4 ms·
Can't you buy your own cable modem and use that?
by JohnFen 4y ago
Can't you buy your own cable modem and use that?
- Filligree 4y agoI keep seeing references to this from Americans, but is this actually a thing? There’s no way my ISP would allow me to connect a device that isn’t owned by them.
- zwieback 4y agoYes, you can go to an office supply store and pick one up, use a webpage or phone call to hook it up to your ISP, generally.
- karaterobot 4y agoDefinitely! Comcast charges $5-10 a month to rent a cable modem, so buying your own pays off pretty quick.
- Filligree 4y agoThey do what now? I've never heard of an ISP charging for their own equipment.
- JohnFen 4y agoYes, they do. Further, my experience with Comcast specifically is that every three months, they "forget" that I don't rent a modem from them and just start charging me the rental fee anyway. Then I have to call them up to tell them to remove the charges and stop adding new ones.
- karaterobot 4y agoWhen Americans complain about Comcast, it's not a meme, they are actually an awful company. But for the record: If you just sign up for Comcast (XFinity, whatever) and use the internet, you are renting a modem/router combo from them for about $10 a month, in perpetuity. You can buy an off the shelf modem/router for a couple hundred bucks, and use that instead. It'll pay off in a year or two. You have to call Comcast up and activate the device, but it's otherwise a completely painless process.
- dazilcher 4y agoYou can use the Xfinity mobile app to activate your own modem. No call required (anymore).
- JohnFen 4y agoIs this just a US thing? Not only can you do it in the US, but the cable company will give you clear instructions on how to get it set up and running on their system. And it's a good idea. Not only to avoid paying the modem rental fee, but also because the modem provided by cable companies tends to be pretty awful.
- the_mitsuhiko 4y agoHere you don’t pay a fee for the modem but they don’t let you run your own. Among other reasons because they want to force retire unsupported frequencies.
- Filligree 4y agoI don't know about "just US", but I've never seen an EU country where it'd be either sensible or allowed.
- detaro 4y agoIt's allowed here in Germany. And EU rules demand it, but some countries left loopholes in their implementation.
- p_l 4y agoEU rules do not necessarily demand it - it depends on how exactly things are structured logically. They do demand that what you connect to termination point of ISP network is your decision, but that termination point can be a cable modem for example.
- coretx 4y agoIf you can pull/transfer the certificates from the provided modem and can clone the MAC's to your own modem it should just work.
- SargeDebian 4y agoNo. There's even a Dutch law that requires ISPs to allow and provide basic configuration information for a customer's own modem. The cable company resisted it but ultimately published a how-to as well. https://www.ziggo.nl/klantenservice/apparaten/wifi-modems/eigen-modem https://www.ziggo.nl/klantenservice/apparaten/wifi-modems/ei...
- LocalH 4y agoShades of pre-1968 AT&T. "Oh no, you can't connect that modem to our lines." In fact, prior to late 1956, AT&T even told people they couldn't mechanically attach a device to their phones.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- kotaKat 4y agoI at one point spent a hundred bucks and bought a used JDSU DSAM 3300 cable testing meter. It's only rated for DOCSIS 3, but I can get some good info out of it about my local cable plant and figure out if it's my side or the outside plant. Then they show up and use their shiny new Viavi (formerly JDSU) OneExpert... and see the same thing and fix their shit. ;)
- wolrah 4y ago> Can't you buy your own cable modem and use that? Unfortunately no, Armstrong did not support bringing your own modem. It could technically be done prior to DOCSIS 2.0 but it was never officially allowed. In the US providers are not required to allow users to own their modem, but they have to provide a modem for free if you can't bring your own. This is mostly fine as long as they offer a plain modem, it's when they don't offer a model without its own (almost always absolute garbage) firewall/router built in that it's a problem. IMO it shouldn't be allowed to call something "internet service" unless I have a handoff I can plug in to a firewall of my choice and have a publicly routable internet address directly on my box's WAN port
- JohnFen 4y ago> it's when they don't offer a model without its own (almost always absolute garbage) firewall/router built in that it's a problem. That is a problem, but you can work around all of that. All of the ones I've seen have allowed you to just turn that stuff off, but even if you can't, you can approximate it by setting router rules that just forward everything to your real router.
- wolrah 4y ago> All of the ones I've seen have allowed you to just turn that stuff off, but even if you can't, you can approximate it by setting router rules that just forward everything to your real router. The BGW320 gateway that AT&T provides with its 2g/2g and 5g/5g fiber services has a NAT table limited to 8192 tracked connections. Let me repeat that, a 5 gigabit symmetrical XGPON service has a NAT table that makes a 2004-era garbage tier device look good by comparison. It does not support a bridge mode, only "IP Passthrough" or the standard default NAT "DMZ" mode commonly seen on consumer hardware. Both of those rely on the tiny NAT table, so anyone who wants to establish more than 8192 connections at one time has to get a routed block of static IPs that allows the NAT to be entirely bypassed. At least officially, for now there's also a method to clone your ONT identifiers on to one that works as a plain bridge, which I have the parts for but haven't installed it yet. Their high speed DSL "U-Verse" services have a similar issue with a bad mandatory device, those require a complicated bypass involving passing through 802.1x packets to the provided router so it can authenticate while you then use your own to actually send/receive internet traffic.