5 ms·
> The thing that was very confusing to me as an immigrant was that liberal type of racism,” she says. “People who sound like they really care about you, but the
by rayiner 3y ago
> The thing that was very confusing to me as an immigrant was that liberal type of racism,” she says. “People who sound like they really care about you, but they’d be like: ‘Don’t you think it’s going to be hard for you?’
This is why I object to teaching kids about racism in schools. Maybe the teacher was racist. Or maybe she got good grades—which isn’t hard to do in American high schools—but her teachers didn’t think she was one of the exceptional kids who could go on to excel in the field as a career. If you aren’t socialized to think of yourself as the target of racism, the natural response is to probe further. “But my grades are good!” The explanation that comes next might lead to learning and growth, or at least renewed motivation (“I’ll show him!”) But if a kid has been socialized to perceive such interactions in terms of racism, there are, they can’t learn from such conversations. After all it’s pointless arguing with a racist, nor can you learn anything valuable about yourself from a racist.
I moved to Virginia from Bangladesh back in the 1980s, to a school and neighborhood that was nearly 100% white. At the time, northern Virginia where we were was solidly Republican. But my parents never taught me about “racism” and it was a tremendous blessing. I never wondered whether the ordinary negative interactions of life were racially motivated. Was that kid being a bully because I was brown, or because I was a book worm? What good would it have done me to recognize it anyway?
I’m extremely worried about how the discourse is going to affect my kids. It’s impossible to protect your kids these days from folks like Gebru.
- prepend 3y ago> ‘Don’t you think it’s going to be hard for you‘ I found this curious when reading the article and expected more context as to why this was racist. Why did Gebru consider this was due to her race or immigrant status? I got this comment through my whole life too even though I don’t share Gebru’s background or demographic factors. Were my teachers racist? Or were they concerned? Or was the subject just really hard? Or were they classist against my poverty? It seems more info is needed and attributing this to racism (or sexism or xenophobia) seems like an unsupported conclusion. Although it seems Gebru felt it was racist and significant enough to mention in the background for this article. I think this is what makes measuring micro aggressions so difficult. It’s rare to confirm the intent of the person who did something that is perceived as micro aggressions but the recipient feels and infers an intent. I don’t know how to fix this but I want to. I remember once remarking to a coworker that they had a nice car. It was a new 7-series and looked really nice. I thought nothing of it as it was just small talk and I frequently make such small comments to note something positive. A few months later we were having a large zoom call after the George Floyd murder where people were recounting persistent and systematic racism. My coworker shared an example of what he called everyday racism when someone said he had a nice car and he assumed it was because he was black and couldn’t afford such a nice car. He seemed really hurt and spoke for 5 minutes about it and how he worked really hard to afford the car and his spouse had a high income as well. He didn’t name me as the person who made the comment but it sounded like my small comment. I was so confused as to how all that could be inferred from “nice car.” I don’t know him well enough to ask about it and clear it up. I felt bad he was hurt, even though I just intended it as a small comment recognizing a nice car from a coworker and would have made the comment regardless of his race. So I don’t think I did anything wrong but still feel bad. And there’s no way I could predict such a response. I don’t compliment coworkers cars any longer.
- netsharc 3y ago> I don’t compliment coworkers cars any longer. It's unfortunate, but for you to feel guilty and to stop this seems unreasonable. There are myriad of traps I can imagine you'd be afraid of falling into. Like, "Oh I want lunch and I fancy some fried chicken. Oh wait if I invite [black colleague] will they be offended at the suggestion to go for that food?" Communication goes through filters, as this cheap graphic shows, and I don't think it's something you can fix on your side: https://external-content.duckduckgo.com/iu/?u=https%3A%2F%2Fimage.slidesharecdn.com%2Fcommunicationfilters-090401235329-phpapp02%2F95%2Fcommunication-filters-2-728.jpg%3Fcb%3D1238630053&f=1&nofb=1&ipt=5858b72f911f4f2505f2dc3884f900f0fbcdd76329822bd9904ff950d673657d&ipo=images https://external-content.duckduckgo.com/iu/?u=https%3A%2F%2F...
- prepend 3y agoTo clarify, I don’t feel guilty over my actions and didn’t stop complimenting out of virtue. I stopped to not cause potential harm, or even worse, to be labeled a racist and all the time they would take. I also never suggest friend chicken for lunch. I love fried chicken. I make a pretty good friend chicken. I’m just too timid and over leveraged to risk having it perceived incorrectly.
- david38 3y agoWow. Totally wrong lesson learned. Go refresh yourself to some hardcore problems and then replay your situation again. A more standard response may be: “oh that was me. Your car is better than mine. Sometimes you know, a compliment is just a compliment.” I’m currently reading Hunting Eichmann. Really nasty stuff that went down, as many know. A very strong reminder that so many of these first-world problems, micro-aggressions, sympathy-seeking woe-is-me public sob stories are just crap. Seriously?? He felt bad from a complement about his car??
- lisasays 3y agoSo I don’t think I did anything wrong but still feel bad. And there’s no way I could predict such a response. I feel bad for both of you. This anecdote seems to capture everything wrong with the current climate of discussion on these topics in the US right now.