8 ms·
When will global warming hit the landmark 1.5 ºC limit?
- sillywalk 4y agoFaster than expected.
- gibsonf1 4y agoOr never
- vkou 4y agoWe're currently at 1.2C, and almost every new year, we emit more carbon than we have in any other year in human history.
- oezi 4y agoThe developed countries have made tremendous strides to reduce CO2 while continuing to grow. China is also investing heavily in reducing their dependency on fossil imports.
- leesalminen 4y ago> China is also investing heavily in reducing their dependency on fossil imports. Sure they want to import less LNG because of increased cost and unstable geopolitics. But they are continuing to build huge amounts of new coal plants (which is largely domestically sourced).
- gary_0 4y agoIf I'm reading these charts right, it's more CO2 per year than at any point on the geological record.
- netjiro 4y agoiirc: we are changing atmospheric CO2 many times faster than the PT Extinction! ... quick search [1] [1] https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-021-22298-7 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-021-22298-7
- waboremo 4y agoWhat's the purpose of denying recorded averages[1]? It's a given 1.5 will happen, as none of the drastic measures have been acted on and most goals have not been hit. [1] https://www.climate.gov/news-features/understanding-climate/climate-change-global-temperature https://www.climate.gov/news-features/understanding-climate/...
- revelio 4y agoDenying recorded averages in this case is unfortunately very reasonable, because temperature graphs don't show recorded averages. That is a common misconception that governments are happy to encourage. Modern temperature graphs are the output of models. The raw data isn't reported. This results in strange artifacts like record breaking temperatures that later become un-record breaking due to revision of historical values. In fact, the "recorded" temperature for every month in history changes every month: https://retractionwatch.com/2021/08/16/will-the-real-hottest-month-on-record-please-stand-up/ https://retractionwatch.com/2021/08/16/will-the-real-hottest... NOAAGlobalTempv5 is a reconstructed dataset, meaning that the entire period of record is recalculated each month with new data. Based on those new calculations, the new historical data can bring about updates to previously reported values.
- gibsonf1 4y agoI think the track record of climate predictions using Co2 etc have been all wrong, so a reasonable person would assume that the chance of additional predictions being wrong is quite high. Additionally, the actual science (by objective scientists) demonstrating human generated cO2 having any impact on global temperature has not been found, and arguably, the theory not behaving in the way the promoters of it have predicted over the last decade with all the models being wrong is quite good evidence for the theory not being true. Its hyper political actually, so a good question for this would be why? Similar things happened with the science of Covid, it also went political, and again, why?
- beardyw 4y agoReminds me of Stephen Leacock's A B and C. C is on his deathbed. "A," whispered C, "I think I'm going fast." "How fast do you think you'll go, old man?" murmured A. Whole thing here https://www.online-literature.com/stephen-leacock/literary-lapses/40/ https://www.online-literature.com/stephen-leacock/literary-l...
- oezi 4y agoWe have the power to change it. It is estimated to cost between 2-6% of global GDP each year until 2050 to prevent exceeding 1.5 C. Costly, but not insanely so. We spend more on quite a lot of things.
- Smoosh 4y ago"Gradually and then suddenly."
- jeffbee 4y agoIt's not a "limit" of course. It's like asking when, if I put the car in gear and stand on the gas, will I go crashing through the back wall of the garage? You can figure it out but it doesn't really matter. Recent research suggests that if we stop emitting CO2 right now, the earth could continue warming to a peak of +10ºC over centuries. https://theclimatebrink.substack.com/p/warming-in-the-pipeline-decoding https://theclimatebrink.substack.com/p/warming-in-the-pipeli...
- willtheperson 4y agoA bit pessimistic though right? Carbon capture through both natural and engineered methods is a thing that could have more investment/incentive if that were the case which counters the idea that just because CO2 hangs around a long time doesn't mean there's nothing to be done about it. Obviously, it'd be great to limit the production of more CO2 going forward but I don't believe that everyone will collectively just give up.
- yieldcrv 4y agoNot to be defeatist but the solutions have byproducts that are just as counterproductive to our goals
- piyh 4y agoIt's a hell of a carbon loan to take out against future generations.
- c0nfused 4y agoWe need to stop burning fossil fuels. Full stop. Hitting the 2100 target 70 years early should be a wake up call to us all. I see little evidence we will even attempt to cut our output and less that we will pay money to solve this issue before we have global disaster.
- baggy_trough 4y agoThat just simply isn't going to happen. Next plan?
- adictator 4y ago[dead]
- LatteLazy 4y agoIt's important thet we know when to stop pretending we will try and prevent 1.5C and move on to pretending we will try and stop 2.0C...
- hikawaii 4y agoWe are trying! Cars get ever more fuel efficient, there's more investment in public transit than ever, Britain is interested in nuclearizing again, carbon offsets are widely purchased and many of our most energy hungry companies are finding ways to go to less or zero emissions. Continuous carastrophization and disrespect for things people actually are working quite hard at doing, with implicit blame for "those other guys" to boot is how you make people try less. Large efforts to transform the economy are quite difficult and take a long time. Transitioning away from fossil fuels entirely may be the single most complex international effort ever attempted. You can say that all the bad guys at oil companies want more cars and more profits - but the reason they are so profitable is that energy consumption is directly related to quality of life, and until 10 or 20 years ago - fossil fuels were the way to get it.
- LatteLazy 4y agoWe've spent 40 years congratulating ourselves on having done nothing, and it's not worked so far, but anyone who points that out is engaged in catastrophization...
- brutusborn 3y agoI dunno about you, but the billions of dollars spent on renewables in my country don’t suggest ‘nothing’ is being done. And emissions in the west are slowing down. I’d say we’re almost there!
