4 ms·
> just using excel because it won’t change on them. Are your accounting people quite young? Excel moves and changes stuff, though not on quite such an aggressi
by tialaramex 3y ago
> just using excel because it won’t change on them.
Are your accounting people quite young? Excel moves and changes stuff, though not on quite such an aggressive timeline. Modern Office is not like 1990s Office where you buy it and then it doesn't change unless you decide to change it.
This is fine, the universe's one constant is change, if we fight it we'll lose, but it's worth calling out that there will be change, just some of these outfits are taking the piss.
- rvba 3y agoMany companies have tons of desginers who need to prove they are needed, so they force change for the sake of change - at the cost of users.
- andai 3y agoIt might be like the thing at Google, where people want to get promoted and big changes or new launches are the only way up, regardless of the effect on user experience.
- Projectiboga 3y agoWith M$ the bias is towards their certification and training business. They have to change enough to make training seem more important.
- Spooky23 3y agoThat’s just one leg of the stool. They used to be relentless at driving SQL Server Enterprise adoption. Now it’s shifted to M365 E5, plus accessory subscriptions. PowerBI, Viva and Copilot for whatever are the new legs.
- nordsieck 3y ago> Many companies have tons of desginers who need to prove they are needed, so they force change for the sake of change - at the cost of users. That may be one part. But another part is companies that need to demonstrate to their uses that a version change is a big change. Microsoft is (im)famous for this: as far as I can tell, there has been little need for the constant UI churn in windows aside from convincing users that a new version is big enough to warrant that appellation (as opposed to a service pack/patch).
- bombcar 3y agoYou’d think that the SaaS Office would change less, but it seems to churn about as much as ever.
- waboremo 3y agoDesigners alone can't push through a change for the sake of change as their work relies entirely on user research. Even if they do have the research needed to prove a change is required, they also have to get developers on board. So I don't know where this conspiracy theory comes from, but it's entirely unfounded unless you're talking about a designer like Jony Ive with the power to go through multiple obstacles with ease, in which case the change isn't happening to prove he's needed but because he has a different vision.
- mLuby 3y ago> as their work relies entirely on user research Definitely not the case everywhere.
- waboremo 3y agoIt's the case everywhere. A designer (in the context of software/hardware) does not work without user research, that is core to their work. Any position that does not require user research in design is titled differently these days.
- patmorgan23 3y agoUnless the designers end up becoming the product managers/owners and stop scrutinizing the designers.
- shlubbert 3y agoOf course no engineers would ever make bad UX decisions.
- layer8 3y agoThey’re probably older, on the contrary, and are still using the non-subscription desktop version instead of Microsoft 365.
- drumhead 3y agoYes, everyone seems to be stuck on 2010.
- SoftTalker 3y agoI'm older. I still haven't gotten over the "ribbon" interface. It drove me to LibreOffice despite all its faults.
- jimnotgym 3y agoAre you a professional accountant? EDIT: rather than downvoting, maybe you could engage? Following the thread back the question was about accountants using Excel and then someone weighed in that they use Libre/open office. I have never seen an accountant use libre office for accounts work, hence my question. Are you an accountant who moved from Excel because of whatever, or was your comment irrelevant?
- emeril 3y agoI'm sure he's not, I am one and I have to use excel though I also hate the ribbon but I just use excel 2010 + ubitmenu and will continue to use that version or similar until I can't anymore I had used excel 2003 until I was forced to use win 10 at which point it barely functioned anymore (i.e., it worked great in win 7) I still miss excel 2003, it has been downhill from there As for accounting software, they all mostly stink though serve a purpose in larger companies where you need some degree of separation of duties to reduce (at least in appearance as much internal control is theatre) error/theft risk...
- SoftTalker 3y agoI'm not, and I'm sure if I had to use Excel every day I would adapt. But both Windows and Office reached their peak at around 2003 and it's been downhill ever since. I quite liked Windows 2000 Pro as a desktop.
- eitland 3y agoIt is already many years ago since that I started to do certain jobs in Libre Office (back then it was still OpenOffice.org) even if I had MS Office. I mean, it was better at certain tasks and costed nothing. In all fairness, back them I also had to use MS Office for certain other tasks, but luckily I don't need that anymore. Now there is Confluence instead however to mangle our docs and waste our time.
- eropple 3y agoExcel is distinctly different from the rest of Office for a power user because while you're right that they've reorganized things (though only one real reorganization since at least Office 95, that's pretty good), the keyboard shortcuts have remained the same for literally my entire life. It's why Excel is nonstandard and weird compared to even other Office apps: Excel is the most this-is-for-work tool in Office, and they've been loath to break things for people like...well...me. And I don't hate the ribbon interface, I think it's totally fine--but also, in Excel specifically, I almost never click a button on it. QuickBooks's online version, on the other hand, has terrible discoverability and doesn't have standard keyboard controls.
- c5karl 3y agoThose keyboard shortcuts (the ones that begin with a slash, at least) date back to Lotus 123.
- rhaway84773 3y agoThe Excel UI has changed once significantly in the past 2 decades with the addition of the Ribbon. The Excel data format has changed once, significantly, in the past 2 decades (which was forced on MS and even though MS has tried to sabotage the openness of the new formats they were required to create, its still much better than the predecessors). It’s hard to think of any other change that wasn’t just an addition (new formulas, higher column/row limits).
- kjs3 3y agoThe Excel data format has changed once, significantly, in the past 2 decades But, importantly, that data format change didn't mean you were forced to stop using the old format.
- kpw94 3y ago> Are your accounting people quite young? Excel moves and changes stuff, though not on quite such an aggressive timeline. Excel UI interface changes but it won't change your spreadsheet content, which is the core functionality Excel users care about. I've been using 15 year old .xlsx files with no issues across Excel 2007, to 2021, and Excel online. I've seen companies using files with an absurd amount of worksheets within the file, or with an absurd number of rows (up to the limit), and those haven't been broken. And I don't remember transitioning from xls to xlsx to be that painful, but this might be untrue for people using some very specific features.
- drumhead 3y agoNot at the same speed as SaaS software. Jira seems to change every five minutes.
- bobse 3y agoI use LibreOffice bacause you know what Microsoft.
- jimnotgym 3y agoAre you a professional accountant?
- Spooky23 3y agoThe chrome of Excel changes. The core product is COBOL like in its stability. The problem with all of these enterprise web applications is that they all suck. I worked for a big government agency that transitioned from a mostly homegrown, mainframe 3270 based accounting system to PeopleSoft. The staff revolted. We joked about the “Revenge of the Beancounters”, but looking at it, they were right. It took them 4-6 months to train a new person with the old system, but they were hyper-productive. With the new system, they actually needed to grow the staff because you couldn’t build out workflows that the business needed. They did get some benefits, like improved payments and invoice tracking. (Which drove the business case) But the general financial operations suffered.