucethemoose2 4y agoI believe it... But it is not relevant. The consequence of global warming is not a uniform temperature rise, and not limited to an average temperature rise that may help people in cold climates.
- aeternum 4y agoYet the article focuses entirely on temp rise and is somehow considered relevant? Let's be honest: Global warming/climate change will likely save human lives in the short term but could be quite bad in the long term if left unchecked. That however cannot be stated.
- 4y ago
- gmuslera 4y agoThat "temperature" is not your usual daily temperature. It is about global yearly average temperature. The way it manifest in the day after day lives is that the global weather system have more energy for i.e. powering extreme weather events. So what you will get extremer cold, heatwaves, cyclones, droughts, rains and so on. And our civilization is built upon more or less mild and predictable weather. That kinds of events will compromise agricultural productions, make from cities to smaller settlements risky to live on, disrupt supply chains, air/sea travel, and so on. We are having right now a small hint on how destructive this kind of change, and it only will get worse from now on. Another thing that will do that in a slower way is to raise enough average temperatures to trigger tipping points and activate or make stronger positive feedback loops that will make global average temperature to rise even more, so it won't be the end of the change. The 1.5ºC mark by the end of the century was to avoid reaching those thresholds or slow down the process as much as possible, but if we reach that mark this decade I don't think things will hold below 2ºC by 2050, much less 2100.
- jakear 4y ago[flagged]
- uoaei 4y agoIs this sarcasm/jest? If so it's based on a gravely flawed understanding of thermodynamics and definitely doesn't make the point you think it makes.
- jakear 4y agoExplain what about thermodynamics allows for a closed system to progress forward in time without increasing disorder please. Or are you proposing we export the disorder to outer-space? If so that’s a plan I’d love to hear.
- uoaei 4y agoThere's a very large difference and lots of possible expressible dynamics between "no entropy increase" and "lots of entropy increase". Keep showing us how little you know about the topics on which you comment. PS the Earth is not a closed system either. The incident sunlight is the only thing that keeps the Earth warm at the macro scale, and energy radiates back out mostly in the infrared range. The amount of greenhouse gases can differ and the global temperature will differ as a result.
- aaron695 4y ago[dead]
- brucethemoose2 4y agoI can't believe how much denial is still in every climate change internet thread I see. People will pull out one paper or one interesting theory and act like that totally negates the enormous majority of conservative scientific literature, going back decades, telling us its literally an ongoing disaster. And possibly a very large disaster if something trips. And its not an acceptable amount of internet noise... It feels like 30-40%. And it seems much higher than the past.
- tenpies 4y agoI think there's three reasons: 1. Anyone old enough, remembers that Florida and New York are suppose to be under water now. Going outside should be hazardous, requiring that I cover every inch of my body or be instantly burned by the sun. My incredibly "green" 5th grade teacher told me that by about 20 years ago, water would be so scarce that we would all wash our bodies with wash cloths instead of showers. 2. It's undeniable that there is a natural component to climate change. You literally would have to be anti-science to ignore what we know about climate change throughout the planet's history, and even just within the Holocene.[1] You'd have to be a science denialist to ignore the non-human factors of climate change: solar acvitiy (which we cannot model), volcanic eruption (which we cannot stop), and sometimes we aren't even sure what caused drastic climate changes. 3. Climate change is the only constant. We know that even if there are no human emissions the climate does change drastically from little ice ages, to warming periods, all within a single human lifespan. Our current focus seems to be in denial of this. Instead of accepting that this is a natural process that we must prepare for, we seem to be hyper-focused on what can be described as real-time terraforming. What I've had most luck with is being more accurate. Instead of "humans are causing climate change", use "climate change is a natural process, but human activity seems to be destabilizing it and making it more extreme". Don't use average temperature like this article did, because most people think a constant +2 degrees year-round. It's all about volatility: a winter that's 10 degrees colder, followed by a summer that's 14 degrees warmer. From then though, it becomes a bit harder because you're in the policy side of things. The UN SDG and WEF are honestly not helping anyone with their messaging. The focus should be on things like building resilient food supply chains so that food can be plentiful an affordable, even when natural disasters hit. Everyone would be in favour of that. Instead we get a moronic "Meat will be a special treat", and by the way "you will own nothing and be happy".[2] Good luck with anyone but a Davos Elite being on board for that. --- [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_periods_and_events_in_climate_history#Holocene https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_periods_and_events_in_... [2] https://twitter.com/wef/status/983378870819794945 https://twitter.com/wef/status/983378870819794945