- Gigachad 4y agoCars got more efficient, so everyone went and bought larger cars. Carbon offsets are largely a scam which could have a worse than useless effect when people believe they are actually real.
- tromp 4y agoAnd when we hit 1.5C, will we already be on an irreversible course to 2C?
- ke88y 4y agoWe are already on an irreversible course to 2C.
- wfhBrian 4y agoApple TV's "Extrapolations" is an interesting dramatization of this. Highly recommended.
- andybee 4y agoI don't think we need more "dramatizations" on this topic but rather realistic and pragmatic analysis and solutions. Frankly, while facing this just watching a show to pat yourself on the back as being part of the solution, isn't really appealing.
- ConfusedDog 4y agoFTC could try to raise interest rates again see if that would lower the global temperature.
- yieldcrv 4y agoFRB, or just “Fed”
- wonderwonder 4y agoIt's all so tiresome. When German leaders went online to celebrate turning off their last nuclear plant and instead turned on more coal I learned it was all theater by woke fools. They are not fools because they are woke but just because they are foolish. The dutch seizing farms in the name of global warming. Where are they going to get food from? Ukraine? China? Giving power to foreign possibly enemy nations like they did with Russia. It's all political theater that will weaken the west and do nothing to accomplish it's goals. Africa and Asia are going to want the same standard of living as the west so carbon use is only going to go up. You don't intentionally cripple industries in your country in the face of global competition.
- flandish 4y agoIt really sends home the concept behind the phrase, “ain’t no war but class war.” This “ruling” class just does the theater to keep us in the, sometimes actual, dark.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- anononaut 4y agoIt's like shouting in the darkness, isn't it? Don't become discouraged, though.
- londons_explore 4y agoI see only two solutions: * A global carbon tax/cap/trading/limit system, with sanctions for any country that does not comply. * A realistic risk that a global compulsory carbon cap/tax/trading system will be implemented, and that any carbon emissions tracking will be backdated - such that any extra emissions today might disadvantage your country in the future. With neither of the above two, it is in every countries best interests to emit as much carbon as possible and use free/cheap carbon based energy to produce goods/food/whatever, while doing only a few highly visible environmental moves.
- 4y ago
- melling 4y agoI don’t think attitudes towards addressing climate change have changed much. This was 8 years ago. https://youtu.be/3E0a_60PMR8 https://youtu.be/3E0a_60PMR8
- luis_cho 4y agoDoes anyone here knows what is the temperature value that we are comparing to? I cannot find that anywhere.
- explaininjs 4y ago[flagged]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- dymk 4y ago> The 1.5 ºC number was chosen in an attempt to limit the severity of the impacts of warming, taking into account factors such as food security and extreme weather events.
- explaininjs 4y ago[flagged]
- BobbyJo 4y agoIf by made up you mean a chosen measured timeframe[1], sure. [1]https://climatepositions.com/global-warming-pre-industrial-temperature-baselines-measurements-and-the-2c-limit/ https://climatepositions.com/global-warming-pre-industrial-t...
- explaininjs 4y agoArbitrarily selected with little to no scientific basis. Check the siblings, it was some random “scientist” that pulled a number out of who knows where, under the consideration “politicians like limits and people tend to go over speed limits, so I said 1.5”. There’s no science to it, just fear mongering and grant seeking. When this happens in any other “scientific” field HN is quick to jump on it, but when it comes to climate change we love to toe the party line.
- egberts1 4y agoLet us ignore the 14,200 new temperature reading weather stations installed within United States since 1975. Have fun doing a running means, medians, and average year-over-year as your N-sample increases without regard to urban versus rural settings. This eliminating of cluster bias because of this hyper-focusing of added but coalesced sampling has got to be nothing but challenging.
- gred 4y agoAre there any environmentalist schools of thought which accept human nature for what it is, make pessimistic (realistic?) assumptions about the (un)likelihood of global coordination on this topic, and use that as a starting point for research, modeling and recommendations? So much of what makes its way into politics and mainstream media on this topic seems to be naive pipe dreams, mindless posturing, or political opportunism. The scientists seem to often make the same mistake.
- jules-jules 4y agoThis might be interesting for you https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4CVe8-eKSK8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4CVe8-eKSK8
- karmakurtisaani 4y agoI suppose many of the institutions responsible for national security are making worst-case analyses all over the world. Of course that research wouldn't be public. As for the "naive pipe dreams" as you put it, I suppose being more pessimistic will soon lead you being labelled as a doomer and ignored. There is some material though, like Uninhabitable Earth by David Wallace-Wells. It's a depressing read.
- gred 4y agoThanks for the reference. I watched some of his Joe Rogan episode to get a sense of his thesis, and it sounds like he's hoping for either litigation or a popular opinion shift to open the door to government intervention (taxes or policy) which significantly alters the incentives around emissions. He seems to mix realism (acknowledging that there are probably deeper desires at play, not just societal or governmental conventions) and wishful thinking (government policy as climate deus ex machina, countries imposing their climate agendas on other countries via war within 30 years). I suppose I belong to what he calls the "invent our way out of it" school of thought... also possibly very naive!
- revelio 4y agoThe people who are attracted to geo-engineering are probably the closest fit for what you want. You can argue that geo-engineering still requires global coordination. The types you ask for are quite rare. If you accept human nature for what it is, you have to admit the possibility that claims are being exaggerated for political opportunism, fame, grant money, clicks ... and due to the huge cost of all proposed solutions, you'd want to double check. But if you ever double check any of this stuff you're doomed because environmental research is so riven with fraud. You end up a skeptic and be immediately excluded from politics, media, and academia. That's why you can't find many of that school of thought.
- goldforever 4y ago[dead]