3 ms·
It's a little cooked. The OMAP4430 is a latest-and-greatest SoC design. The Atom N270 was released 4 years ago, for goodness sake. It's true that there's a h
by ajross 15y ago
It's a little cooked. The OMAP4430 is a latest-and-greatest SoC design. The Atom N270 was released 4 years ago, for goodness sake.
It's true that there's a hole in the Atom line right now -- Medfield would be the best comparison, and it's not in the market yet. Cedar Trail (also not quite released) is a higher power part than the N270, but should honestly wipe the floor with the OMAP.
That's not to say that ARM hasn't come a long way over the past half decade. They clearly have, and are getting to the point where there almost at parity with Intel's SoC offerings. But this comparison isn't really fair.
- hackermom 15y agoThis isn't just about computational performance. It's just as much about power consumption. Diamondville sits at about 2.5 watts per core, while the A9 sits at under 300 mW per core, totalling to some orders of magnitude better performance per watt. Should we say that the comparison is unfair because of this as well? We could maintain that stance up until the point where we compare two CPUs with identical processing power and power consumption, but somehow that would defeat the purpose of comparing at all. And for the record, they could just as well have brought the Pineview and Cedar Trail cores into the picture, as fresh as the A9, which might've been more "fair", but very little still would've changed in computational performance. These tests are really about showing exactly how much you can get out of under a watt of power when opting out of x86.
- ajross 15y agoSure, there are apples/oranges problems all over the place in this comparison. But you completely missed my point. I'm saying that comparing TI's flagship SoC product with a 4-year old CPU that is three (soon to be four in a month or two) process nodes behind Intel's state of the art and claiming it is somehow representative of "ARM" vs. "Atom" is straight up crazy. How would you like it if Phoronix decided to show off a Medfield vs. ARM11, which are separated by roughtly the same amount of engineering time?
- hackermom 15y agoNo I got your point exactly. But Diamondville, Pineview et al. represents the current available state of the art in mobile x86 cores from Intel. Medfield isn't released yet, but when it shows up I would be pleased seeing it pitted against the state of the art ARM cores.
- nextparadigms 15y agoIntel hasn't improved performance of Atom all that much in the past 4 years. They've been mostly working on lowering TDP, while in the same time ARM tried to maintain their very low TDP, while increasing performance. Either way, these are still underclocked Cortex A9 CPU's. By the time Intel Atom hits the market in a phone or tablet, it will compete with same clock dual core or quad core Cortex A9, dual core Krait chips, and possibly even dual core Cortex A15 chips by summer. There's no way Intel will remain competitive - not even in performance, let alone power consumption and price.
- ajross 15y agoI'm with you up until the last sentence, where you veer off into fantasy land. When will the ARM competitor to a 4-core 3.7GHz Sandy Bridge arrive? :) [edit, rather than needlessly extend a fanboi thread: the comparison with SB certainly is relevant to your statement "There's no way Intel will remain competitive - not even in performance", which was laughably wrong. Intel won't be losing the lead in performance any time this decade, I assure you.] Look, this is all just fine. ARM has made some amazing progress in the last five years, and they are to be commended. But the cheerleading has gotten out of hand. Intel's death has been predicted so many times over the years that it's become a running gag in the industry. ARM Ltd. is just the latest competitor to show some spunk. Will they succeed where Motorola, MIPS, DEC, and AMD failed? ... Maybe! But I'm not putting a lot of money on it. And I'm certainly not changing my opinion based on a comparison between a brand new Pandaboard/GNexus and a so-old-it-smells-bad netbook. [1] 68000, then R2000, then Alpha, then the K6/Athlon/Athlon64 -- every one of those designs was going to "kill Intel" according to "serious people in the Industry" -- check the Google groups archives for all the fun flame wars.