3 ms·
Especially with low level degrees, fewer associate going to college with bettering oneself as much as meeting a checklist for a job interview or a parent's requ
by zamadatix 3y ago
Especially with low level degrees, fewer associate going to college with bettering oneself as much as meeting a checklist for a job interview or a parent's requirement for continued financial support. Many of these jobs don't inherently require being educated it's more a "well, why wouldn't we hire the person with the degree if we can" kind of situation and jobs tend to drive the family requirement more than the "fluffier" stuff about education. In these cases going to college is seen as an required obstacle by the student, not an opportunity. Any way to get out of as much of it as possible is valued more than going to learn. After all, the interest was in meeting some external requirement, not getting educated. Not to mention, for a great deal of people (by volume) getting a degree at all is an extremely difficult, if not impossible, task. Getting one and having high grades to stand out can be seen as having more reward given by society than genuinely getting a degree and having poor grades.
It's not great by any means, obviously more people interested in educating themselves is better. At the same time, it shouldn't be a mystery. It, particularly, shouldn't be something one assumes is related to a particular country/culture rather than an everywhere thing. That's not to say there won't be variance between location, rather that it's a pretty common outlook everywhere.
- lisper 3y agoAlso, the ability to appropriate someone else's work to further your own goals is actually a very useful life skill. It is arguably the foundation of capitalism.
- simonh 3y agoIn liberal economies you buy someone else’s work. In communism it is appropriated by the state. Source: I have family who grew up and lived in a non-capitalist worker’s utopia.
- lisper 3y agoSure. But people pay to use GPT, and people pay to have others do their homework for them. Compensation is orthogonal to the question of whether someone else did the work.
- zdragnar 3y agoThe word "appropriate" as a verb in colloquial American English most often implies without permission or compensation. Certain domains, such as budgeting, use it as a synonym for "allocate" but given the context it was first used in your comment it definitely implied "taking without consent".
- lisper 3y agoYes, I know. The point I'm trying to make is that there is no salient difference between an employer hiring an employee to do the work and a student doing the same. Students typically do not actually steal the work that they pass off as their own, they usually pay for it. But for some reason, when a student does it it's considered underhanded whereas when an employer does it it's considered a normal business transaction.
- zamadatix 3y agoThis carries the assumption things like "school work" and "business work" are inherently fungible on the basis they are both types of work. Dropping the assumption for a moment, it seems reasonable there may be more than one goal of or type of work, and that these goals/types might not be interchangeable with each other. This view of the difference is only possible if you start with the earnest question of "what's the difference supposed to be" rather than asserting a conversation along the lines of "these are the same, so why are we treating them different". Taking this approach, many might find school work is, largely, effort done to grade a level of understanding the individual has of the content. On the other hand, one might find business work is, largely, effort done to accomplish a customer's request. Additional less common types of each may come up as well, and there are, of course, exceptions to the main theme of each. In general though, I think you'd agree swapping the goals to say "school work is effort done to grade whether someone understands the content while business work is effort done to see if the particular person you make the request to is able to complete it on their own" seems rather unlikely in comparison. Because of this, swapping who does the work in each case results in different treatments. Not because it's a question of whether work gets done rather what the goal in doing the work is.