3 ms·
Only the murder itself should be illegal. If it's some kind of weird pornography, for example, then the filming and distribution of it could be illegal. If we
by 1827163 3y ago
Only the murder itself should be illegal. If it's some kind of weird pornography, for example, then the filming and distribution of it could be illegal.
If we try to prosecute whether it's viewed for pleasure or not, then we are trying to prosecute thought crimes. We are trying to prosecute someone's state of mind there.
No, just viewing someone's death does not violate privacy laws, in my opinion. But if you share the material with others, than it might be right to make that illegal, in my opinion.
We should take such material down, but nobody should ever see jail time or any form of punishment for viewing or reading anything, in a free society. Any situation otherwise is a hallmark of a police state, and it shows how far the Overton window has shifted. How much the frog has boiled over the years.
And seeing the harm caused by the War on Drugs and countless other cases of overcriminalization, it may well be we are living in a de-facto police state, and unaware of it. We've internalized and accepted loss of our fundamental liberties over the years. And this trend started roughly around 1980 or so.
- oh_sigh 3y agoSo the person who posted george Floyd's murder should be punished under your system?
- 1827163 3y agoNo, it only applies to material produced as a type of pornography, for example. I've reworded the post to make it clearer.
- zoklet-enjoyer 3y agoExactly. Cartel and ISIS style murder videos and live streams like the Christchurch and Buffalo massacres should be treated the same as child porn. The creation of those videos are crimes and the distribution and possession should be too. Videos like George Floyd and JFK are recorded by bystanders and are evidence of crimes.
- grepfru_it 3y ago…so if someone recorded the buffalo massacre as a bystander then it’s evidence and ok? Slippery slope
- zoklet-enjoyer 3y agoHow is that a slippery slope? It's dry, level ground. Did the person filming participate in the murder? Nope. They are documenting evidence of a crime.
- laratied 3y agoyea this is a terrible idea. I think of the Zapruder film.