3 ms·
> LassPass, hacked in 2022; remote storage of raw passwords I know that it's been one dumpster fire after the other in the past few years, but did they actuall
by lxgr 4y ago
> LassPass, hacked in 2022; remote storage of raw passwords
I know that it's been one dumpster fire after the other in the past few years, but did they actually go as far? The most severe one I remember hearing of was a leak of (possibly insufficiently salted, depending on the age of the account) encrypted password vaults. Still, I'll never again consider or recommend them going forward.
> In pwsafe, unbroken TwoFish algorithm is still being used instead of currently safer Argon2i
This is actually a negative point for it, in my view. AES is just as unbroken, yet has received considerably more scrutiny over the years.
The only place were non-AES symmetric algorithms still make sense these days is platforms where hardware acceleration is not available (e.g. djb's Salsa/Chacha), and even there only for high-throughput applications, which a password safe decidedly isn't.
> The recommended client-wise of PasswordSafe is still Netwrix (formerly MATESO of Germany)
I've never heard of them. Is it open source or at least properly audited?
- egberts1 4y agoUpdate: This post is half-wrong; Salsa is a streaming cipher and AES is a block cipher and one still need a PBKDF mechanism to construct a safer key. Problem with AES and Salsa is that salting is required for smaller-sized password and are not considered a "hashing" algorithm; those two are block ciphers, as I recall. No, MATESO is not open source but with an enterprise license, you can negotiate for the source code. And they have contracted audits against their software. Netwrix PasswordSafe is more enterprise-ready with their SOC 2, ISO 27001 and HIPAA compliance but that is a moot point for most SMBs, SMEs, family-servers and homelabs.
- lxgr 4y agoAES and Twofish are both block ciphers. Neither are hasing algorithms, and you'll need a PBKDF or some other construction to derive a key for either, no? Salsa is a stream cipher.
- egberts1 4y agoRight. thanks for the update. My note should have been consulted as you being correct. Hate my memory nowadays. Need to consult some more notes before speaking.
- egberts1 4y ago"AES-KDF in KeePass is only CPU hard, while Argon2 is both CPU and RAM hard. This means that AES-KDF is victim to GPUs and ASICs for fast password cracking. The memory requirements in Argon2 make GPUs and ASICs considerably more expensive to reach similar password cracking speeds." https://www.reddit.com/r/KeePass/comments/k511o6/comment/ged1gd8/ https://www.reddit.com/r/KeePass/comments/k511o6/comment/ged...